Shelach Lecha 5771
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
A good friend once told me that the best way of being a tourist in a new place is by getting lost. He’s right. The first day I moved to New York City, I put on my headphones, filled my water bottle and headed south on Broadway. As I walked, I was overwhelmed by the sheer mass of cars, people, and buildings. With music moving in my head, I cast my eyes upward at the canyon formed by the walls of so many tall buildings. Soon enough, I got lost.
Almost by definition, being lost means you are a tourist. The difference between being a native and a visitor is that natives are of a place, they know where to go, when to go, and who to talk to. The place where they live shapes them. This lesson is one that I find relevant in this week’s Torah portion, Shelach Lecha. Moses sends twelve spies to the Land latur et ha-aretz (Numbers 13:16), to literally tour the land, to scout it out. The questions the Israelites ask sound a bit touristy: “What kind of country is it? Are the people nice? Are the towns big? How’s the food?” And my favorite: “Don’t forget to bring me back something.” (Numbers 13:18-20.) These questions are not the kind of questions a native of the Land would ask. They are the questions of outsiders – tourists.
When I finally got home after my hours long walk around New York, I felt transformed. I didn’t feel lost anymore because I learned which streets go in which direction, what the average price of a bagel and coffee is, and other invaluable things that oriented me to becoming a “New Yorker” (As if I could ever really be one.) I started a process of moving beyond being a tourist to being a native, being of a place.
So twelve tourists went to the Land, but only ten tourists returned. For the ten who came home and reported back to Moses, they explained that the Land has great food, but is filled with ferocious people; a great place to visit, perhaps, but not live. For the two who came back different, Joshua and Caleb, something about the Land transformed them. They felt an immediate connection. After forty days of getting lost, they found their home in the Land promised by the Holy One. Caleb explains to the people, “we will elevate ourselves and take the inheritance of it, for chol-yachol nuchal lah, literally for our entire capacity is for it [meaning this place.] (Numbers 13:30) Our capacity for life is tied to this place, this land. We are not outsiders, tourists, but insiders, inheritors. The key to understanding the difference between being a tourist and a native is the sense of immediate elevation a place brings to you. If the Land shapes you, makes you deeper, raises your personal expectations, it’s yours, you are home.
This week our VBS community sends its own fifty scouts to Israel with Rabbi Hoffman. We wish them only the safest and most meaningful journey. But this is no journey of tourists. While they move about the country, taste its foods and see its sites, I know that something deeper is at play. If you let the Land elevate you, you become elevated. If you let the history of our people shape you, you become shaped. If you take note of every moment, you will remember them forever. Because whenever you go to Israel, our Land, you can elevate yourself from being a tourist to being a native. You are home.
Rabbi Hoffman will be sharing the stories of our community’s travels while he is in Israel. Stay tuned to this blog to hear of the amazing transformations our members feel when the report back to us how wonderful a place Israel truly is.
To those who are traveling this Sunday, we say B’tzetchem L’shalom. Go in peace. Oh, and bring us back something nice.
Shabbat Shalom.
Thursday, June 16, 2011
Friday, June 3, 2011
Shabbat Shalom--June 3-4, 2011
Nasso-When Torah Must be Changed
Rabbi Paul Steinberg
The Torah doesn’t always offer us such wonderful models of the gender roles, nor does it offer many model relationships between men and women. Perhaps, however, today’s society doesn’t really, either. The Torah describes a patriarchal society where men “own” their wives. I just can’t relate to that. But I am also struggling to relate to the gender divisions of men and women today, particularly with men and women in their 20’s and 30’s.
Let’s start with today and work our way back to looking at the Torah.
When teenage boys watch movies today, they see a cadre of common male role models, including caricatures often played by Adam Sandler, Seth Rogen, Will Ferrel, and Jonah Hill. The reason teenage boys love watching them is because these grown men are actually just like them. The most important things to these guys are hanging with their buddies, beer, playing Halo on PlayStation, action flicks, and their subscription to Maxim Magazine. This Sandler-Rogen type is between 21-35 years old, they’re unmarried, and are still figuring out their careers. They may not be necessarily lazy or unintelligent, they’re just in no rush to grow up.
For girls, the type of women to watch for are... well, picture Carrie, Miranda, Charlotte and Samantha from Sex and the City. These are upwardly mobile, urban professionals, and in the case of Sex and the City, they boast of a columnist, a Harvard law school graduated lawyer, a director of an art gallery, and an independent PR executive. This is likely to be the most educated and successful group of women ever portrayed! Like their male counterparts, this female demographic is also generally unmarried, but their “biological clocks” are ticking. While the men can wait until their 40’s to marry and have kids, women can’t.
In her book, Manning Up, Kay Mymowitz identifies this new 21st century demographic as “pre-adults.” She specifically calls the men “child-men.” The existence of pre-adults for Mymowitz is a result of economics. Although she believes there are differences between men and women, this emerging life stage is not about hormones or brain chemistry. She explains that this is a manifestation of what economists call the “knowledge economy” wherein people go to university more, they move from city to city more, and they marry later. The average age of marriage in 1950 for men was 22.8 and for women 20.3, compared with 28.4 for men and 26.5 for women today (American Jews tend to marry even later than the national average). Moreover, the job market has created new jobs that are attractive to women at least as much as men in areas including technology, public relations and marketing, and health and fitness.
Now, contrasting the complexity and challenge of the foregoing discussion on family, marriage, and career as it pertains to gender here in America in the 21st century, it is utterly inane and practically inconceivable to seriously consider and regard the selection from this week’s Torah portion, which discusses the woman accused of infidelity to her husband (Num. 5:11-31). The ritual of the sotah (literally “deviant woman”) describes a jealous husband who accuses his wife of adultery. He takes her to the local priest where she is stripped and forced to drink a bitter potion. Along with incantations and sacrifices, the priest declares that if she is guilty, a spell will enter her body, “causing the belly to distend and the thigh to sag” (Num. 5:22). If she is innocent, she will go free.
The Rabbis of the Mishnah extrapolate and detail this procedure, leading to a strange justification for women to study Torah: “Ben Azzai infers that it is a man’s duty to teach his daughter Torah so that if she must drink [the sotah waters because she is an accused adulterer] she should know that merit will keep her punishment on hold.” (Mishnah, Sotah 3:4). Of all of the reasons to teach my three daughters Torah, I must confess that concern over any of them becoming a sotah and enduring this rite is not among them.
The Mishnah (Sotah 3:4) continues:
Rabbi Eliezer says: “If any man teaches his daughter Torah it is as though he taught her lewdness [tiflot].” Rabbi Yehoshua says: “A woman prefers one measure of lewdness to nine measures of chastity” [i.e., a wife would prefer more sex and less income over more income and less sex].
Interestingly, this Rabbinic stream of consciousness leads to the majority acceptance of Rabbi Eliezer’s position, namely that it is prohibited to teach girls Torah on the basis of illicit sexual indiscretion. “Torah” here was later interpreted as Talmud (specifically the Gemara), which continues to remain prohibited to girls for study in many Jewish circles.
As I study this source and I consider the issues Mymowitz raises about the real gender, family, and demographic concerns facing us in the 21st century, I cannot help but to think that the Rabbis were simply living in a different world. What the Rabbis express in Jewish law and what they believed to be the will of God concerning men and women is simply not what I believe or could accept. This may have been an acceptable line of thinking for our Rabbis then, but it’s wrong and unhelpful for us today.
Despite the dissonance between the contemporary study of family and gender and the concept of gender and relationships exemplified in the Torah and Mishnah, I still maintain that the study of Torah, especially study for its own sake, is among the highest spiritual practices available. I also maintain that no text is off limits, including this one about the sotah ritual. We must not be blind, however, to the fact that people authored our sacred texts from a particular time and place. Those who wrote these and other texts that are so obviously irrelevant today were undoubtedly wise. Much of what they taught is universally and eternally true, and… they also got a few things wrong.
Study of sacred texts is intended to be mind-opening, so that when we look at a text and sincerely question it, we see that the truth, which is universal and eternal, is held within those manifold questions that the texts raise. That is to say, the sotah text – no matter how alien it appears at first glance – is really asking deep questions about the relationship between husbands and wives: How do we express the pain of jealousy? How do we engage our spouses and community when we suspect them of adultery? What kind of strain does this put on a family or community and how do we collectively reconcile and resolve it? The sotah text also asks questions of the relationship between parents, children, and gender differences: Should parents have different academic or professional expectations for sons and daughters? How do parents themselves acquiesce to the cultural gender stereotypes for their own children? Should boys and girls be reared differently and to what ends?
The truth is that Mymowitz is asking some of these same questions regarding gender and family. She, like the ancient texts, is merely viewing these questions from her own time and place and with the cultural assumptions and tools accessible to her, namely the media and scientific method. She adds her own conceptions to the layers upon layers of scholars that have asked if there should be gender roles and if so what they should be for a healthy society. Mymowitz proves that answers to the same questions will change for each generation, just as it has with regard to women in the professional world. And frankly, sometimes, the answer to such questions simply must change; if the Torah is to remain relevant, there are times when a new Torah must heal the old Torah. In the end, however, Judaism espouses that the truth is ultimately in the asking, questioning assumptions, comparing and contrasting, analyzing, and asking again: “Turn it, turn it for everything is in it” (Mishnah, Avot 5:22).
Shabbat Shalom
Rabbi Paul Steinberg
The Torah doesn’t always offer us such wonderful models of the gender roles, nor does it offer many model relationships between men and women. Perhaps, however, today’s society doesn’t really, either. The Torah describes a patriarchal society where men “own” their wives. I just can’t relate to that. But I am also struggling to relate to the gender divisions of men and women today, particularly with men and women in their 20’s and 30’s.
Let’s start with today and work our way back to looking at the Torah.
When teenage boys watch movies today, they see a cadre of common male role models, including caricatures often played by Adam Sandler, Seth Rogen, Will Ferrel, and Jonah Hill. The reason teenage boys love watching them is because these grown men are actually just like them. The most important things to these guys are hanging with their buddies, beer, playing Halo on PlayStation, action flicks, and their subscription to Maxim Magazine. This Sandler-Rogen type is between 21-35 years old, they’re unmarried, and are still figuring out their careers. They may not be necessarily lazy or unintelligent, they’re just in no rush to grow up.
For girls, the type of women to watch for are... well, picture Carrie, Miranda, Charlotte and Samantha from Sex and the City. These are upwardly mobile, urban professionals, and in the case of Sex and the City, they boast of a columnist, a Harvard law school graduated lawyer, a director of an art gallery, and an independent PR executive. This is likely to be the most educated and successful group of women ever portrayed! Like their male counterparts, this female demographic is also generally unmarried, but their “biological clocks” are ticking. While the men can wait until their 40’s to marry and have kids, women can’t.
In her book, Manning Up, Kay Mymowitz identifies this new 21st century demographic as “pre-adults.” She specifically calls the men “child-men.” The existence of pre-adults for Mymowitz is a result of economics. Although she believes there are differences between men and women, this emerging life stage is not about hormones or brain chemistry. She explains that this is a manifestation of what economists call the “knowledge economy” wherein people go to university more, they move from city to city more, and they marry later. The average age of marriage in 1950 for men was 22.8 and for women 20.3, compared with 28.4 for men and 26.5 for women today (American Jews tend to marry even later than the national average). Moreover, the job market has created new jobs that are attractive to women at least as much as men in areas including technology, public relations and marketing, and health and fitness.
Now, contrasting the complexity and challenge of the foregoing discussion on family, marriage, and career as it pertains to gender here in America in the 21st century, it is utterly inane and practically inconceivable to seriously consider and regard the selection from this week’s Torah portion, which discusses the woman accused of infidelity to her husband (Num. 5:11-31). The ritual of the sotah (literally “deviant woman”) describes a jealous husband who accuses his wife of adultery. He takes her to the local priest where she is stripped and forced to drink a bitter potion. Along with incantations and sacrifices, the priest declares that if she is guilty, a spell will enter her body, “causing the belly to distend and the thigh to sag” (Num. 5:22). If she is innocent, she will go free.
The Rabbis of the Mishnah extrapolate and detail this procedure, leading to a strange justification for women to study Torah: “Ben Azzai infers that it is a man’s duty to teach his daughter Torah so that if she must drink [the sotah waters because she is an accused adulterer] she should know that merit will keep her punishment on hold.” (Mishnah, Sotah 3:4). Of all of the reasons to teach my three daughters Torah, I must confess that concern over any of them becoming a sotah and enduring this rite is not among them.
The Mishnah (Sotah 3:4) continues:
Rabbi Eliezer says: “If any man teaches his daughter Torah it is as though he taught her lewdness [tiflot].” Rabbi Yehoshua says: “A woman prefers one measure of lewdness to nine measures of chastity” [i.e., a wife would prefer more sex and less income over more income and less sex].
Interestingly, this Rabbinic stream of consciousness leads to the majority acceptance of Rabbi Eliezer’s position, namely that it is prohibited to teach girls Torah on the basis of illicit sexual indiscretion. “Torah” here was later interpreted as Talmud (specifically the Gemara), which continues to remain prohibited to girls for study in many Jewish circles.
As I study this source and I consider the issues Mymowitz raises about the real gender, family, and demographic concerns facing us in the 21st century, I cannot help but to think that the Rabbis were simply living in a different world. What the Rabbis express in Jewish law and what they believed to be the will of God concerning men and women is simply not what I believe or could accept. This may have been an acceptable line of thinking for our Rabbis then, but it’s wrong and unhelpful for us today.
Despite the dissonance between the contemporary study of family and gender and the concept of gender and relationships exemplified in the Torah and Mishnah, I still maintain that the study of Torah, especially study for its own sake, is among the highest spiritual practices available. I also maintain that no text is off limits, including this one about the sotah ritual. We must not be blind, however, to the fact that people authored our sacred texts from a particular time and place. Those who wrote these and other texts that are so obviously irrelevant today were undoubtedly wise. Much of what they taught is universally and eternally true, and… they also got a few things wrong.
