EKEV, 1999
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Write a letter. Address it to those you love -- your spouse, your children and grandchild, your friends, your community. Put into this letter what life has taught you: What you learned from childhood, from growing up, from your education. What you learned from marriage and raising children? What have you learned from work, from your triumphs and successes in the world, from your failures and disappointments? What you have learned from the death of loved ones, and the path of mourning and grief. What has life taught you? What is the meaning, the lesson, the wisdom of your life? What is your message?
I ask you to do this for three principal reasons:
First, do it for yourself. You deserve to know what your life has meant, what it has taught. There are 5,485 verses in a Torah scroll; tens of thousands of words, more than a hundred thousand handwritten letters. According to tradition, if any one letter, in any word in any verse, is defaced or erased, the entire Torah is pasul, invalid, and may not be read. A Torah missing even the tiniest yud is set aside. Why such an obsession? A hasidic tradition teaches that each letter stands for one human soul. Each individual human being carries one letter, one byte, of God’s message into the world. Just as the loss of the tiniest letter invalidates an entire Torah scroll, losing one human being makes God’s message indecipherable. You carry part of the message. But do you know what it is? Have you discovered, decoded your part of the message? Have you delivered it?
Second, write the letter for your loved ones. As a rabbi, I frequently accompany families as they grieve. I ask them to share the stories and wisdom of their loved ones’ lives. And I’m often surprised how little they know. They can recount with precision the history of declining health, but they have no notion of the soul -- the inner life, the moral struggles, the deepest values. God forbid anything should happen to you. But shouldn’t your loved ones know what you’ve learned from life -- what secrets you’ve wrestled out of the experiences of living, what wisdom you’ve found?
Third, write the letter for your spiritual life. Our tradition begins with the commandment to Abraham, lech lecha, Go into yourself. Hearing the voice of God begins with hearing your own soul. There are many who believe that spiritual wisdom is far away -- on some mountaintop to be wrested from a master of mystery. But Torah, real spiritual truth, we are taught, is not beyond your reach. It is not in the heavens...neither is it beyond the sea...It is very close to you, in your mouth and in your heart... (Deuteronomy 30:11-14)
Write the letter. But know that it isn’t easy. For so many, the heart is more inaccessible than the heavens, more forbidding than the sea. Denial, avoidance, even distraction, keep us from listening.
Modernity has brought us many gifts. But one of the casualties of modern life is contemplation. Our ancestors lived in a much slower world. They walked to and from work. They had time to think, to meditate, to pray. At evening, their homes were not filled with television, internet, CD’s VCR’s., DVD’s or AOL. Instead, they read to one another, made their own music, and told stories. In the world before computers, air travel, and running water, they had time to discover the meaning and lessons of existence. With all our leisure and freedom, we must discipline ourselves to make time for contemplation. Otherwise we live from day to day, from appointment to project to vacation and back again to work, without ever stopping to wonder why. It takes a conscientious effort of the will to make the time, to find the quiet, the turn inward and to listen to what life has come to teach us. If only you would listen, begs the Torah in this week’s portion, then all of God’s blessings would find you. Shabbat Shalom.
Thursday, July 29, 2010
Friday, July 23, 2010
Shabbat Shalom July 23-24, 2010
VAETCHANAN, 2005
Who Loves You?
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Their daughter, a bright and otherwise articulate second-grader, was having night terrors. Well after midnight she’d awaken screaming hysterically something about death. So her parents brought her to see me, the rabbi.
“I know kids, but I’m not a therapist,” I complained.
“But she trusts you,” they responded.
So I agreed to speak to the child and see what I could do.
“Sounds like you’re really scared at night,” I began.
“Yeah,” she agreed, playing with the knickknacks on my desk.
“Did something happen that made you so scared?” I inquired.
“No, nothing really,” she put me off. Then after a pause, “Well, my dog died.”
I jumped on this, “That’s terrible! Your poor dog died. You must be really sad about that.”
“No,” she parried, “he was really old and really sick and really smelly, and I didn’t like him very much.” And then, “But when he died, I started thinking about my grandma who died.”
Having been put off once, I proceeded more carefully, “And what was that like?”
“Well, I was only three, so I don’t really remember her very well. But I started thinking that if grandma could die, and grandma was mommy’s mother, well, that means mommy could die. And that made me really scared.”