Study of sacred texts is intended to be mind-opening, so that when we look at a text and sincerely question it, we see that the truth, which is universal and eternal, is held within those manifold questions that the texts raise. That is to say, the sotah text – no matter how alien it appears at first glance – is really asking deep questions about the relationship between husbands and wives: How do we express the pain of jealousy? How do we engage our spouses and community when we suspect them of adultery? What kind of strain does this put on a family or community and how do we collectively reconcile and resolve it? The sotah text also asks questions of the relationship between parents, children, and gender differences: Should parents have different academic or professional expectations for sons and daughters? How do parents themselves acquiesce to the cultural gender stereotypes for their own children? Should boys and girls be reared differently and to what ends?
The truth is that Mymowitz is asking some of these same questions regarding gender and family. She, like the ancient texts, is merely viewing these questions from her own time and place and with the cultural assumptions and tools accessible to her, namely the media and scientific method. She adds her own conceptions to the layers upon layers of scholars that have asked if there should be gender roles and if so what they should be for a healthy society. Mymowitz proves that answers to the same questions will change for each generation, just as it has with regard to women in the professional world. And frankly, sometimes, the answer to such questions simply must change; if the Torah is to remain relevant, there are times when a new Torah must heal the old Torah. In the end, however, Judaism espouses that the truth is ultimately in the asking, questioning assumptions, comparing and contrasting, analyzing, and asking again: “Turn it, turn it for everything is in it” (Mishnah, Avot 5:22).
Shabbat Shalom
Tuesday, May 24, 2011
Shabbat Shalom--May 27-28, 2011
B'midbar--The Tenth Jew
Rabbi Harold M. Schulweis
I stand at the threshold of the synagogue, waiting for the tenth Jew, so I can recite the Kaddish for my mother. We wait together — nine of us — looking for the tenth, so we can chant and respond to the reader. If we fail to find a tenth, we will have to disband, return to our home, unprayed. We wait for the tenth person, as our people has waited for the messianic Redeemer.
How dependent we are on each other: my “Amen” leading on the reader’s benediction, the sanctification of God’s name waiting for “the yehay shmay rabbah” of the minyan.
Without a minyan, we are silenced. The Sh’ma and its attendant benedictions, the prescribed portions of the Torah and prophets, the priestly benedictions, and the seven benedictions over the newly wed, are all left abandoned by the absence of the tenth person. We need a minyan to elevate the insulated self.
I need you. Without you, we each return to our privatized lives, our dreams unsung, our petitions muted.
Why “ten” to make up a minyan? Why was “ten” the critical number chosen by the tradition as the nucleus of the community? Surely the sages were wise enough to choose a smaller number to satisfy the quorum. They could have chosen “five” for a minyan, after the number of the five books of the Torah. Or, they could have chosen “seven” after the seven days of Creation.
But the sages chose “ten” as the minimum number for the minyan because of the episode recorded in the fourth book of the Bible (Numbers 14:27). Here is told a story of twelve scouts chosen to spy out the land of Israel, to judge whether this wandering people escaped from bondage, stranded in the desert, had the heart and the faith and the courage to enter the promised land and to create there a place of its own, where they could realize the yearnings of liberty they dreamt of in the dungeons of Pharoah.
But ten of the twelve scouts return from spying the land and came with melancholy heart, defeated in spirit and small in their own eyes like grasshoppers. And so they appeared in the eyes of the others. Their defeatism imperiled the hopes of Israel.
Moses turned to the ten and addressed them as “a wicked edah.” “Edah” is the Hebrew term for “community” or “congregation,” and it is used to apply to the people for the first time in the Bible.
What lesson can we learn from this unflattering appellation, “wicked congregation” ? Perhaps to teach us that a congregation is not made up only of fully righteous, saintly, angelic persons, perfect flawless beings. But a congregation is a community that knows its members can become better, softer, wiser, kinder. Together, a congregation can experience the embrace of belonging, the transcendence of belief, and the moral behavior that is refined through belonging.
We need each other. We depend on each other. Without the tenth person, the soaring song of prayer turns into a whimpering whisper; the Sh’ma is stifled, the Kaddish is orphaned.
I need you to enlarge the image of myself. I need you to transmit ethical wisdom to my family, to my friends, to myself. I need you because in your absence, I die a little. With you, I can open my lips and raise my voice on earth so that it may reach the heavens. With you, I live differently.
You are the tenth link in the grand chain of Jewish being … and so am I.
Shabbat Shalom
Rabbi Harold M. Schulweis
I stand at the threshold of the synagogue, waiting for the tenth Jew, so I can recite the Kaddish for my mother. We wait together — nine of us — looking for the tenth, so we can chant and respond to the reader. If we fail to find a tenth, we will have to disband, return to our home, unprayed. We wait for the tenth person, as our people has waited for the messianic Redeemer.
How dependent we are on each other: my “Amen” leading on the reader’s benediction, the sanctification of God’s name waiting for “the yehay shmay rabbah” of the minyan.
Without a minyan, we are silenced. The Sh’ma and its attendant benedictions, the prescribed portions of the Torah and prophets, the priestly benedictions, and the seven benedictions over the newly wed, are all left abandoned by the absence of the tenth person. We need a minyan to elevate the insulated self.
I need you. Without you, we each return to our privatized lives, our dreams unsung, our petitions muted.
Why “ten” to make up a minyan? Why was “ten” the critical number chosen by the tradition as the nucleus of the community? Surely the sages were wise enough to choose a smaller number to satisfy the quorum. They could have chosen “five” for a minyan, after the number of the five books of the Torah. Or, they could have chosen “seven” after the seven days of Creation.
But the sages chose “ten” as the minimum number for the minyan because of the episode recorded in the fourth book of the Bible (Numbers 14:27). Here is told a story of twelve scouts chosen to spy out the land of Israel, to judge whether this wandering people escaped from bondage, stranded in the desert, had the heart and the faith and the courage to enter the promised land and to create there a place of its own, where they could realize the yearnings of liberty they dreamt of in the dungeons of Pharoah.
But ten of the twelve scouts return from spying the land and came with melancholy heart, defeated in spirit and small in their own eyes like grasshoppers. And so they appeared in the eyes of the others. Their defeatism imperiled the hopes of Israel.
Moses turned to the ten and addressed them as “a wicked edah.” “Edah” is the Hebrew term for “community” or “congregation,” and it is used to apply to the people for the first time in the Bible.
What lesson can we learn from this unflattering appellation, “wicked congregation” ? Perhaps to teach us that a congregation is not made up only of fully righteous, saintly, angelic persons, perfect flawless beings. But a congregation is a community that knows its members can become better, softer, wiser, kinder. Together, a congregation can experience the embrace of belonging, the transcendence of belief, and the moral behavior that is refined through belonging.
We need each other. We depend on each other. Without the tenth person, the soaring song of prayer turns into a whimpering whisper; the Sh’ma is stifled, the Kaddish is orphaned.
I need you to enlarge the image of myself. I need you to transmit ethical wisdom to my family, to my friends, to myself. I need you because in your absence, I die a little. With you, I can open my lips and raise my voice on earth so that it may reach the heavens. With you, I live differently.
You are the tenth link in the grand chain of Jewish being … and so am I.
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, May 20, 2011
Shabbat Shalom--May 20-21, 2011
B’chukotai
Cantor Herschel Fox
In this very challenging portion of the week, God makes a very powerful and controversial statement:
“If you walk in My statutes, and keep My commandments and do them, then I will give your rains in their season and the land shall yield her produce, and the trees of the field shall yield their fruit…”
The question naturally arises: And what if we don’t keep God’s commandments? God issues a prophetic warning with the “Tochacha,” a series of “penalties and horrors” (as J.H. Hertz calls them) that would befall the sinful people. These are arranged in a series of groups of increasing severity: sickness and defeat, famine, wild beasts, siege, and exile.
When I was young and studied B’chukotai, truthfully I felt that this was unfair. However, as I got older, I agreed with a Torah commentator who wrote, “Understand that God does not punish for punishment’s sake; He wants to get our attention so that we will introspect, recognize our errors and correct our ways. God does not wish to destroy us, and will never annul His covenant with us.
This is the Almighty’s guarantee to the Jewish people: “I will not grow so disgusted with them nor so tired of them that I would destroy them and break my covenant with them, since I am the Lord their God” (Deut. 26:44-45). He wants to prevent us from becoming so assimilated that we disappear as a nation.
In my opinion, had the Jews not had Torah principles as a blueprint for their lives we would not have existed in exile for nearly 2,000 years till 1948 – the creation of Israel as a sovereign nation.
Interestingly, in the sixth verse of B’chukotai, one of the great promises God makes is “V’natati shalom ba’aretz” —“And I will give peace in the land.” As a people, the Jewish people have constantly searched, dreamed and wanted peace.
Rabbi Zelig Pliskin — reflecting on the great commentator Rashi’s quote, “If there is no peace, there is nothing” — wrote the following:
“There are many people who would really feel satisfied with what they themselves already have. However, because they see that others have more, they feel envious of those people. They actually feel pain when they see that someone else has what they do not.
“When a person feels sincere love for someone else, he is not envious of that person. It does not bother him if that person has more than him. Therefore, the only way for people to really experience a total blessing with what the Almighty has given them is for there to be true peace amongst people. This is the peace in which people feel love for one another and are happy for their good fortunes.
“The only way you will be able to enjoy what you have is to master the attitude of feeling good for the good fortune of others. Envy prevents you from living life to its fullest. The more joy you feel for others, the better your own quality of life.”
I wish you “Shabbat Shalom” — A Shabbat of peace.
Cantor Herschel Fox
In this very challenging portion of the week, God makes a very powerful and controversial statement:
“If you walk in My statutes, and keep My commandments and do them, then I will give your rains in their season and the land shall yield her produce, and the trees of the field shall yield their fruit…”
The question naturally arises: And what if we don’t keep God’s commandments? God issues a prophetic warning with the “Tochacha,” a series of “penalties and horrors” (as J.H. Hertz calls them) that would befall the sinful people. These are arranged in a series of groups of increasing severity: sickness and defeat, famine, wild beasts, siege, and exile.
When I was young and studied B’chukotai, truthfully I felt that this was unfair. However, as I got older, I agreed with a Torah commentator who wrote, “Understand that God does not punish for punishment’s sake; He wants to get our attention so that we will introspect, recognize our errors and correct our ways. God does not wish to destroy us, and will never annul His covenant with us.
This is the Almighty’s guarantee to the Jewish people: “I will not grow so disgusted with them nor so tired of them that I would destroy them and break my covenant with them, since I am the Lord their God” (Deut. 26:44-45). He wants to prevent us from becoming so assimilated that we disappear as a nation.
In my opinion, had the Jews not had Torah principles as a blueprint for their lives we would not have existed in exile for nearly 2,000 years till 1948 – the creation of Israel as a sovereign nation.
Interestingly, in the sixth verse of B’chukotai, one of the great promises God makes is “V’natati shalom ba’aretz” —“And I will give peace in the land.” As a people, the Jewish people have constantly searched, dreamed and wanted peace.
Rabbi Zelig Pliskin — reflecting on the great commentator Rashi’s quote, “If there is no peace, there is nothing” — wrote the following:
“There are many people who would really feel satisfied with what they themselves already have. However, because they see that others have more, they feel envious of those people. They actually feel pain when they see that someone else has what they do not.
“When a person feels sincere love for someone else, he is not envious of that person. It does not bother him if that person has more than him. Therefore, the only way for people to really experience a total blessing with what the Almighty has given them is for there to be true peace amongst people. This is the peace in which people feel love for one another and are happy for their good fortunes.
“The only way you will be able to enjoy what you have is to master the attitude of feeling good for the good fortune of others. Envy prevents you from living life to its fullest. The more joy you feel for others, the better your own quality of life.”
I wish you “Shabbat Shalom” — A Shabbat of peace.
Friday, May 6, 2011
Shabbat Shalom -- May 6-7, 2011
EMOR
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
The great Rabbi of sixteenth century Prague, Rabbi Yehuda Loew, received word of a coming a blood libel, an attack on his community. So he prayed for divine help. In a dream, he saw ten Hebrew words in alphabetical order: Create a Golem of Clay, Destroy Those Tearing Israel’s Heart.
After seven days of fasting and praying, he took his son-in-law and his disciple at midnight and went to the banks of the river, Moldau. Out of river clay, he fashioned a man, and under the creature’s tongue, he placed a slip of paper inscribed with the secret, unutterable name of God. On the creature’s forehead, Rabbi Yehuda wrote, Emet -Truth. They circled the creature seven times, reciting sacred incantations. The creature came alive. Rabbi Yehuda commanded, “Stand,” and the creature stood. They dressed him in servant’s clothes and brought him home. As three they had come; as four they returned. Thus was the Golem born.
The Golem lived in the Rabbi’s house. Strong as ten men, invulnerable, able to turn himself invisible, he repeatedly saved the community from those who threatened the Jews. But the Rabbi worried that someone would misuse the Golem’s powers. Despite his warnings, members of the household sent the Golem on trivial errands. Once they sent him to the river to bring water. But they did not know how to stop him. Soon all were in danger of perishing in a flood. Only the Rabbi’s timely arrival saved them from drowning.
Fearing a calamity, the Rabbi brought the Golem to the synagogue attic, and commanded him to lie among the old tallisim and prayerbooks. The Rabbi removed the slip of paper from the Golem’s mouth, and erased the first letter on his forehead, changing Eme-, Truth, to Met- Dead. And the Golem turned back into lifeless clay.
The Golem is said to rest to this day in the attic of Prague’s ancient synagogue.
In fact, he lives. He lives among us here in America.
Jewish discourse is awash in harsh anger especially when it comes to the future of the Jewish state. There are those who say that the left forsakes their Jewish heritage to accommodate the will of an unreliable partner. They label the left as traitors to the Jewish people and Israel. There are those who say that the right forsakes their Jewish values like compassion for the sake of an old narrative of victimhood. They label the right as traitors to sacred morality.
We can be a self-righteous and angry people. For sixty-five years, we have suffered a severe case of post-traumatic stress. But now, a half-century late, our rage is finally coming out. Like the Golem, rage is a gift of God intended to protect us. Rage gives us strength to defeat an enemy. But like the Golem, rage has no discretion. It attacks everything. It doesn’t know how to stop. Without an external foe, our rage is displaced -- directed internally; not against them, but against our own. It stands behind a banner of Emet-Truth. It speaks in the Name of God. And it will surely drown us.
The Lord said to Moses: “Speak to the priests, the sons of Aaron, and say to them: None [of you] shall defile himself for any [dead] person among his people.” (Leviticus 21:1-2) This week’s Torah portion begins with this puzzling instruction: We would expect the opposite. When there is a death in the community, the Rabbi is among the first we call for help. Why were priests not permitted to attend to the dead? The Ishbitzer Rebbe answered: In the presence of death, one is filled with rage and bitterness. The priest is Oved Hashem, the servant of God, the embodiment of God’s love and care. One so charged cannot carry out his calling with a heart full of anger. Rage and bitterness disqualify him. Only one free of anger may lead and teach the Jewish people.
In the imagination of the Talmud, God prays each morning. And what, the Talmud asks, does God pray? “May it be My will that My love may suppress My anger, and that My love may prevail over My [other] attributes, so that I may deal lovingly with My children.” So may it be for us.
Shabbat Shalom
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
The great Rabbi of sixteenth century Prague, Rabbi Yehuda Loew, received word of a coming a blood libel, an attack on his community. So he prayed for divine help. In a dream, he saw ten Hebrew words in alphabetical order: Create a Golem of Clay, Destroy Those Tearing Israel’s Heart.
After seven days of fasting and praying, he took his son-in-law and his disciple at midnight and went to the banks of the river, Moldau. Out of river clay, he fashioned a man, and under the creature’s tongue, he placed a slip of paper inscribed with the secret, unutterable name of God. On the creature’s forehead, Rabbi Yehuda wrote, Emet -Truth. They circled the creature seven times, reciting sacred incantations. The creature came alive. Rabbi Yehuda commanded, “Stand,” and the creature stood. They dressed him in servant’s clothes and brought him home. As three they had come; as four they returned. Thus was the Golem born.
The Golem lived in the Rabbi’s house. Strong as ten men, invulnerable, able to turn himself invisible, he repeatedly saved the community from those who threatened the Jews. But the Rabbi worried that someone would misuse the Golem’s powers. Despite his warnings, members of the household sent the Golem on trivial errands. Once they sent him to the river to bring water. But they did not know how to stop him. Soon all were in danger of perishing in a flood. Only the Rabbi’s timely arrival saved them from drowning.
Fearing a calamity, the Rabbi brought the Golem to the synagogue attic, and commanded him to lie among the old tallisim and prayerbooks. The Rabbi removed the slip of paper from the Golem’s mouth, and erased the first letter on his forehead, changing Eme-, Truth, to Met- Dead. And the Golem turned back into lifeless clay.
The Golem is said to rest to this day in the attic of Prague’s ancient synagogue.
In fact, he lives. He lives among us here in America.
Jewish discourse is awash in harsh anger especially when it comes to the future of the Jewish state. There are those who say that the left forsakes their Jewish heritage to accommodate the will of an unreliable partner. They label the left as traitors to the Jewish people and Israel. There are those who say that the right forsakes their Jewish values like compassion for the sake of an old narrative of victimhood. They label the right as traitors to sacred morality.
We can be a self-righteous and angry people. For sixty-five years, we have suffered a severe case of post-traumatic stress. But now, a half-century late, our rage is finally coming out. Like the Golem, rage is a gift of God intended to protect us. Rage gives us strength to defeat an enemy. But like the Golem, rage has no discretion. It attacks everything. It doesn’t know how to stop. Without an external foe, our rage is displaced -- directed internally; not against them, but against our own. It stands behind a banner of Emet-Truth. It speaks in the Name of God. And it will surely drown us.
The Lord said to Moses: “Speak to the priests, the sons of Aaron, and say to them: None [of you] shall defile himself for any [dead] person among his people.” (Leviticus 21:1-2) This week’s Torah portion begins with this puzzling instruction: We would expect the opposite. When there is a death in the community, the Rabbi is among the first we call for help. Why were priests not permitted to attend to the dead? The Ishbitzer Rebbe answered: In the presence of death, one is filled with rage and bitterness. The priest is Oved Hashem, the servant of God, the embodiment of God’s love and care. One so charged cannot carry out his calling with a heart full of anger. Rage and bitterness disqualify him. Only one free of anger may lead and teach the Jewish people.
In the imagination of the Talmud, God prays each morning. And what, the Talmud asks, does God pray? “May it be My will that My love may suppress My anger, and that My love may prevail over My [other] attributes, so that I may deal lovingly with My children.” So may it be for us.
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, April 22, 2011
Shabbat Hol HaMoed Pesah 5771--April 23-24, 2011
BIBILICAL LIBERTY
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
Freedom! Every Passover for thousands of years Jews have gathered around dining room tables, in synagogue ballrooms, in ghetto basements, and in frontline bunkers to celebrate our liberation from Egypt. From what I remember, the Passover seder integrates the international Jewish community – it is practiced by more Jews than any other mitzvah. But what is this liberty that we speak of? When we raise our wine glasses and toast to freedom, what exactly are we praising God for?
There are two great narratives of liberty that have engaged in a kind of philosophical wrestling match with each other over the course of our people’s long history and our nation’s shorter one. The first, as the philosopher Isaiah Berlin understands it, is called, “negative liberty.” Simply put, negative liberty is freedom from interference. As Berlin writes, “The fundamental sense of freedom is freedom from chains, from imprisonment, and from enslavement by others.” The second idea of liberty is called “positive liberty.” It is the freedom to grow and prosper, find fulfillment, and a flourishing life. On the face of it, freedom from interference and freedom to prosper might not seem so far apart. But when given over to communal structures and how we decide to shape our community, negative liberty and positive liberty lead us in very different directions.
Negative liberty gives energy to the idea that each one of us carries certain natural rights that must not be impugned by others. Negative liberty originates inside each one of us. Thoughts cannot be compelled, character cannot be minted. Even if we are enslaved to others' political will, it is the liberty of the mind that is freedom’s beginning. Biblically, we find root of this idea in the Exodus story. After 400 years of oppression, the Israelite slaves first freed their minds and looked to wider horizons of human living. Then they were able to finally see the disconnect between the way they lived as slaves and the way they could live as free people. The groaning was heard by God, who took note of this primal call for freedom and reached out the God’s mighty hand to begin the Exodus.
Beyond the machinations of the mind, it is in our acts of will in which negative liberty accrues true force and celebration. “Remember this day, on which you went free from Egypt, the house of bondage, how the LORD freed you from it with a mighty hand...You go free on this day, in the month of Aviv.” (Exodus 13:5) In the opening moments of liberation, the Israelites understood freedom in its rawest form – as freedom from oppression. After the Exodus, negative liberty normalizes in as value in biblical law. For example, debtors cannot be stripped of the shirts off their backs, and each one of us has an inalienable right to food and clothing.
Given its head, however, negative liberty can affirm too strongly the idea of rugged individualism. “Don’t tread on me” can easily become “don’t bother me.” An understanding of this sort of libertarianism leads us precisely to the type of virtue the rabbis understand as the virtue of Sodom, “What’s mine is mine and what’s yours is yours.” (Avot 5:10). Like the character of Noah, if we affirm liberty only as freedom from interference, our disposition situates ourselves alone in a world flooded with “others” of whom we have no real concern.
On the other side of the spectrum is positive liberty. The freedom to prosper entails a different sort of communal expectation than simply a freedom from interference. Positive liberty looks to wider goals or ideals than negative liberty. Positive liberty pursues ends like human fulfillment, societal welfare, and moral perfection. If each of us has the right to prosper freely, then each of us must create a society that allows for everyone to pursue those rights. As the rabbis say, each one of us has, “a share in the world to come.” In the Torah, human flourishing overrides even the most strident of individuals including the injunction against covetous behavior (Exodus 20:12) the requirement of safe harbor for guests (Genesis 19), the exceptions to conscription into the army (Deuteronomy 24:5), and denial of permanent ownership over property or others (Leviticus Ch. 25). Micah, understands positive liberty in the broadest of terms: “He has told, you O human, what is good, And what the LORD requires of you: Only to do justice and to love goodness and to walk modestly with your God.” (Micah 6:8)
But positive liberty given its teeth can also lead to disaster. If the conventions used to secure the human good for all are strengthened qua convention, then the resultant society limits freedom instead of promoting it. The most dastardly examples of positive liberty are found in political systems that find their power in the enslavement to a single idea of the human good where the good for the many trumps any notion of individual choice. As Jews, we are rightly chary of those who wish to choose for us our fate.
Both negative and positive liberty animates our Torah and our sense of Judaism. Moreover, these notions of freedom stand at the heart of the choices set before us as Americans. In the coming weeks and months, our nation will embark on a policy discussion that will shape the texture and timbre of our society. How do we understand our freedom as individuals? On one side of the debate the central question is how can the government have the right to proscribe my liberties for the sake of another’s? On the other side, the central question is how could it not? It is these questions that will rub one type of liberty against the other on the threshing-floor of the House and Senate, across tables in lunchrooms and boardrooms, and on porches and in family rooms across the country.
I believe, however, the question is not of kind, but of degree. Our sacred texts speak of both, because we need both. Positive liberty cannot alienate negative rights and negative liberty is fascicle without positive rights. The rabbis understood the interplay between these ideas of cherut, freedom, as engraved into the very tablets that stand at the center of our religion as a covenanted people: “The Tablets of the Law are the work of God, engraved upon the stones. (Exodus. 32:16) Read not charut [engraved] but cherut, [freedom]. To which one rabbi believes it means freedom from oppression, and another takes it to mean freedom to live. At which all the rabbis agreed that freedom at the very least means freedom from suffering. As we move into the final days of Passover we realize with all too much clarity that the answers to the most important questions, like, “What does it mean to be free?,” yield complex answers. Yet, as we all know, there is no end to the questions set before us on Passover. It is in the questions that we find the meaning and direction that will shape our lives and our children’s lives in the years to come.
Shabbat Shalom
Chag Sameach
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
Freedom! Every Passover for thousands of years Jews have gathered around dining room tables, in synagogue ballrooms, in ghetto basements, and in frontline bunkers to celebrate our liberation from Egypt. From what I remember, the Passover seder integrates the international Jewish community – it is practiced by more Jews than any other mitzvah. But what is this liberty that we speak of? When we raise our wine glasses and toast to freedom, what exactly are we praising God for?
There are two great narratives of liberty that have engaged in a kind of philosophical wrestling match with each other over the course of our people’s long history and our nation’s shorter one. The first, as the philosopher Isaiah Berlin understands it, is called, “negative liberty.” Simply put, negative liberty is freedom from interference. As Berlin writes, “The fundamental sense of freedom is freedom from chains, from imprisonment, and from enslavement by others.” The second idea of liberty is called “positive liberty.” It is the freedom to grow and prosper, find fulfillment, and a flourishing life. On the face of it, freedom from interference and freedom to prosper might not seem so far apart. But when given over to communal structures and how we decide to shape our community, negative liberty and positive liberty lead us in very different directions.
Negative liberty gives energy to the idea that each one of us carries certain natural rights that must not be impugned by others. Negative liberty originates inside each one of us. Thoughts cannot be compelled, character cannot be minted. Even if we are enslaved to others' political will, it is the liberty of the mind that is freedom’s beginning. Biblically, we find root of this idea in the Exodus story. After 400 years of oppression, the Israelite slaves first freed their minds and looked to wider horizons of human living. Then they were able to finally see the disconnect between the way they lived as slaves and the way they could live as free people. The groaning was heard by God, who took note of this primal call for freedom and reached out the God’s mighty hand to begin the Exodus.
Beyond the machinations of the mind, it is in our acts of will in which negative liberty accrues true force and celebration. “Remember this day, on which you went free from Egypt, the house of bondage, how the LORD freed you from it with a mighty hand...You go free on this day, in the month of Aviv.” (Exodus 13:5) In the opening moments of liberation, the Israelites understood freedom in its rawest form – as freedom from oppression. After the Exodus, negative liberty normalizes in as value in biblical law. For example, debtors cannot be stripped of the shirts off their backs, and each one of us has an inalienable right to food and clothing.
Given its head, however, negative liberty can affirm too strongly the idea of rugged individualism. “Don’t tread on me” can easily become “don’t bother me.” An understanding of this sort of libertarianism leads us precisely to the type of virtue the rabbis understand as the virtue of Sodom, “What’s mine is mine and what’s yours is yours.” (Avot 5:10). Like the character of Noah, if we affirm liberty only as freedom from interference, our disposition situates ourselves alone in a world flooded with “others” of whom we have no real concern.
On the other side of the spectrum is positive liberty. The freedom to prosper entails a different sort of communal expectation than simply a freedom from interference. Positive liberty looks to wider goals or ideals than negative liberty. Positive liberty pursues ends like human fulfillment, societal welfare, and moral perfection. If each of us has the right to prosper freely, then each of us must create a society that allows for everyone to pursue those rights. As the rabbis say, each one of us has, “a share in the world to come.” In the Torah, human flourishing overrides even the most strident of individuals including the injunction against covetous behavior (Exodus 20:12) the requirement of safe harbor for guests (Genesis 19), the exceptions to conscription into the army (Deuteronomy 24:5), and denial of permanent ownership over property or others (Leviticus Ch. 25). Micah, understands positive liberty in the broadest of terms: “He has told, you O human, what is good, And what the LORD requires of you: Only to do justice and to love goodness and to walk modestly with your God.” (Micah 6:8)
But positive liberty given its teeth can also lead to disaster. If the conventions used to secure the human good for all are strengthened qua convention, then the resultant society limits freedom instead of promoting it. The most dastardly examples of positive liberty are found in political systems that find their power in the enslavement to a single idea of the human good where the good for the many trumps any notion of individual choice. As Jews, we are rightly chary of those who wish to choose for us our fate.
Both negative and positive liberty animates our Torah and our sense of Judaism. Moreover, these notions of freedom stand at the heart of the choices set before us as Americans. In the coming weeks and months, our nation will embark on a policy discussion that will shape the texture and timbre of our society. How do we understand our freedom as individuals? On one side of the debate the central question is how can the government have the right to proscribe my liberties for the sake of another’s? On the other side, the central question is how could it not? It is these questions that will rub one type of liberty against the other on the threshing-floor of the House and Senate, across tables in lunchrooms and boardrooms, and on porches and in family rooms across the country.