The knickknacks were set aside, and we were both paying attention now. She was such an open and forthright kid, I thought I’d go a bit farther. “What do you think about when you’re so scared?”
“Well, you know, if mommy died, who would take care of me?”
“That is scarrey.”
“Yeah, that’s what I think about at night and that’s why I start crying.”
Of course you’re crying. At age 7, you’ve discovered the single most terrifying element of the human condition and your world is no longer so secure and bright. Of course you’re crying. We’ve all cried those tears. But we know something else about being human. And you know it too.
“Tell me something, who loves you?”
“That’s a silly question….lots of people love me!”
“Like who?”
“Well, mommy and daddy, my grandpa, and my other grandma and grandpa – I call them Nana and Papa, my Uncle Jack – he’s really funny…”
“Wait a second,” I held her back and reached to find a piece of coloring paper and a marker. “Start writing. Make a list of all the people who love you.”
So we started the list again. “Mommy, daddy, grandpa, Nana, Papa, Uncle Jack…” Soon the list grew long including teachers, doctors, babysitters, the lady at the bakery who gave away cookies. Even the rabbi made the list.
“Here’s what I want you to do. Keep this right next to your bed. When you wake up in the middle of the night, and you start thinking those scarrey thoughts about death, read the list. Read the list of all the people who love you. Read it out loud. Let’s see what happens.”
She read the list every night before bed. And sometimes in the middle of the night. And the night terrors stopped.
This week’s Torah portion gives us the central affirmation of Jewish prayer – Shema Yisrael. Before saying Shema Yisrael in the morning, tradition requires that we gather together the tzitziot, the fringes of the tallit. We wrap them around the fingers and hold them close as we affirm our faith. There are several authoritative interpretations of this custom. But now I have my own, taught to me by this insightful young woman. As we gather the fringes, we gather all those who love us and all those we love into our hands. We gather them into one, as we say the word Ehad -- to affirm the oneness that give us the courage to face all the terrors of being human and continue to live with hope and with faith. The custom is, as well, to elongate the word Ehad – hold the syllable, Ehaaaaaad – long enough to include them all, all those we love, and all whose love touches us. To feel their collective love is to feel the presence of the One who loves us.
Who Loves You?
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Their daughter, a bright and otherwise articulate second-grader, was having night terrors. Well after midnight she’d awaken screaming hysterically something about death. So her parents brought her to see me, the rabbi.
“I know kids, but I’m not a therapist,” I complained.
“But she trusts you,” they responded.
So I agreed to speak to the child and see what I could do.
“Sounds like you’re really scared at night,” I began.
“Yeah,” she agreed, playing with the knickknacks on my desk.
“Did something happen that made you so scared?” I inquired.
“No, nothing really,” she put me off. Then after a pause, “Well, my dog died.”
I jumped on this, “That’s terrible! Your poor dog died. You must be really sad about that.”
“No,” she parried, “he was really old and really sick and really smelly, and I didn’t like him very much.” And then, “But when he died, I started thinking about my grandma who died.”
Having been put off once, I proceeded more carefully, “And what was that like?”
“Well, I was only three, so I don’t really remember her very well. But I started thinking that if grandma could die, and grandma was mommy’s mother, well, that means mommy could die. And that made me really scared.”
The knickknacks were set aside, and we were both paying attention now. She was such an open and forthright kid, I thought I’d go a bit farther. “What do you think about when you’re so scared?”
“Well, you know, if mommy died, who would take care of me?”
“That is scarrey.”
“Yeah, that’s what I think about at night and that’s why I start crying.”
Of course you’re crying. At age 7, you’ve discovered the single most terrifying element of the human condition and your world is no longer so secure and bright. Of course you’re crying. We’ve all cried those tears. But we know something else about being human. And you know it too.
“Tell me something, who loves you?”
“That’s a silly question….lots of people love me!”
“Like who?”
“Well, mommy and daddy, my grandpa, and my other grandma and grandpa – I call them Nana and Papa, my Uncle Jack – he’s really funny…”
“Wait a second,” I held her back and reached to find a piece of coloring paper and a marker. “Start writing. Make a list of all the people who love you.”
So we started the list again. “Mommy, daddy, grandpa, Nana, Papa, Uncle Jack…” Soon the list grew long including teachers, doctors, babysitters, the lady at the bakery who gave away cookies. Even the rabbi made the list.