I believe, however, the question is not of kind, but of degree. Our sacred texts speak of both, because we need both. Positive liberty cannot alienate negative rights and negative liberty is fascicle without positive rights. The rabbis understood the interplay between these ideas of cherut, freedom, as engraved into the very tablets that stand at the center of our religion as a covenanted people: “The Tablets of the Law are the work of God, engraved upon the stones. (Exodus. 32:16) Read not charut [engraved] but cherut, [freedom]. To which one rabbi believes it means freedom from oppression, and another takes it to mean freedom to live. At which all the rabbis agreed that freedom at the very least means freedom from suffering. As we move into the final days of Passover we realize with all too much clarity that the answers to the most important questions, like, “What does it mean to be free?,” yield complex answers. Yet, as we all know, there is no end to the questions set before us on Passover. It is in the questions that we find the meaning and direction that will shape our lives and our children’s lives in the years to come.
Shabbat Shalom
Chag Sameach
Tuesday, April 12, 2011
Shabbat Shalom--April 15-16, 2011
Acharei Mot
Cantor Phil Baron
This week’s parasha begins a section of the Torah (culminating in next week’s parasha K’doshim) commonly referred to as the “Holiness Code,” which sounds like something author Dan Brown would think up. The plot should cook with intrigue, mysterious French women, fast cars and secret societies.
But no, it’s actually far more profound, if not quite as exciting as “The Da Vinci Code.” This part of the Torah is a litany of do’s and don’ts regarding commanded and proscribed behaviors leading to holiness. But how do these behaviors actually make us holy?
And in fact, how do you define “holiness?” The Torah sets out to specifically teach us how to achieve a state of holiness by doing certain things and refraining from others. But this state is external. Heaven can see we’re doing right, and we may look nice and holy on the outside, but what is going on in our hearts?
I do my best thinking out on the patio in my back yard, so I grabbed a cup of tea, a stack of scholarly books and a commentary from the internet and set to work staring blankly into space. Suddenly I felt a wet nose at my ankle and looked down to see my daughter and son-in-law’s new puppy, followed moments later by my son-in-law Marc. He gave me a sunny smile and said hello. I stuffed the interenet print-out randomly into one of my books and asked Marc to help me answer the burning question: how do you define holiness?
Marc is getting used to me throwing these deep questions at him. He quickly answered that any discussion about holiness should start with a discussion about goodness. Fine. Goodness was easy to describe. You needed to love your neighbor, he said, give tz’dakah, be kind to strangers, respectful to elders, and honest in your business dealings. Holiness, on the other hand, involved going to synagogue, praying, and other religious activities.
Nice answer, but this also felt too external. It occurred to me that, as in prayer, holiness was about intention. Maimonides taught that giving is elevated when done with a full heart. Any kindness can be achieved automatically, but is only holy when done with kavanah – with direction. Now I was getting somewhere. Marc said he saw my point (after all he had to respect his elder) as he scooped up the puppy and headed toward the door.
With a renewed sense of purpose I grabbed a book off the stack and opened to the random spot where I had stuck my papers. I gasped as I read the title on the page: “The Holy and the Good.” I had pulled Rabbi Jonathan Sacks’ "To Heal a Fractured World" off my shelf, having no idea that he dealt with the subject! Clearly the rabbi and my son-in-law were in cahoots.
As I read the chapter in earnest I soon realized what the Holiness Code boils down to. Humankind needs the commandments, statutes and judgments found in Acharei Mot and its partner, parashat K’doshim. As Rabbi Sacks teaches, “there is nothing inevitable about human virtue. The life of the commandments is an ongoing exercise in character formation, a sustained seminar in Judaism’s ‘habits of the heart.’” Then I found something I resonated with. The rabbi writes that these habits do indeed become holy when we remember that we are made in the image of God, and that “life belongs to Him, not us.” In this is transcendence. As Rabbis Schulweis and Feinstein would say, we are intended to be co-creators with God.
So the Holiness code is a roadmap, leading us through action to that desired state of holiness. “Our prayers, texts and rituals hold before us a vision of how the world might be. The holy is where we enter the ideal; the good is how we make it real.”
But I would respectfully add to the equation Rabbi Sacks and my son-in-law put forward, for there is a step missing. How do we enter the ideal? Here I would return to Maimonides. The Holiness Code repeatedly commands us to do (or refrain from doing) things because “I am the Lord.” This is like a parent saying “because I said so.” The Rambam writes, “It is not right to serve God…out of fear.” However, “whoever serves God out of love…impelled by no external motive whatsoever…such a person does what is truly right.” Love, or “direction of the heart” is what takes the external commandments of Acharei Mot and elevates them to the holy.
So that is my definition of holiness: acts of goodness lovingly performed with the knowledge of our partnership with God. Hmm, not bad. I think I’ll run that by my son-in-law…
Shabbat Shalom
Cantor Phil Baron
This week’s parasha begins a section of the Torah (culminating in next week’s parasha K’doshim) commonly referred to as the “Holiness Code,” which sounds like something author Dan Brown would think up. The plot should cook with intrigue, mysterious French women, fast cars and secret societies.
But no, it’s actually far more profound, if not quite as exciting as “The Da Vinci Code.” This part of the Torah is a litany of do’s and don’ts regarding commanded and proscribed behaviors leading to holiness. But how do these behaviors actually make us holy?
And in fact, how do you define “holiness?” The Torah sets out to specifically teach us how to achieve a state of holiness by doing certain things and refraining from others. But this state is external. Heaven can see we’re doing right, and we may look nice and holy on the outside, but what is going on in our hearts?
I do my best thinking out on the patio in my back yard, so I grabbed a cup of tea, a stack of scholarly books and a commentary from the internet and set to work staring blankly into space. Suddenly I felt a wet nose at my ankle and looked down to see my daughter and son-in-law’s new puppy, followed moments later by my son-in-law Marc. He gave me a sunny smile and said hello. I stuffed the interenet print-out randomly into one of my books and asked Marc to help me answer the burning question: how do you define holiness?
Marc is getting used to me throwing these deep questions at him. He quickly answered that any discussion about holiness should start with a discussion about goodness. Fine. Goodness was easy to describe. You needed to love your neighbor, he said, give tz’dakah, be kind to strangers, respectful to elders, and honest in your business dealings. Holiness, on the other hand, involved going to synagogue, praying, and other religious activities.
Nice answer, but this also felt too external. It occurred to me that, as in prayer, holiness was about intention. Maimonides taught that giving is elevated when done with a full heart. Any kindness can be achieved automatically, but is only holy when done with kavanah – with direction. Now I was getting somewhere. Marc said he saw my point (after all he had to respect his elder) as he scooped up the puppy and headed toward the door.
With a renewed sense of purpose I grabbed a book off the stack and opened to the random spot where I had stuck my papers. I gasped as I read the title on the page: “The Holy and the Good.” I had pulled Rabbi Jonathan Sacks’ "To Heal a Fractured World" off my shelf, having no idea that he dealt with the subject! Clearly the rabbi and my son-in-law were in cahoots.
As I read the chapter in earnest I soon realized what the Holiness Code boils down to. Humankind needs the commandments, statutes and judgments found in Acharei Mot and its partner, parashat K’doshim. As Rabbi Sacks teaches, “there is nothing inevitable about human virtue. The life of the commandments is an ongoing exercise in character formation, a sustained seminar in Judaism’s ‘habits of the heart.’” Then I found something I resonated with. The rabbi writes that these habits do indeed become holy when we remember that we are made in the image of God, and that “life belongs to Him, not us.” In this is transcendence. As Rabbis Schulweis and Feinstein would say, we are intended to be co-creators with God.
So the Holiness code is a roadmap, leading us through action to that desired state of holiness. “Our prayers, texts and rituals hold before us a vision of how the world might be. The holy is where we enter the ideal; the good is how we make it real.”
But I would respectfully add to the equation Rabbi Sacks and my son-in-law put forward, for there is a step missing. How do we enter the ideal? Here I would return to Maimonides. The Holiness Code repeatedly commands us to do (or refrain from doing) things because “I am the Lord.” This is like a parent saying “because I said so.” The Rambam writes, “It is not right to serve God…out of fear.” However, “whoever serves God out of love…impelled by no external motive whatsoever…such a person does what is truly right.” Love, or “direction of the heart” is what takes the external commandments of Acharei Mot and elevates them to the holy.
So that is my definition of holiness: acts of goodness lovingly performed with the knowledge of our partnership with God. Hmm, not bad. I think I’ll run that by my son-in-law…
Shabbat Shalom
Tuesday, April 5, 2011
Shabbat Shalom--April 8-9, 2011
Parshat Metzora
Rabbi Paul Steinberg
“My God, keep my tongue from evil, my lips from lies. Help me ignore those who slander me. Let me be humble before all.”
- Concluding lines of silent Amidah prayer
In his book Chutzpah, renowned law professor Alan Dershowitz relates the following story:
My mother is vacationing at a Jewish hotel in the Catskill Mountains, and is sitting around with a group of older women. One of them hears my mother’s name and, without realizing that she is my mother, launches into a discussion of that other Dershowitz, the Harvard professor. “Such a wonderful boy he is, but why did he have to go off and marry a shiksa [non-Jewish woman]? All the smart and successful ones do it, Henry Kissinger, Ted Koppel…? Why?”
My mother, playing dumb, strings along the know-it-all: “How do you know that Dershowitz married a shiksa?”
Mrs. Know-it-all knows: “My son’s cousin is his best friend. He was at the church where they had the wedding.”
My mother responds: “Well, I heard that he married a Jewish woman.”
“So you heard wrong,” Mrs. K.I.A. assures my mother. “That’s the story his family is putting out, can you blame them?”
At this point my mother can’t hold back. “Alan Dershowitz is my son. I was at the shul where he married Carolyn Cohen, whose father’s name is Mordechai and whose mother speaks fluent Yiddish. So what do you say about that?”
“Oh, I’m so glad it wasn’t true!” Mrs. K.I.A. says in obvious relief, but quickly adding, “How about Henry Kissinger, is his wife Jewish too?” (p. 15)
Although a bit silly (e.g., the chutzpah of insisting on such a false story), Dershowitz’s anecdote speaks to the power of the lure of gossip. So tempting is gossip that we will embellish and even falsify information for the mere feeling of passing it on.
Judaism identifies two kinds of gossip that are to be avoided:
1. Lashon Ha-ra (literally, “the evil tongue”) – true, but negative stories or information that lowers the esteem of the person about whom it is told. A subcategory of this is tattling.
2. Motzi Shem Ra (literally, “bringing an evil name”) – Lies and rumors; negative and false statements about someone.
Why would anyone gossip? When we are honest with ourselves, we find that we primarily gossip in order to raise our own status by lowering the status of others. Rarely is spreading humiliating information about another person for the sole purpose of protecting someone, but instead it is almost always self-serving. Somehow we feel a temporary and pseudo-sense of gratification by shining light on someone else’s miseries, peccadillos, or secrets. After all, isn’t the media obsession with Lindsey Lohan and Charlie Sheen in large part feeding the dark pleasure of enjoying the misfortune and downfall of the rich, famous, and beautiful.
Second, by gossiping we feel – albeit artificially – that we are “in the know.” If we know a personal secret, inside information about someone else, we can feel a sense of self-importance, and justify our prejudices and attempts to assassinate someone’s character (such as the Dershowitz story, where a woman’s cousin had inside information).
Finally, we also spread gossip to exact revenge for being wronged. This is usually especially unfair. In this case, we carry anger about something and use information to damage the one who angered us, often exaggerating the information so that it especially stings.
In this week’s parshah, Metzora discusses the person with a horrible skin disease called tza’arat (often called “leprosy,” but not the leprosy we know today). The rabbinic sages ask what would cause such a disease. Citing cases when Moses’s skin became infected for refusing to obey God’s command (Ex. 4:1-6) and Miriam’s skin disease (Num. 12:1-13), the Rabbis conclude that rather than a physical ailment, this tza’arat is the consequence of gossip; it is a physical symptom of a spiritual malady. Moreover, the Rabbis notice that the word metzora (“leper”) can be read as an acronym, hinting at the aforementioned term for gossip: Motzi Shem Ra.
All of the biblical commentators pick up on this rabbinic interpretation, claiming that the disease serves as a just punishment for the sin of gossip – “a measure for measure”. Perhaps most notably, Pinchas Peli, a twentieth century Israeli commentator suggests that a skin disease is a “deserved punishment… [because it is] an illness that cannot be hidden [from the public]” just as the act of lying, slander, and gossip publically damages someone else.
Certainly gossip does not, or at least very rarely, causes physical diseases, and those who suffer from skin ailments should not be seen as guilty of gossip. That said, it is absolutely clear that, like an infectious disease, gossip, slander, tale-bearing, lying, character assassination can poison, spread, and destroy a society. This is especially true today, when we have access to so many modes of faceless communication, such as texting and the Internet. Unfortunately, as Rabbi Harvey Fields notes, “Learning to quarantine such evil and to cure ourselves from the temptation of lashon ha-ra [and motzi shem ra] are still significant challenges today.”
Shabbat Shalom!
Rabbi Paul Steinberg
“My God, keep my tongue from evil, my lips from lies. Help me ignore those who slander me. Let me be humble before all.”
- Concluding lines of silent Amidah prayer
In his book Chutzpah, renowned law professor Alan Dershowitz relates the following story:
My mother is vacationing at a Jewish hotel in the Catskill Mountains, and is sitting around with a group of older women. One of them hears my mother’s name and, without realizing that she is my mother, launches into a discussion of that other Dershowitz, the Harvard professor. “Such a wonderful boy he is, but why did he have to go off and marry a shiksa [non-Jewish woman]? All the smart and successful ones do it, Henry Kissinger, Ted Koppel…? Why?”
My mother, playing dumb, strings along the know-it-all: “How do you know that Dershowitz married a shiksa?”
Mrs. Know-it-all knows: “My son’s cousin is his best friend. He was at the church where they had the wedding.”
My mother responds: “Well, I heard that he married a Jewish woman.”
“So you heard wrong,” Mrs. K.I.A. assures my mother. “That’s the story his family is putting out, can you blame them?”
At this point my mother can’t hold back. “Alan Dershowitz is my son. I was at the shul where he married Carolyn Cohen, whose father’s name is Mordechai and whose mother speaks fluent Yiddish. So what do you say about that?”
“Oh, I’m so glad it wasn’t true!” Mrs. K.I.A. says in obvious relief, but quickly adding, “How about Henry Kissinger, is his wife Jewish too?” (p. 15)
Although a bit silly (e.g., the chutzpah of insisting on such a false story), Dershowitz’s anecdote speaks to the power of the lure of gossip. So tempting is gossip that we will embellish and even falsify information for the mere feeling of passing it on.
Judaism identifies two kinds of gossip that are to be avoided:
1. Lashon Ha-ra (literally, “the evil tongue”) – true, but negative stories or information that lowers the esteem of the person about whom it is told. A subcategory of this is tattling.
2. Motzi Shem Ra (literally, “bringing an evil name”) – Lies and rumors; negative and false statements about someone.
Why would anyone gossip? When we are honest with ourselves, we find that we primarily gossip in order to raise our own status by lowering the status of others. Rarely is spreading humiliating information about another person for the sole purpose of protecting someone, but instead it is almost always self-serving. Somehow we feel a temporary and pseudo-sense of gratification by shining light on someone else’s miseries, peccadillos, or secrets. After all, isn’t the media obsession with Lindsey Lohan and Charlie Sheen in large part feeding the dark pleasure of enjoying the misfortune and downfall of the rich, famous, and beautiful.
Second, by gossiping we feel – albeit artificially – that we are “in the know.” If we know a personal secret, inside information about someone else, we can feel a sense of self-importance, and justify our prejudices and attempts to assassinate someone’s character (such as the Dershowitz story, where a woman’s cousin had inside information).
Finally, we also spread gossip to exact revenge for being wronged. This is usually especially unfair. In this case, we carry anger about something and use information to damage the one who angered us, often exaggerating the information so that it especially stings.
In this week’s parshah, Metzora discusses the person with a horrible skin disease called tza’arat (often called “leprosy,” but not the leprosy we know today). The rabbinic sages ask what would cause such a disease. Citing cases when Moses’s skin became infected for refusing to obey God’s command (Ex. 4:1-6) and Miriam’s skin disease (Num. 12:1-13), the Rabbis conclude that rather than a physical ailment, this tza’arat is the consequence of gossip; it is a physical symptom of a spiritual malady. Moreover, the Rabbis notice that the word metzora (“leper”) can be read as an acronym, hinting at the aforementioned term for gossip: Motzi Shem Ra.
All of the biblical commentators pick up on this rabbinic interpretation, claiming that the disease serves as a just punishment for the sin of gossip – “a measure for measure”. Perhaps most notably, Pinchas Peli, a twentieth century Israeli commentator suggests that a skin disease is a “deserved punishment… [because it is] an illness that cannot be hidden [from the public]” just as the act of lying, slander, and gossip publically damages someone else.
Certainly gossip does not, or at least very rarely, causes physical diseases, and those who suffer from skin ailments should not be seen as guilty of gossip. That said, it is absolutely clear that, like an infectious disease, gossip, slander, tale-bearing, lying, character assassination can poison, spread, and destroy a society. This is especially true today, when we have access to so many modes of faceless communication, such as texting and the Internet. Unfortunately, as Rabbi Harvey Fields notes, “Learning to quarantine such evil and to cure ourselves from the temptation of lashon ha-ra [and motzi shem ra] are still significant challenges today.”
Shabbat Shalom!
Thursday, March 31, 2011
Shabbat Shalom--April 1-2, 2011
TAZRIAH, 1997
People Of The Disk
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Why do we read the Torah from a scroll? A hand-written, parchment scroll, no less.
There have been at least three "information revolutions" since the tradition of reading the Torah began. In the eleventh century, a German monk stacked the pages of a scroll one atop the other and drove a staple through the side, creating the "codex" form of books we use to this day. This codex form allows one to turn pages quickly, to jump from one page to another, and to read in two places at once -- by keeping a finger on one spot and turning simultaneously to another. More importantly, a codex book can be indexed -- allowing the reader to search for information all over the book at once. The codex broke the linear arrangement of the scroll -- allowing information to be delivered in a much more complex way. But despite all these advantages, we still read Torah from a scroll. Slow, linear, one word, one line at a time.
In the fifteenth century, Gutenberg introduced movable type. Once again, the delivery of information was revolutionized. Printing made books widely available and abundant. But not just books -- newspapers, pamphlets, journals, junk mail. Printing filled the world with the written word. And printing standardized texts. Suddenly, we had the "authorized" version -- corrected and approved. But Jews still insist on a scroll. We may follow the text from a printed book, but the real reading is from a scroll written by hand. Slowly. It takes a year to write a Sefer Torah. And carefully. Because the standardization of a Sefer Torah is not a product of a machine, but rather a matter of human will, love and obedience.
In the last decade, we've entered the third revolution. On my desk sits a computer that processes several million "bits" of information per second. Attached to the computer is a CD ROM device. I slip in a disk and instantaneously I have complete access to whole libraries of knowledge. You can get, on one disk, the entire 4000-year history of Jewish wisdom. One disk contains the Bible, the Talmud, all the major collections of Midrash, all the Codes of Jewish Law, the Zohar, and all the major commentaries on these works. A lifetime -- several lifetimes -- of learning, comes up instantaneously on my screen. Ask it to find any word, any concept, any name, and it accomplishes a year's worth of bibliographic research in a matter of seconds.
Will our children look upon books as we look upon a scroll -- a relic, honored by tradition, but of limited efficiency?
Still, we read Torah from a scroll. And we will read from a scroll long after CD ROM is surpassed by the next revolution. Not just out of stubborn adherence to ancient tradition. And not just as a symbol of the authenticity of ancient truths. But precisely because the scroll is so inefficient, so slow, so linear. Only in that way does the word remain real and important. Each word. Written slowly and carefully. Read slowly and carefully. Each information revolution puts us in touch with so many more words so much more quickly; but each compromises the depth of the words we touch. And that's the soul of Torah: to read deeply, and slowly, and reflectively.
When the Rabbis of the Talmud read this week's Torah portion, and its procedures for the treatment of leprosy, they were convinced that more than dermatology was at stake. They came to understand the Torah's metzorah, leprosy, as a more serious malady -- a leprosy of language. As leprosy contaminates and debilitates the body, so too, there are plagues that attack and corrupt our words. As leprosy disfigures the human form, there are plagues that disfigure a culture's soul by stealing the depth and resonance of its words. The Torah is read from a scroll to inoculate us. To keep our words healthy, our language holy, and our souls awake.
Shabbat Shalom
People Of The Disk
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Why do we read the Torah from a scroll? A hand-written, parchment scroll, no less.
There have been at least three "information revolutions" since the tradition of reading the Torah began. In the eleventh century, a German monk stacked the pages of a scroll one atop the other and drove a staple through the side, creating the "codex" form of books we use to this day. This codex form allows one to turn pages quickly, to jump from one page to another, and to read in two places at once -- by keeping a finger on one spot and turning simultaneously to another. More importantly, a codex book can be indexed -- allowing the reader to search for information all over the book at once. The codex broke the linear arrangement of the scroll -- allowing information to be delivered in a much more complex way. But despite all these advantages, we still read Torah from a scroll. Slow, linear, one word, one line at a time.
In the fifteenth century, Gutenberg introduced movable type. Once again, the delivery of information was revolutionized. Printing made books widely available and abundant. But not just books -- newspapers, pamphlets, journals, junk mail. Printing filled the world with the written word. And printing standardized texts. Suddenly, we had the "authorized" version -- corrected and approved. But Jews still insist on a scroll. We may follow the text from a printed book, but the real reading is from a scroll written by hand. Slowly. It takes a year to write a Sefer Torah. And carefully. Because the standardization of a Sefer Torah is not a product of a machine, but rather a matter of human will, love and obedience.
In the last decade, we've entered the third revolution. On my desk sits a computer that processes several million "bits" of information per second. Attached to the computer is a CD ROM device. I slip in a disk and instantaneously I have complete access to whole libraries of knowledge. You can get, on one disk, the entire 4000-year history of Jewish wisdom. One disk contains the Bible, the Talmud, all the major collections of Midrash, all the Codes of Jewish Law, the Zohar, and all the major commentaries on these works. A lifetime -- several lifetimes -- of learning, comes up instantaneously on my screen. Ask it to find any word, any concept, any name, and it accomplishes a year's worth of bibliographic research in a matter of seconds.
Will our children look upon books as we look upon a scroll -- a relic, honored by tradition, but of limited efficiency?
Still, we read Torah from a scroll. And we will read from a scroll long after CD ROM is surpassed by the next revolution. Not just out of stubborn adherence to ancient tradition. And not just as a symbol of the authenticity of ancient truths. But precisely because the scroll is so inefficient, so slow, so linear. Only in that way does the word remain real and important. Each word. Written slowly and carefully. Read slowly and carefully. Each information revolution puts us in touch with so many more words so much more quickly; but each compromises the depth of the words we touch. And that's the soul of Torah: to read deeply, and slowly, and reflectively.
When the Rabbis of the Talmud read this week's Torah portion, and its procedures for the treatment of leprosy, they were convinced that more than dermatology was at stake. They came to understand the Torah's metzorah, leprosy, as a more serious malady -- a leprosy of language. As leprosy contaminates and debilitates the body, so too, there are plagues that attack and corrupt our words. As leprosy disfigures the human form, there are plagues that disfigure a culture's soul by stealing the depth and resonance of its words. The Torah is read from a scroll to inoculate us. To keep our words healthy, our language holy, and our souls awake.
Shabbat Shalom
Wednesday, March 23, 2011
Shabbat Shalom--March 25-26, 2011
Holiness in Humility
Rabbi Joshua Hoffman
Parshat Shemini 5771
Why does the troubling episode of Nadav and Avihu, Aaron’s sons, enter into the narrative of Leviticus? Are we to find in the tragic consumption of these two souls a sobering adjuration against improper offerings? Shall we read this as some sort of perversion of holiness?
The entire affair is brief – a total of three verses (with a couple more explaining how the community deals with the bodies in the aftermath). Two of Aaron’s sons come forward before God in the Mishkan and offer fire, “which He had not enjoined upon them.” (v.1) Nadav and Avihu are consumed and God then pronounces, “Through those near to Me I show Myself holy/ And gain glory before all the people.” (v.3)
We can’t assume that Nadav and Avihu anticipated or expected that God would engulf them in flames as a consequence for their disobedience. Even if their motivations for bringing the offerings were suspicious, as many rabbinic commentaries would suggest, there is no precedent or forewarning that their behavior was worthy of a death sentence, a gruesome and harrowing one at that. It appears at the very least that their actions are the cause of unintended consequences.
Look up “unintended consequences” and you’ll find an entire school of thought on the subject. According to one source, consequences of this sort can be classified as positive, negative, or oddly denoted - perverse. How wonderful are those moments when a new discovery emerges from a serendipitous mistake, like the discovery of Penicillin in healing the sick, or the discovery of aspirin to help prevent heart attacks. So many lives have been saved from blunders and mishaps; there is holiness in this type of discovery as well.
And then there are those actions which are unintentional and innocent, yet cause far greater harm than one could have possibly imagined such as irrigating a land plot and causing irreparable erosion or the proliferation of cattle raising for food and the impact it has on the depletion of the ozone layer. The perverse nature of such consequences is even seen in our social sphere where, for example, there was a dramatic rise in ‘hit-and-run’ accidents as a direct result of tougher laws prohibiting drinking and driving. This too, has a dimension of holiness, according to our Torah.
We must learn holiness can not only be ascribed to positive outcomes, not only because we do not find this to be true in our own life experience, but also because the path toward holy living is filled with twists and turns that can never fully anticipate the consequences of our actions.
Herein lies our truth. We may posit that Nadav and Avihu were lacking a certain humility and did not adhere to God’s warnings for proper entrance into the Tent and bringing sanctified offerings. The rabbis of the Talmud suggest that Nadav and Avihu’s punishment was a spiritual death. The fire that was intended to consume their offerings consumed their souls instead, leaving their bodies intact. (Sanhedrin 52a) They may have walked away from the experience but their souls were scorched in the process.
Entering into God’s presence is never unintended. Our gratitude for unintentional consequences may rest both in the pleasant surprises in discovering new truths and improvements to the human condition, and in the staggering realization that our efforts can sometimes cause great harm to ourselves, to others, and to the world. But kedushah – holiness itself is neither positive nor negative. It is the unmitigated, completely dedicated encounter with Divine Truth. We can sense this from the lesson, “Through those near to Me I show Myself holy/ And gain glory before all the people.” Only the God of Israel shows holiness and glory before all the people. From this we learn to proudly be the humble, dedicated, and intentional servants of this holy truth.
Shabbat Shalom.
Rabbi Joshua Hoffman
Parshat Shemini 5771
Why does the troubling episode of Nadav and Avihu, Aaron’s sons, enter into the narrative of Leviticus? Are we to find in the tragic consumption of these two souls a sobering adjuration against improper offerings? Shall we read this as some sort of perversion of holiness?
The entire affair is brief – a total of three verses (with a couple more explaining how the community deals with the bodies in the aftermath). Two of Aaron’s sons come forward before God in the Mishkan and offer fire, “which He had not enjoined upon them.” (v.1) Nadav and Avihu are consumed and God then pronounces, “Through those near to Me I show Myself holy/ And gain glory before all the people.” (v.3)
We can’t assume that Nadav and Avihu anticipated or expected that God would engulf them in flames as a consequence for their disobedience. Even if their motivations for bringing the offerings were suspicious, as many rabbinic commentaries would suggest, there is no precedent or forewarning that their behavior was worthy of a death sentence, a gruesome and harrowing one at that. It appears at the very least that their actions are the cause of unintended consequences.
Look up “unintended consequences” and you’ll find an entire school of thought on the subject. According to one source, consequences of this sort can be classified as positive, negative, or oddly denoted - perverse. How wonderful are those moments when a new discovery emerges from a serendipitous mistake, like the discovery of Penicillin in healing the sick, or the discovery of aspirin to help prevent heart attacks. So many lives have been saved from blunders and mishaps; there is holiness in this type of discovery as well.