“Here’s what I want you to do. Keep this right next to your bed. When you wake up in the middle of the night, and you start thinking those scarrey thoughts about death, read the list. Read the list of all the people who love you. Read it out loud. Let’s see what happens.”
She read the list every night before bed. And sometimes in the middle of the night. And the night terrors stopped.
This week’s Torah portion gives us the central affirmation of Jewish prayer – Shema Yisrael. Before saying Shema Yisrael in the morning, tradition requires that we gather together the tzitziot, the fringes of the tallit. We wrap them around the fingers and hold them close as we affirm our faith. There are several authoritative interpretations of this custom. But now I have my own, taught to me by this insightful young woman. As we gather the fringes, we gather all those who love us and all those we love into our hands. We gather them into one, as we say the word Ehad -- to affirm the oneness that give us the courage to face all the terrors of being human and continue to live with hope and with faith. The custom is, as well, to elongate the word Ehad – hold the syllable, Ehaaaaaad – long enough to include them all, all those we love, and all whose love touches us. To feel their collective love is to feel the presence of the One who loves us.
Thursday, July 15, 2010
Shabbat Shalom July 16-17, 2010
DEVARIM, 1997
The Last Taboo
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
I love answering kids' questions. I'll visit a classroom and face an eager chorus of "Did God create dinosaurs?" "Where do people go when they die?" Then at the end, there's always one wise guy, who smirks and asks, "What's the meaning of life?" I love that kid. I admire his chutzpah, and I love the question.
This may be the last taboo. In our culture, people are encouraged to reveal every intimate detail of their lives, every personal secret. In public meetings, at social gatherings, and if that weren't enough, on national television, people shamelessly share every foible and fantasy, every nuance of sexual adventure and interpersonal sin, every addiction and fixation. We'll listen with rapt intent as strangers recounts their bouts with drugs and drink, his infidelities, broken relationships with parents, spouse and children, the bizarre and the spectacular lengths they've gone to obtain thrills. That's permitted. It's even celebrated. But ask "What's the meaning of your life?" and the conversation stops dead.
Try dropping my young friend's question at a cocktail reception or summer barbecue. "So, what's the meaning of your life?" People will laugh. They think you're joking. Isn't that strange? Don't we all, at some point, need to ask this question with seriousness and reflection? Why the laughter?
A homework assignment: On you way home, stop at a drug store and pick up a package of 200 4X6 index cards, and a box of pencils. When you return home, and you find a quiet moment alone, write down on a card all that life has taught you. In Medieval times, Jews left their children a special will. More than instructions for dividing the property, it contained a summary of a life's wisdom. Write one for yourself. To force your concentration, keep it short, no more than an index card. What have you learned from life? From growing up, from school, marriage (and divorce), from raising kids, making a living, building a community, saying goodbye to loved ones? What has life taught you?
It might take a hundred attempts -- one hundred cards written, then tossed out -- to arrive at just the right words. When you arrive at just the right words, cherish that card. Save it, look at it and update it each Rosh Hashana. You deserve to know the meaning, the lesson, the wisdom, of your life. Each of us, according to a mystical teaching, carries one word in God's message to the world. Wouldn't you like to figure out what your word is? And if anything, God forbid, were to happen to you tomorrow, wouldn't you like your children, your grandchildren, your friends to know?
The Torah portion this week describes a miracle. Moses finds words. This man who once protested Lo ish devarim anochi "I am not a man of words devarim" (Exodus 4:10), now stands before his people with something to say. Elah ha-devaim asher deber Moshe el kol Yisrael "These are the words devarim which Moses addressed to all Israel on the other side of the Jordan." The forty year journey has not only brought Israel to the Promised Land. The forty year journey has brought Moses to words. He has discovered the message and meaning of his life's struggle. And for the entire book of Deuteronomy, the once mute prophet will articulate his words.
My young friend asks the question and he is shocked when I answer forthrightly.
When God created the world, it was left unfinished. We are God's partners, assigned to finish the work of Creation. The world that we encounter is a mixture of chaos and order, of good and evil, of darkness and light. It is our job, as God's partners, to bring order to the chaos, to bring good out of evil, to cast light into the darkness. There is a corner of the world that only you can fix. You must find that corner, and applying your energies, imagination and intelligence, bring wholeness and healing. In that direction you will find the meaning of your life.
The Last Taboo
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
I love answering kids' questions. I'll visit a classroom and face an eager chorus of "Did God create dinosaurs?" "Where do people go when they die?" Then at the end, there's always one wise guy, who smirks and asks, "What's the meaning of life?" I love that kid. I admire his chutzpah, and I love the question.
This may be the last taboo. In our culture, people are encouraged to reveal every intimate detail of their lives, every personal secret. In public meetings, at social gatherings, and if that weren't enough, on national television, people shamelessly share every foible and fantasy, every nuance of sexual adventure and interpersonal sin, every addiction and fixation. We'll listen with rapt intent as strangers recounts their bouts with drugs and drink, his infidelities, broken relationships with parents, spouse and children, the bizarre and the spectacular lengths they've gone to obtain thrills. That's permitted. It's even celebrated. But ask "What's the meaning of your life?" and the conversation stops dead.
Try dropping my young friend's question at a cocktail reception or summer barbecue. "So, what's the meaning of your life?" People will laugh. They think you're joking. Isn't that strange? Don't we all, at some point, need to ask this question with seriousness and reflection? Why the laughter?
A homework assignment: On you way home, stop at a drug store and pick up a package of 200 4X6 index cards, and a box of pencils. When you return home, and you find a quiet moment alone, write down on a card all that life has taught you. In Medieval times, Jews left their children a special will. More than instructions for dividing the property, it contained a summary of a life's wisdom. Write one for yourself. To force your concentration, keep it short, no more than an index card. What have you learned from life? From growing up, from school, marriage (and divorce), from raising kids, making a living, building a community, saying goodbye to loved ones? What has life taught you?
It might take a hundred attempts -- one hundred cards written, then tossed out -- to arrive at just the right words. When you arrive at just the right words, cherish that card. Save it, look at it and update it each Rosh Hashana. You deserve to know the meaning, the lesson, the wisdom, of your life. Each of us, according to a mystical teaching, carries one word in God's message to the world. Wouldn't you like to figure out what your word is? And if anything, God forbid, were to happen to you tomorrow, wouldn't you like your children, your grandchildren, your friends to know?
The Torah portion this week describes a miracle. Moses finds words. This man who once protested Lo ish devarim anochi "I am not a man of words devarim" (Exodus 4:10), now stands before his people with something to say. Elah ha-devaim asher deber Moshe el kol Yisrael "These are the words devarim which Moses addressed to all Israel on the other side of the Jordan." The forty year journey has not only brought Israel to the Promised Land. The forty year journey has brought Moses to words. He has discovered the message and meaning of his life's struggle. And for the entire book of Deuteronomy, the once mute prophet will articulate his words.
My young friend asks the question and he is shocked when I answer forthrightly.
When God created the world, it was left unfinished. We are God's partners, assigned to finish the work of Creation. The world that we encounter is a mixture of chaos and order, of good and evil, of darkness and light. It is our job, as God's partners, to bring order to the chaos, to bring good out of evil, to cast light into the darkness. There is a corner of the world that only you can fix. You must find that corner, and applying your energies, imagination and intelligence, bring wholeness and healing. In that direction you will find the meaning of your life.
Thursday, July 8, 2010
Parashat Mattot-Mas'ei
Parashat Mattot-Mas'ei
Numbers 30:2–36:13
July 10, 2010 / 28 Tammuz 5770
This week's commentary was written by Dr. Alan Mintz, Chana Kekst Professor of Hebrew Literature in the Department of Jewish Literature, Jewish Theological Seminary.
The Torah is replete with lists of every kind: the generations before and after Noah, the enumeration of the tribes and their chieftains in the desert, the catalogs of forbidden foods, the inventories of priestly garments. The book of Numbers, which begins with a census, is especially true to its name. The beginning of chapter 33, which opens Parashat Mas'ei (the second of the double portions read in the synagogue this week), presents one of the grandest lists of all: the forty-two stations of Israel's wandering from Ramses in Egypt to the steppes of Moab on the eve of the entry into the Promised Land. Although we may feel that we have heard all of these place names in earlier weekly readings, the fact is that a significant number of these stations (verses 19–30) are mentioned here for the first time. The uniqueness of this list is indicated by the fact that Moses is specifically instructed to record the names in writing. In many synagogues, a special singsong melody used by the Torah reader also makes this passage unique.