And then there are those actions which are unintentional and innocent, yet cause far greater harm than one could have possibly imagined such as irrigating a land plot and causing irreparable erosion or the proliferation of cattle raising for food and the impact it has on the depletion of the ozone layer. The perverse nature of such consequences is even seen in our social sphere where, for example, there was a dramatic rise in ‘hit-and-run’ accidents as a direct result of tougher laws prohibiting drinking and driving. This too, has a dimension of holiness, according to our Torah.
We must learn holiness can not only be ascribed to positive outcomes, not only because we do not find this to be true in our own life experience, but also because the path toward holy living is filled with twists and turns that can never fully anticipate the consequences of our actions.
Herein lies our truth. We may posit that Nadav and Avihu were lacking a certain humility and did not adhere to God’s warnings for proper entrance into the Tent and bringing sanctified offerings. The rabbis of the Talmud suggest that Nadav and Avihu’s punishment was a spiritual death. The fire that was intended to consume their offerings consumed their souls instead, leaving their bodies intact. (Sanhedrin 52a) They may have walked away from the experience but their souls were scorched in the process.
Entering into God’s presence is never unintended. Our gratitude for unintentional consequences may rest both in the pleasant surprises in discovering new truths and improvements to the human condition, and in the staggering realization that our efforts can sometimes cause great harm to ourselves, to others, and to the world. But kedushah – holiness itself is neither positive nor negative. It is the unmitigated, completely dedicated encounter with Divine Truth. We can sense this from the lesson, “Through those near to Me I show Myself holy/ And gain glory before all the people.” Only the God of Israel shows holiness and glory before all the people. From this we learn to proudly be the humble, dedicated, and intentional servants of this holy truth.
Shabbat Shalom.
Wednesday, March 16, 2011
Shabbat Shalom--March 18-19, 2011
Parashat Tzav
Cantor Herschel Fox
Tsav is full of laws about sacrifices – Korbanot. In Tzav we are taught in great detail the laws of the burnt offering and the ritual of the grain, etc. In addition, there are other laws we are commanded to perform such as “And the Lord spoke to Moses saying: Speak to the Israelite people thus: You shall eat no fat of ox or sheep or goat. Fat from animals that died or were torn by beasts may be put to any use but you must not eat it.” (Lev.7:22-24)
There is one idea in Tzav that has always touched me deeply. In Leviticus Chapter 7, Verse 19 it says: “Flesh that touches any contaminated thing may not be eaten, it shall be burned in fire.” I remember when we were young and studied with Rabbi Kravets, the Rabbi and principal of the Talmud Torah; we discussed this idea at length. We asked Rabbi Kravets, “Just because something clean or pure touches something unclean or impure for a brief moment, why does the clean thing become impure or contaminated? It starts small but it gets bigger!” Rabbi Kravets told us that the Torah says even if something pure touches something impure only once, it can result in problems.
His answer taught us a great lesson. He began by telling us in Yiddish “Zog mir ver es zenen daine fraint vel ich dir zog’n ver du bist.” “Tell who your friends are and I’ll tell you who you are!” We got it. Who is touching your soul?
We all knew somebody who had a friend that created a negative example for him. Everyone knew someone who suggested you try drugs. What could one snort or needle hurt? What could a little fun hurt? Everyone knew someone who snuck out of the house in the middle of the night and go into trouble.
Rabbi Kravets said to us; God doesn’t care so much about our animal sacrifices, God wants us to be “Mentshen.” He would say to us “Men darf zain a mentsh!, You have to be a good person!” Each week on Friday afternoon, the Rabbi would teach us Mussar because the key idea was always that we should be decent human beings “Zai a mentsh” Be a good person!”
Shabbat Shalom
Cantor Herschel Fox
Tsav is full of laws about sacrifices – Korbanot. In Tzav we are taught in great detail the laws of the burnt offering and the ritual of the grain, etc. In addition, there are other laws we are commanded to perform such as “And the Lord spoke to Moses saying: Speak to the Israelite people thus: You shall eat no fat of ox or sheep or goat. Fat from animals that died or were torn by beasts may be put to any use but you must not eat it.” (Lev.7:22-24)
There is one idea in Tzav that has always touched me deeply. In Leviticus Chapter 7, Verse 19 it says: “Flesh that touches any contaminated thing may not be eaten, it shall be burned in fire.” I remember when we were young and studied with Rabbi Kravets, the Rabbi and principal of the Talmud Torah; we discussed this idea at length. We asked Rabbi Kravets, “Just because something clean or pure touches something unclean or impure for a brief moment, why does the clean thing become impure or contaminated? It starts small but it gets bigger!” Rabbi Kravets told us that the Torah says even if something pure touches something impure only once, it can result in problems.
His answer taught us a great lesson. He began by telling us in Yiddish “Zog mir ver es zenen daine fraint vel ich dir zog’n ver du bist.” “Tell who your friends are and I’ll tell you who you are!” We got it. Who is touching your soul?
We all knew somebody who had a friend that created a negative example for him. Everyone knew someone who suggested you try drugs. What could one snort or needle hurt? What could a little fun hurt? Everyone knew someone who snuck out of the house in the middle of the night and go into trouble.
Rabbi Kravets said to us; God doesn’t care so much about our animal sacrifices, God wants us to be “Mentshen.” He would say to us “Men darf zain a mentsh!, You have to be a good person!” Each week on Friday afternoon, the Rabbi would teach us Mussar because the key idea was always that we should be decent human beings “Zai a mentsh” Be a good person!”
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, March 11, 2011
Shabbat Shalom March 11-12, 2011
VAYIKRA
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
How do the books of the Torah get their names? It's really rather arbitrary: Each name is simply the first significant word found in the first lines of the book. But by some powerful coincidence, these randomly chosen names capture and express the character and content of each book:
B'reshit, (Genesis) is a book of beginnings -- recounting the origins of the world, of humanity, and of Israel. More, B'reshit sets the foundation of Jewish faith -- our fundamental attitudes about God, the world, the human being, nature, gender, family, and evil.
Sh'mot, (Exodus) means "names", because the book opens with names of Jacob's clan who went down into Egypt. But at the center of Sh'mot are those events that give us our identity as a people: the Exodus from Egypt and the Giving (and Receiving) of Torah on Mt. Sinai. Sh'mot is, indeed, the book of our name.
Va'yikra, (Leviticus) the book we begin this week, translates "and He [God] called..." which is precisely the book's content: God's call to the people Israel to attain holiness -- to live up to God's dream to become a "nation of priests and a holy people", and Israel's response through mitzvot and worship.
Bamidbar, (Numbers) means "in the wilderness." The book's story takes us from Mt Sinai, through the wilderness wanderings of the Israelites to the boundaries of the Promised Land. But more than the geographic wilderness, this book describes a social wasteland. Every tie that binds the People Israel falls apart: The driving dream of the Promised Land is violated by the people's fear and doubt. The base physical desires of hunger, thirst, and sexual lust overcome the Vayikra vision of the people's holiness and duty. The tragedy of Bamidbar falls heaviest on Moshe. Everyone in his life betrays him: his people, his tribe, even his own family. And finally, ironically, he is betrayed by God...and for what?...for hitting the rock instead of speaking to it! But what else could be expected? Nowhere in Bamidbar do words function properly! In Bamidbar, there are no shared words. Leaders speak, but on one listens. Leaders lead, but no one follows. Filled with screaming and shouting and whining, it is the noisiest, most disturbing book in the Bible.
Had the Torah ended here, as some scholars suggest it once did, it would have been a very different book...and we would be a very different people. But it doesn't end here.
The Torah's final book is D'varim (Deuteronomy). D'varim means "words", and the book relates all the words shared by the once wordless Moshe with the children of the Bamidbar generation. It's a remarkable revolution: he talks, they listen. He teaches, they learn. Here is dialogue, shared vision, shared values, shared direction. The most important word in D'varim is Sh'ma -- "Listen!" ... It is a book of listening. It is a book filled with the calm of consensus and confidence. At the end, as at the beginning, creation overcomes chaos...and it is good.
Why does the Torah juxtapose such antithetical books -- the holy vision of Vayikra, the discordant bedlam of Bamidbar, the calm of Dvarim? Why such contradictory visions of human life and human community? Because all life is an oscillation among them -- vision and division, chaos and consensus. This is the inner life, as we alternatively grasp and then grow out of our conceptions of life's purpose and mission. This is family life -- as we learn to hold onto one another, and at the same time, learn to let go. And this is the life of human communities. No community's consensus lasts forever. Nor should it. We must, periodically, re-enter Bamidbar to find a new course, a new vision, a new language. But the Torah offers this wisdom: Out of Bamidbar comes Dvarim -- out of rebellion and wandering will come consensus and direction, just as out of chaos comes Creation. That's the Torah's faith.
Shabbat Shalom.
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
How do the books of the Torah get their names? It's really rather arbitrary: Each name is simply the first significant word found in the first lines of the book. But by some powerful coincidence, these randomly chosen names capture and express the character and content of each book:
B'reshit, (Genesis) is a book of beginnings -- recounting the origins of the world, of humanity, and of Israel. More, B'reshit sets the foundation of Jewish faith -- our fundamental attitudes about God, the world, the human being, nature, gender, family, and evil.
Sh'mot, (Exodus) means "names", because the book opens with names of Jacob's clan who went down into Egypt. But at the center of Sh'mot are those events that give us our identity as a people: the Exodus from Egypt and the Giving (and Receiving) of Torah on Mt. Sinai. Sh'mot is, indeed, the book of our name.
Va'yikra, (Leviticus) the book we begin this week, translates "and He [God] called..." which is precisely the book's content: God's call to the people Israel to attain holiness -- to live up to God's dream to become a "nation of priests and a holy people", and Israel's response through mitzvot and worship.
Bamidbar, (Numbers) means "in the wilderness." The book's story takes us from Mt Sinai, through the wilderness wanderings of the Israelites to the boundaries of the Promised Land. But more than the geographic wilderness, this book describes a social wasteland. Every tie that binds the People Israel falls apart: The driving dream of the Promised Land is violated by the people's fear and doubt. The base physical desires of hunger, thirst, and sexual lust overcome the Vayikra vision of the people's holiness and duty. The tragedy of Bamidbar falls heaviest on Moshe. Everyone in his life betrays him: his people, his tribe, even his own family. And finally, ironically, he is betrayed by God...and for what?...for hitting the rock instead of speaking to it! But what else could be expected? Nowhere in Bamidbar do words function properly! In Bamidbar, there are no shared words. Leaders speak, but on one listens. Leaders lead, but no one follows. Filled with screaming and shouting and whining, it is the noisiest, most disturbing book in the Bible.
Had the Torah ended here, as some scholars suggest it once did, it would have been a very different book...and we would be a very different people. But it doesn't end here.
The Torah's final book is D'varim (Deuteronomy). D'varim means "words", and the book relates all the words shared by the once wordless Moshe with the children of the Bamidbar generation. It's a remarkable revolution: he talks, they listen. He teaches, they learn. Here is dialogue, shared vision, shared values, shared direction. The most important word in D'varim is Sh'ma -- "Listen!" ... It is a book of listening. It is a book filled with the calm of consensus and confidence. At the end, as at the beginning, creation overcomes chaos...and it is good.
Why does the Torah juxtapose such antithetical books -- the holy vision of Vayikra, the discordant bedlam of Bamidbar, the calm of Dvarim? Why such contradictory visions of human life and human community? Because all life is an oscillation among them -- vision and division, chaos and consensus. This is the inner life, as we alternatively grasp and then grow out of our conceptions of life's purpose and mission. This is family life -- as we learn to hold onto one another, and at the same time, learn to let go. And this is the life of human communities. No community's consensus lasts forever. Nor should it. We must, periodically, re-enter Bamidbar to find a new course, a new vision, a new language. But the Torah offers this wisdom: Out of Bamidbar comes Dvarim -- out of rebellion and wandering will come consensus and direction, just as out of chaos comes Creation. That's the Torah's faith.
Shabbat Shalom.
Friday, March 4, 2011
Shabbat Shalom-March 4-5, 2011
Pekudei 2011
Fashioning Your Life
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
We are all builders.
Our lives are our most precious endeavor. Our daily living is in fact a lifelong barn-raising; each one of us, embedded in our family and our community sets the plan and lifts the struts that form our abode on this earth. We are the fashioners of our lives. Yet everyday many of us are lost in the monotony, spending our waking hours commuting to work, coming home, making dinner, and finally hitting the pillow exhausted at the end of the night just to start it all over again. Have you stopped for a moment and looked seriously at your life and asked, “What is all this toiling for? What are the foundations of my life? What am I building here, exactly?” This is perhaps the deepest and most important question of human existence. It is the “why” of living.
Every human being that has ever lived has asked questions about existence. In many ways it is our questions that make us human. But what are our answers to the “why”? The place in which we look for meaning when we build our lives will dictate those answers. Advertisers know this. The first place they want you to look is to the material world. If you purchase this house, this car, this techno-gizmo you will have meaning in your life. “It’s the best part of waking up.” “It’s the real thing.” “Can you hear me now?” They tell you that if you weigh and measure your life by the size of your hard drive you will find the meaning that you are searching for. Until, of course, someone else has a better-faster gizmo, a nicer house, a newer car. Then you realize that you didn’t answer the “why” of life, you sublimated with a “what.” And you can’t answer a “why” with a “what.”
It was nearly two thousand years ago when the rabbis taught that “blessing is not to be found in anything that has been already weighed or measured or numbered, but only in a thing hidden from sight (TB Ta’anit 8b).” You cannot build the meaning of life through material facts. The wondrous significance of your life goes beyond mere fact. To find true blessings you must cross the divide of experience from the “what” of living to the “why”. For that a more infinite answer must be sought. You must move from the world of fact to the world of value.
The Torah is a book that recognizes the depths of human striving. In this week’s Torah portion, Pekudei, Bezalel, the chief artisan of the Israelites, builds all the physical material that is necessary for the operation of the Mishkan. Given what we know, this seems to be the wrong answer to the right question. How can the Israelites, even at God’s behest, build a “what” to answer the ultimate question of human existence? The rabbinic tradition is of some help here. The midrash speaks of Bezalel as God’s partner in creation. After all, his name means, “in God’s shadow” or “In the image of God.” Bezalel had the knowledge of how to fashion the objects of creation from the values of creation. “He fashioned the menorah from the aspect of love in order to teach love…He fashioned the altar from the aspect of awe in order to teach awe.”