Like many lists, the great wilderness itinerary of Numbers 33 marks a significant boundary. Until this point, the book of Numbers, true to its Hebrew name, Bemidbar, has rendered an exhaustive account of the events that befell Israel in its trek through the wilderness, right up to the present moment when the people stands poised to undertake the conquest of the Land. The remaining three chapters of Numbers look forward in time; they deal exclusively with matters that will become relevant after the conquest. The epic desert narrative has been concluded, and the comprehensive recapitulation of the stations of the journey marks an ending on the eve of a new beginning.
For the Rabbis of the midrash, the itinerary of Numbers 33 functions not only to draw a boundary but also to summarize the moral and spiritual meaning of the entire forty-year sojourn in the desert. Yet even though the Rabbis are joined in extracting a deeper meaning from the list of places, they are deeply divided in their essential attitudes to direction of that meaning.
On the one hand, the Rabbis explain that the "Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses: 'Write down the stages by which Israel journeyed in the wilderness, in order that they shall know what miracles I wrought for them.'" Barren of water and sustenance and rife with snakes, scorpions, and hostile marauding tribes, the desert is a place where life is possible only by virtue of God's protection and intervention. The chronicle of the forty-two stations then becomes a catalog of miracles and a record of an abundance of kindnesses. Even the number forty-two, which at first seems so large, emphasizes God's mercy. The first fourteen encampments, as Rashi points out, took place very early on, before the mission of the spies and the punishment of the forty years of wandering; and the last eight took place during the fortieth year. Thus there were only some twenty journeys during the great bulk of the sojourn; Israel was therefore not vexed by frequent forced marches. In fact, for the prophet Jeremiah, as quoted prominently in the Zikhronot liturgy in the Musaf service for Rosh Hashanah, the desert years are invoked nostalgically as a kind of prolonged honeymoon in the covenantal relations between God and Israel.
The opposite stance toward the desert years is presented by the Rabbis in a parable that likens the enumeration of the itinerary to the case of a king who has taken his son on a journey to cure him of his ills. "On their return journey his father began to recount all the stages, saying: 'Here we slept; here we cooled ourselves, here you had a headache.' So the Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses: 'Recount to them all the places where they provoked me.'" Indeed, this severe assessment needs little special pleading or elaboration because it is the principal experience that we have as readers of the Torah's stories of the desert: complaint, murmuring, disobedience, and rebellion over and over again.
An interesting attempt to make a homiletical connection between these conflicting interpretations of the list and the desert years it describes is undertaken by Samson Raphael Hirsch, the nineteenth-century German rabbi. Hirsch notes a reversed duplication in the second verse of the chapter: "Moses recorded the starting points of their various marches as directed by the Lord; their marches, by starting point, were as follows." In the beginning of the verse, the Hebrew reads motsa'eihem lemas'eihem (the starting point of their journeys), whereas the end of the verse has the same pair of terms in the opposite order, mas'eihem lemotsa'eihem. Although a critical reader might take this simply as an instance of chiasm, the abba pattern that the Torah text often delights in, Hirsch sees the reversal as fraught with meaning. The ordering in the first phrase describes how God regarded their travels. In the divine perspective, each starting point moved Israel forward in a journey that culminated in their accession to the Land and the fulfillment of God's promise. When the order is reversed, however, the travels are rendered from the point of view of the people, who also wanted to set forth on the next stage, but for different reasons. Rather than keeping their eyes on the high purpose of their journey, they were motivated to move on by boredom and dissatisfaction with their current encampment and by the desire merely to change their circumstances.
The wanderings of Israel in the desert, then, have many meanings, and the great itinerary of Numbers 33 looks in many directions.
The publication and distribution of the JTS Commentary are made possible by a generous grant from Rita Dee and Harold (z"l) Hassenfeld.
Numbers 30:2–36:13
July 10, 2010 / 28 Tammuz 5770
This week's commentary was written by Dr. Alan Mintz, Chana Kekst Professor of Hebrew Literature in the Department of Jewish Literature, Jewish Theological Seminary.
The Torah is replete with lists of every kind: the generations before and after Noah, the enumeration of the tribes and their chieftains in the desert, the catalogs of forbidden foods, the inventories of priestly garments. The book of Numbers, which begins with a census, is especially true to its name. The beginning of chapter 33, which opens Parashat Mas'ei (the second of the double portions read in the synagogue this week), presents one of the grandest lists of all: the forty-two stations of Israel's wandering from Ramses in Egypt to the steppes of Moab on the eve of the entry into the Promised Land. Although we may feel that we have heard all of these place names in earlier weekly readings, the fact is that a significant number of these stations (verses 19–30) are mentioned here for the first time. The uniqueness of this list is indicated by the fact that Moses is specifically instructed to record the names in writing. In many synagogues, a special singsong melody used by the Torah reader also makes this passage unique.
Like many lists, the great wilderness itinerary of Numbers 33 marks a significant boundary. Until this point, the book of Numbers, true to its Hebrew name, Bemidbar, has rendered an exhaustive account of the events that befell Israel in its trek through the wilderness, right up to the present moment when the people stands poised to undertake the conquest of the Land. The remaining three chapters of Numbers look forward in time; they deal exclusively with matters that will become relevant after the conquest. The epic desert narrative has been concluded, and the comprehensive recapitulation of the stations of the journey marks an ending on the eve of a new beginning.
For the Rabbis of the midrash, the itinerary of Numbers 33 functions not only to draw a boundary but also to summarize the moral and spiritual meaning of the entire forty-year sojourn in the desert. Yet even though the Rabbis are joined in extracting a deeper meaning from the list of places, they are deeply divided in their essential attitudes to direction of that meaning.
On the one hand, the Rabbis explain that the "Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses: 'Write down the stages by which Israel journeyed in the wilderness, in order that they shall know what miracles I wrought for them.'" Barren of water and sustenance and rife with snakes, scorpions, and hostile marauding tribes, the desert is a place where life is possible only by virtue of God's protection and intervention. The chronicle of the forty-two stations then becomes a catalog of miracles and a record of an abundance of kindnesses. Even the number forty-two, which at first seems so large, emphasizes God's mercy. The first fourteen encampments, as Rashi points out, took place very early on, before the mission of the spies and the punishment of the forty years of wandering; and the last eight took place during the fortieth year. Thus there were only some twenty journeys during the great bulk of the sojourn; Israel was therefore not vexed by frequent forced marches. In fact, for the prophet Jeremiah, as quoted prominently in the Zikhronot liturgy in the Musaf service for Rosh Hashanah, the desert years are invoked nostalgically as a kind of prolonged honeymoon in the covenantal relations between God and Israel.
The opposite stance toward the desert years is presented by the Rabbis in a parable that likens the enumeration of the itinerary to the case of a king who has taken his son on a journey to cure him of his ills. "On their return journey his father began to recount all the stages, saying: 'Here we slept; here we cooled ourselves, here you had a headache.' So the Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses: 'Recount to them all the places where they provoked me.'" Indeed, this severe assessment needs little special pleading or elaboration because it is the principal experience that we have as readers of the Torah's stories of the desert: complaint, murmuring, disobedience, and rebellion over and over again.
An interesting attempt to make a homiletical connection between these conflicting interpretations of the list and the desert years it describes is undertaken by Samson Raphael Hirsch, the nineteenth-century German rabbi. Hirsch notes a reversed duplication in the second verse of the chapter: "Moses recorded the starting points of their various marches as directed by the Lord; their marches, by starting point, were as follows." In the beginning of the verse, the Hebrew reads motsa'eihem lemas'eihem (the starting point of their journeys), whereas the end of the verse has the same pair of terms in the opposite order, mas'eihem lemotsa'eihem. Although a critical reader might take this simply as an instance of chiasm, the abba pattern that the Torah text often delights in, Hirsch sees the reversal as fraught with meaning. The ordering in the first phrase describes how God regarded their travels. In the divine perspective, each starting point moved Israel forward in a journey that culminated in their accession to the Land and the fulfillment of God's promise. When the order is reversed, however, the travels are rendered from the point of view of the people, who also wanted to set forth on the next stage, but for different reasons. Rather than keeping their eyes on the high purpose of their journey, they were motivated to move on by boredom and dissatisfaction with their current encampment and by the desire merely to change their circumstances.
The wanderings of Israel in the desert, then, have many meanings, and the great itinerary of Numbers 33 looks in many directions.
The publication and distribution of the JTS Commentary are made possible by a generous grant from Rita Dee and Harold (z"l) Hassenfeld.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)