When he built the Mishkan, Bezalel knew that to be a partner to God, to live in God’s shadow, is to build a life in which facts are subservient to values. This is what separated the Mishkan from the Golden Calf. The yellow cow was a mere thing. The Miskhan, however, was a place infused with the sacred. It was where the “what” and the “why” met. At its center, lives a God who is not a mere fact, an object, but the Infinite loadstone of all value; a Being whose aspects can be represented by holy metaphors, but which no metaphor can wholly represent. The Mishkan is the place where human beings meet their “why”.
And so it is with us. Like Bezalel, we are created in the image of God. The craving we feel inside our hearts for meaning cannot be satiated by mere objects, because at the center of our existence, like the center of the Mishkan, is something much more Infinite. And as we fashion our life, as we search to fill that vacuum of significance, we must remember to place within our holiest place not mere objects, but sacred values. We must learn to answer the “why” not with a “what,” but with the Infinite, -the Holy One in whom we share a sacred space.
Shabbat Shalom
Fashioning Your Life
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
We are all builders.
Our lives are our most precious endeavor. Our daily living is in fact a lifelong barn-raising; each one of us, embedded in our family and our community sets the plan and lifts the struts that form our abode on this earth. We are the fashioners of our lives. Yet everyday many of us are lost in the monotony, spending our waking hours commuting to work, coming home, making dinner, and finally hitting the pillow exhausted at the end of the night just to start it all over again. Have you stopped for a moment and looked seriously at your life and asked, “What is all this toiling for? What are the foundations of my life? What am I building here, exactly?” This is perhaps the deepest and most important question of human existence. It is the “why” of living.
Every human being that has ever lived has asked questions about existence. In many ways it is our questions that make us human. But what are our answers to the “why”? The place in which we look for meaning when we build our lives will dictate those answers. Advertisers know this. The first place they want you to look is to the material world. If you purchase this house, this car, this techno-gizmo you will have meaning in your life. “It’s the best part of waking up.” “It’s the real thing.” “Can you hear me now?” They tell you that if you weigh and measure your life by the size of your hard drive you will find the meaning that you are searching for. Until, of course, someone else has a better-faster gizmo, a nicer house, a newer car. Then you realize that you didn’t answer the “why” of life, you sublimated with a “what.” And you can’t answer a “why” with a “what.”
It was nearly two thousand years ago when the rabbis taught that “blessing is not to be found in anything that has been already weighed or measured or numbered, but only in a thing hidden from sight (TB Ta’anit 8b).” You cannot build the meaning of life through material facts. The wondrous significance of your life goes beyond mere fact. To find true blessings you must cross the divide of experience from the “what” of living to the “why”. For that a more infinite answer must be sought. You must move from the world of fact to the world of value.
The Torah is a book that recognizes the depths of human striving. In this week’s Torah portion, Pekudei, Bezalel, the chief artisan of the Israelites, builds all the physical material that is necessary for the operation of the Mishkan. Given what we know, this seems to be the wrong answer to the right question. How can the Israelites, even at God’s behest, build a “what” to answer the ultimate question of human existence? The rabbinic tradition is of some help here. The midrash speaks of Bezalel as God’s partner in creation. After all, his name means, “in God’s shadow” or “In the image of God.” Bezalel had the knowledge of how to fashion the objects of creation from the values of creation. “He fashioned the menorah from the aspect of love in order to teach love…He fashioned the altar from the aspect of awe in order to teach awe.”
When he built the Mishkan, Bezalel knew that to be a partner to God, to live in God’s shadow, is to build a life in which facts are subservient to values. This is what separated the Mishkan from the Golden Calf. The yellow cow was a mere thing. The Miskhan, however, was a place infused with the sacred. It was where the “what” and the “why” met. At its center, lives a God who is not a mere fact, an object, but the Infinite loadstone of all value; a Being whose aspects can be represented by holy metaphors, but which no metaphor can wholly represent. The Mishkan is the place where human beings meet their “why”.
And so it is with us. Like Bezalel, we are created in the image of God. The craving we feel inside our hearts for meaning cannot be satiated by mere objects, because at the center of our existence, like the center of the Mishkan, is something much more Infinite. And as we fashion our life, as we search to fill that vacuum of significance, we must remember to place within our holiest place not mere objects, but sacred values. We must learn to answer the “why” not with a “what,” but with the Infinite, -the Holy One in whom we share a sacred space.
Shabbat Shalom
Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Shabbat Shalom --- February 25-26, 2011
Parashat Vayakheil
Cantor Phil Baron
On a Friday night in late January, as part of the Shabbat Shira celebration, our congregational choir premiered 16 new musical works. These were in many cases very challenging pieces with odd time signatures, close harmonies, or sudden dynamic changes.
To achieve success with this material required what this week’s Torah portion calls chochma, t’vunah v’da’at, uv’chol m’lacha – wisdom, insight, knowledge and craftsmanship. The Torah was not referring to the grand choir of the ancient Temple – that came much later. Vayakheil deals with the creation of the Mishkan, the Tabernacle or portable shul where our people worshipped until the creation of the Temple. Its elaborate furnishings and sacred objects had to be lovingly fashioned, forged and fastened from whatever resources were at hand. Moshe needed the most expert designers, craftsmen, carpenters, weavers, seamstresses, jewelers and metal workers. He called for them, “and they came.”
But this was not enough. He also asked for kol n’div libo, everyone motivated by his heart. And all of them came too, everyone -- the men and women who were moved to be a part of the sacred task, they all showed up. In fact, the success of the Mishkan, like almost any endeavor of a religious community, depended on participation of all the people, skilled and unskilled. The pure motivation and love of the volunteer was considered equal to the finely-tuned knowledge and craft of the artisan.
In the Mishkan story, even the names of the two contractors in charge reveal the theme. B’tzaleil (“in the image of God”) and Oholiav (“father of tents”). Why two bosses? The Torah teaches that the tent-master’s experience was invaluable, but that he needed the fervor and dedication of one striving with pure motivation for the glory of God alone.
If you look at the many volunteer organizations here at VBS, from Chesed Connection to the Healing Center to Jewish World Watch to the many projects of Sisterhood, Men’s Club and many others, you will find the same combination of qualities the Torah speaks about. For as it says in this week’s parasha, “Everyone who excelled in ability and everyone whose spirit moved him came.”
Like so many of our congregational organizations, the choir is made up of skilled professionals as well as avid volunteers. When I first approached Dr. Green and the choir about this year’s Shabbat Shira I feared that the sheer quantity of pieces, not to mention their difficulty, might be an insurmountable obstacle. To my delight, they responded with enthusiasm and devotion -- and weeks of hard work. Yes, there were a few professional singers sprinkled in, but the success of the service was due to the combination of these “ringers” and their volunteer counterparts.
Ultimately, what holds the artist and the amateur (“lover”) together? The conductor, for one. But the 18th century Chassidic commentator Menachum Nachum has another suggestion -- that the work of the Mishkan is made whole with nothing less than the Divine Presence. He points out that the sockets joining the upper and lower parts of the Mishkan, as described in Vayakheil, are called “adonim” like the name of God (Adonai). Without these, the whole enterprise crashes to earth.
Making our Shabbat Shira work took wisdom, insight, knowledge, craftsmanship, and the joy and devotion of the volunteer. But religious music, like the many wonderful community projects we participate in also requires a kind of divine inspiration as the joining principle that makes creation possible.
Shabbat Shalom
Cantor Phil Baron
On a Friday night in late January, as part of the Shabbat Shira celebration, our congregational choir premiered 16 new musical works. These were in many cases very challenging pieces with odd time signatures, close harmonies, or sudden dynamic changes.
To achieve success with this material required what this week’s Torah portion calls chochma, t’vunah v’da’at, uv’chol m’lacha – wisdom, insight, knowledge and craftsmanship. The Torah was not referring to the grand choir of the ancient Temple – that came much later. Vayakheil deals with the creation of the Mishkan, the Tabernacle or portable shul where our people worshipped until the creation of the Temple. Its elaborate furnishings and sacred objects had to be lovingly fashioned, forged and fastened from whatever resources were at hand. Moshe needed the most expert designers, craftsmen, carpenters, weavers, seamstresses, jewelers and metal workers. He called for them, “and they came.”
But this was not enough. He also asked for kol n’div libo, everyone motivated by his heart. And all of them came too, everyone -- the men and women who were moved to be a part of the sacred task, they all showed up. In fact, the success of the Mishkan, like almost any endeavor of a religious community, depended on participation of all the people, skilled and unskilled. The pure motivation and love of the volunteer was considered equal to the finely-tuned knowledge and craft of the artisan.
In the Mishkan story, even the names of the two contractors in charge reveal the theme. B’tzaleil (“in the image of God”) and Oholiav (“father of tents”). Why two bosses? The Torah teaches that the tent-master’s experience was invaluable, but that he needed the fervor and dedication of one striving with pure motivation for the glory of God alone.
If you look at the many volunteer organizations here at VBS, from Chesed Connection to the Healing Center to Jewish World Watch to the many projects of Sisterhood, Men’s Club and many others, you will find the same combination of qualities the Torah speaks about. For as it says in this week’s parasha, “Everyone who excelled in ability and everyone whose spirit moved him came.”
Like so many of our congregational organizations, the choir is made up of skilled professionals as well as avid volunteers. When I first approached Dr. Green and the choir about this year’s Shabbat Shira I feared that the sheer quantity of pieces, not to mention their difficulty, might be an insurmountable obstacle. To my delight, they responded with enthusiasm and devotion -- and weeks of hard work. Yes, there were a few professional singers sprinkled in, but the success of the service was due to the combination of these “ringers” and their volunteer counterparts.
Ultimately, what holds the artist and the amateur (“lover”) together? The conductor, for one. But the 18th century Chassidic commentator Menachum Nachum has another suggestion -- that the work of the Mishkan is made whole with nothing less than the Divine Presence. He points out that the sockets joining the upper and lower parts of the Mishkan, as described in Vayakheil, are called “adonim” like the name of God (Adonai). Without these, the whole enterprise crashes to earth.
Making our Shabbat Shira work took wisdom, insight, knowledge, craftsmanship, and the joy and devotion of the volunteer. But religious music, like the many wonderful community projects we participate in also requires a kind of divine inspiration as the joining principle that makes creation possible.
Shabbat Shalom
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Shabbat Shalom -- February 18-19, 2011
Parshah Ki Tissa Ex. 30:11-34:35
Paul Steinberg
He [Moses] said, “Oh, let me behold Your Presence!” And He answered, “I will make all My goodness pass before you, and I will proclaim before you the name Adonai, and the grace that I grant and compassion that I show. But,” He said, “you cannot see My face, for man may not see Me and live.” And the Lord said, “See, there is a place near Me. Station yourself on the rock and as My presence passes by, I will put you in a cleft of the rock and shield you with My hand until I have passed by. Then I will take My hand away and you will see My back; but My face must not be seen.
- Exodus 33:18-23
In the Ron Howard film Parenthood, Gil Buckman (Steve Martin) suffers with an array of life stresses, including being passed up for a raise and promotion, financial problems, a son who keeps having panic attacks, a gambling-addicted brother, and a hard-headed father. Gil is angry, doesn’t understand why things have to be so hard all the time, and he feels as though he has no control. All the while, his seemingly senile grandma continues to speak of a random memory of riding a roller-coaster. By the end of the movie, Gil learns that the roller-coaster is just the right metaphor for life, and that a lesson we must learn is to go with it, including its ups and downs, twists and turns.
Some of us may understand why Gil wasn’t enjoying the “rollercoaster.” Sometimes the stress seems impossible to bear; we feel alone and afraid within the uncertainty of it all. We even wonder where God, the Source of Life and Energy must be in this – how could a loving God allow for a world filled with so much stress? Where is God anyway and why does life have to be this way?
In Parshat Ki Tissa, after many ups and downs, including the giving of the tablets of the Pact, the offense and subsequent punishment of the golden calf, and God’s threat to destroy Israel, Moses cannot help but to call out to God, “Oh, let me behold Your Presence!” (Ex. 33:18)
Moses, stressed and afraid, perhaps feeling all alone, wanted to see God. But what would he gain from seeing God, from the sight of God’s Presence? How would this help him? One of the most interesting, traditional answers to this question is Maimonides’s suggestion that Moses wanted to know God – to intellectually grasp and understand who or what God is and God’s motivations. In other words, he wanted to be one with God’s mind.
This understanding illuminates something very important about human psychology and spirituality. Maimonides points out that Moses, like most of us, would love to come to know God’s “mind,” especially during times of stress. We would love to know why pain and suffering happen, why life isn’t easy all the time and why we have to work so hard. We would love to have the mental and emotional control of stepping outside of life, for maybe, just maybe, if we could step outside of life and look down upon it from above, we might be able to absent ourselves from the pain and fear. If we knew how the roller-coaster was built, so to speak, and where the “scary parts” were, we could close our eyes and open them again in time for the “fun parts” ahead.
God, of course, does not oblige Moses’s request, rather God shields his face as “God’s goodness” passes by. A traditional understanding for why God covers Moses’s face is that if Moses were to see God and, in turn, know God’s “mind” he would have to take on the unbearable responsibility for all humanity, as God does. Dr. Avivah Zornberg, however, offers an alternative explanation, noting that this humbling response underscores the essential challenge of the human spiritual condition. She writes that this teaches us that “the only union possible is in relationship, which means separateness.” That is to say, ultimately, we are individuals and must be able to personally move beyond fear and pain on our own terms; others may offer strength, support, and guidance, but it is up to each of us individually to actually live life and endure.
Perhaps the most poignant teaching about this particular encounter is from Rashi (Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki, France, 1040-1105). He says that, although God does not grant his request, when God passes by Moses he is taught how to pray – how to call to God. Here, Rashi recognizes that even though we may never be able to behold God’s Presence, when we are in need, alone, afraid, and we yearn to be connected, we have the gift of prayer. This is a true gift because we all crave to call out to the universe and express our fears, just as on the roller-coaster we need to squeal and scream. We also need to speak our desires, our hopes, our gratitude, and confessions, for somehow in the speaking of what we hold within we cease to be alone – the energy expressed binds us with the energy of the divine and all the universe.
Life will take us up and down, twist and flip us, and we must accept that there are simply some things in God’s hands alone and out of our own. However, we are a people that believes in the power of words. Words can create and destroy worlds and they can also topple the walls between heaven and earth. The words of prayer, even a single one, can bring us closer to God, closer to balance, and closer to inner-peace. These words are a part of the self-healing that is necessary every day in our roller-coaster of a world.
Shabbat Shalom.
Paul Steinberg
He [Moses] said, “Oh, let me behold Your Presence!” And He answered, “I will make all My goodness pass before you, and I will proclaim before you the name Adonai, and the grace that I grant and compassion that I show. But,” He said, “you cannot see My face, for man may not see Me and live.” And the Lord said, “See, there is a place near Me. Station yourself on the rock and as My presence passes by, I will put you in a cleft of the rock and shield you with My hand until I have passed by. Then I will take My hand away and you will see My back; but My face must not be seen.
- Exodus 33:18-23
In the Ron Howard film Parenthood, Gil Buckman (Steve Martin) suffers with an array of life stresses, including being passed up for a raise and promotion, financial problems, a son who keeps having panic attacks, a gambling-addicted brother, and a hard-headed father. Gil is angry, doesn’t understand why things have to be so hard all the time, and he feels as though he has no control. All the while, his seemingly senile grandma continues to speak of a random memory of riding a roller-coaster. By the end of the movie, Gil learns that the roller-coaster is just the right metaphor for life, and that a lesson we must learn is to go with it, including its ups and downs, twists and turns.
Some of us may understand why Gil wasn’t enjoying the “rollercoaster.” Sometimes the stress seems impossible to bear; we feel alone and afraid within the uncertainty of it all. We even wonder where God, the Source of Life and Energy must be in this – how could a loving God allow for a world filled with so much stress? Where is God anyway and why does life have to be this way?
In Parshat Ki Tissa, after many ups and downs, including the giving of the tablets of the Pact, the offense and subsequent punishment of the golden calf, and God’s threat to destroy Israel, Moses cannot help but to call out to God, “Oh, let me behold Your Presence!” (Ex. 33:18)
Moses, stressed and afraid, perhaps feeling all alone, wanted to see God. But what would he gain from seeing God, from the sight of God’s Presence? How would this help him? One of the most interesting, traditional answers to this question is Maimonides’s suggestion that Moses wanted to know God – to intellectually grasp and understand who or what God is and God’s motivations. In other words, he wanted to be one with God’s mind.
This understanding illuminates something very important about human psychology and spirituality. Maimonides points out that Moses, like most of us, would love to come to know God’s “mind,” especially during times of stress. We would love to know why pain and suffering happen, why life isn’t easy all the time and why we have to work so hard. We would love to have the mental and emotional control of stepping outside of life, for maybe, just maybe, if we could step outside of life and look down upon it from above, we might be able to absent ourselves from the pain and fear. If we knew how the roller-coaster was built, so to speak, and where the “scary parts” were, we could close our eyes and open them again in time for the “fun parts” ahead.
God, of course, does not oblige Moses’s request, rather God shields his face as “God’s goodness” passes by. A traditional understanding for why God covers Moses’s face is that if Moses were to see God and, in turn, know God’s “mind” he would have to take on the unbearable responsibility for all humanity, as God does. Dr. Avivah Zornberg, however, offers an alternative explanation, noting that this humbling response underscores the essential challenge of the human spiritual condition. She writes that this teaches us that “the only union possible is in relationship, which means separateness.” That is to say, ultimately, we are individuals and must be able to personally move beyond fear and pain on our own terms; others may offer strength, support, and guidance, but it is up to each of us individually to actually live life and endure.
Perhaps the most poignant teaching about this particular encounter is from Rashi (Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki, France, 1040-1105). He says that, although God does not grant his request, when God passes by Moses he is taught how to pray – how to call to God. Here, Rashi recognizes that even though we may never be able to behold God’s Presence, when we are in need, alone, afraid, and we yearn to be connected, we have the gift of prayer. This is a true gift because we all crave to call out to the universe and express our fears, just as on the roller-coaster we need to squeal and scream. We also need to speak our desires, our hopes, our gratitude, and confessions, for somehow in the speaking of what we hold within we cease to be alone – the energy expressed binds us with the energy of the divine and all the universe.
Life will take us up and down, twist and flip us, and we must accept that there are simply some things in God’s hands alone and out of our own. However, we are a people that believes in the power of words. Words can create and destroy worlds and they can also topple the walls between heaven and earth. The words of prayer, even a single one, can bring us closer to God, closer to balance, and closer to inner-peace. These words are a part of the self-healing that is necessary every day in our roller-coaster of a world.
Shabbat Shalom.
Monday, February 7, 2011
Shabbat Shalom -- February 11-12, 2011
Parashat Tetzaveh
Rabbi Harold M. Schulweis
The parsha of the week deals with the sacred, the Temple, and priesthood. But you can find God in a piece of bread and in a cup of wine.
At home I was taught that if a piece of bread fell from the table, it should quickly be picked up and kissed. Bread was God's gift. I heard wondrous stories about the sacredness of a shtikel broit, "a little piece of bread.”
Once, around the third meal of the Sabbath, the disciples of the Rebbe persisted in asking him to tell them where God is. He remained silent, but at last recited the Motzi and pointed to the loaf of bread on the table. God in a piece of bread? There is theology in a piece of bread. And it is important, particularly for children of entitlement living in the Garden of Gucci, to understand Ben-Zoma's observation: "What labors did Adam have to carry out before he obtained bread to eat? He plowed, he sowed, he reaped, he bound the sheaves, he threshed and winnowed and selected the ears, he ground, then sifted the flour, kneaded and baked, and then, finally, he ate. And I get up and find all things done for me" (Berachot 58a).
Ha-motzi lechem min ha-aretz — that which brings bread out of the earth is godly. Consider the process, the givenness of earth and water and seed, as well as the human energy and ingenuity to turn sheaf into edible cake. "Which is greater, the works of man or of God?" the pagan Tinneius Rufus asked. Rabbi Akiva replied that the works of man are greater than those of God, and illustrated his contention by presenting Tinneius Rufus with sheaves of wheat and loaves of cake. The cakes are greater, not that the works of God are less worthy, but that the full measure of divinity is expressed through the interaction between God's nature and the crown of His creation.
The Motzi is not recited over sheaves of wheat and the Kiddush is not recited over clusters of grapes. The Motzi is recited over the bread, which is made through human effort and the Kiddush is recited over the fruit of the vine, which human ingenuity cultivates. Both benedictions exemplify the power and goodness of God expressed through the works of human beings.
Shabbat Shalom
Rabbi Harold M. Schulweis
The parsha of the week deals with the sacred, the Temple, and priesthood. But you can find God in a piece of bread and in a cup of wine.
At home I was taught that if a piece of bread fell from the table, it should quickly be picked up and kissed. Bread was God's gift. I heard wondrous stories about the sacredness of a shtikel broit, "a little piece of bread.”
Once, around the third meal of the Sabbath, the disciples of the Rebbe persisted in asking him to tell them where God is. He remained silent, but at last recited the Motzi and pointed to the loaf of bread on the table. God in a piece of bread? There is theology in a piece of bread. And it is important, particularly for children of entitlement living in the Garden of Gucci, to understand Ben-Zoma's observation: "What labors did Adam have to carry out before he obtained bread to eat? He plowed, he sowed, he reaped, he bound the sheaves, he threshed and winnowed and selected the ears, he ground, then sifted the flour, kneaded and baked, and then, finally, he ate. And I get up and find all things done for me" (Berachot 58a).
Ha-motzi lechem min ha-aretz — that which brings bread out of the earth is godly. Consider the process, the givenness of earth and water and seed, as well as the human energy and ingenuity to turn sheaf into edible cake. "Which is greater, the works of man or of God?" the pagan Tinneius Rufus asked. Rabbi Akiva replied that the works of man are greater than those of God, and illustrated his contention by presenting Tinneius Rufus with sheaves of wheat and loaves of cake. The cakes are greater, not that the works of God are less worthy, but that the full measure of divinity is expressed through the interaction between God's nature and the crown of His creation.
The Motzi is not recited over sheaves of wheat and the Kiddush is not recited over clusters of grapes. The Motzi is recited over the bread, which is made through human effort and the Kiddush is recited over the fruit of the vine, which human ingenuity cultivates. Both benedictions exemplify the power and goodness of God expressed through the works of human beings.
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, February 4, 2011
Shabbat Shalom - February 4-5, 2011
I WILL MEET YOU THERE
Parshat Terumah
Rabbi Joshua Hoffman
There’s no place like home. Two or three steps out of the car and I already feel the change taking place. After a long day, it’s respite. After a frustrating day, it’s sanctuary. After a sad and difficult day, it’s comfort. Once the key turns the lock and the eyes turn toward the mezuzah, I’m home. I can walk down the hall without thinking, catching all the irregularities (and with young children, this is manifest in Matchbox cars and Barbie dolls) in a glance. Everything is in its place, more or less. It is familiar.
Details upon details are planned out, drawn up, and crafted with elegant design; each facet and corner of our domicile life is carefully considered. Even the clutter is there by intention, whether we admit it or not. And all this effort we expend is to make certain that when we cross the threshold we enter into a space that is protective and uplifting. The objects that adorn our walls and our living spaces carry a sentimental value that often far outweighs their market value.
Building the Mishkan, the sacred dwelling place of the Divine was much like building a home. Each detail enumerated in the Torah text was impeccably placed. Building God’s home demanded nothing less than flawless design. Given that there is little narrative that spans this section of the Torah, there are mountains of interpretation heaped upon each ring, each curtain, each post, and each ritual object. There is a connection to be found in the details. That is what sentimental value represents.
It’s in this familiarity, this attachment to space that we can be brought closer to God. In the midst of God’s plans for the Ark of the Covenant, God says, “I will meet you there,” “No-dah-tee lekha sham” meaning God’s voice would be heard from the place above the ark, containing the most sentimental object of all, the Torah. The word familiar in Hebrew is “Ya-doo-ah” or “known.”
17th century rabbi Shlomo Ephraim Luntschitz, better known as the Kli Yakar (the Precious Vessel), suggests that God chose to meet us above the Ark precisely because it was a familiar place. It was the place where seekers of God’s presence would find uplift and protection, wisdom and strength. It was because God’s presence would be found in the known places of our lives. It is in the Torah that our family – our familiarity is housed.
“God is only found in a place where peace is found,” continues the Kli Yakar, suggesting that a life of Torah, a striving of Torah builds a home of peace. It is as Eli Wiesel once observed, “I do not recall a Jewish home without a book on the table.” He suggests that making our homes a place of Torah, a place where Torah is familiar, is the place where God meets us even today. We should merit such presence and peace in our lives too.
Shabbat Shalom
Parshat Terumah
Rabbi Joshua Hoffman
There’s no place like home. Two or three steps out of the car and I already feel the change taking place. After a long day, it’s respite. After a frustrating day, it’s sanctuary. After a sad and difficult day, it’s comfort. Once the key turns the lock and the eyes turn toward the mezuzah, I’m home. I can walk down the hall without thinking, catching all the irregularities (and with young children, this is manifest in Matchbox cars and Barbie dolls) in a glance. Everything is in its place, more or less. It is familiar.
Details upon details are planned out, drawn up, and crafted with elegant design; each facet and corner of our domicile life is carefully considered. Even the clutter is there by intention, whether we admit it or not. And all this effort we expend is to make certain that when we cross the threshold we enter into a space that is protective and uplifting. The objects that adorn our walls and our living spaces carry a sentimental value that often far outweighs their market value.
Building the Mishkan, the sacred dwelling place of the Divine was much like building a home. Each detail enumerated in the Torah text was impeccably placed. Building God’s home demanded nothing less than flawless design. Given that there is little narrative that spans this section of the Torah, there are mountains of interpretation heaped upon each ring, each curtain, each post, and each ritual object. There is a connection to be found in the details. That is what sentimental value represents.
It’s in this familiarity, this attachment to space that we can be brought closer to God. In the midst of God’s plans for the Ark of the Covenant, God says, “I will meet you there,” “No-dah-tee lekha sham” meaning God’s voice would be heard from the place above the ark, containing the most sentimental object of all, the Torah. The word familiar in Hebrew is “Ya-doo-ah” or “known.”
17th century rabbi Shlomo Ephraim Luntschitz, better known as the Kli Yakar (the Precious Vessel), suggests that God chose to meet us above the Ark precisely because it was a familiar place. It was the place where seekers of God’s presence would find uplift and protection, wisdom and strength. It was because God’s presence would be found in the known places of our lives. It is in the Torah that our family – our familiarity is housed.
“God is only found in a place where peace is found,” continues the Kli Yakar, suggesting that a life of Torah, a striving of Torah builds a home of peace. It is as Eli Wiesel once observed, “I do not recall a Jewish home without a book on the table.” He suggests that making our homes a place of Torah, a place where Torah is familiar, is the place where God meets us even today. We should merit such presence and peace in our lives too.
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, January 28, 2011
Shabbat Shalom--January 28-29, 2011
“Mishpatim” – Rules!
Cantor Herschel Fox
When I was a child at an Orthodox Day School in Winnipeg I did not like this week’s Torah Portion of “Mishpatim” – (Rules). “Breishit” the first book of the Torah was full of beautiful stories – Creation, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, the Brothers, etc. All of a sudden this week’s Torah Portion begins “These are the rules you shall set before them:” We are now served a bundle of rules! Kids don’t like rules. I did not like this portion of “Exodus”, the second book of the Bible.
As I grew up I began to realize that we need rules. Without some rules, indeed, our whole society would fall apart. The Torah wisely gives us a blueprint for our lives.
“Mishpatim” discusses unpleasant matters, because in life we encounter them. What happens when someone is murdered? What if the murder was an accident? We are guided in “Mishpatim” to try our very best to deal compassionately with our fellow man even when there is conflict. We cannot run away from problems.
In today’s world many young people don’t like to face reality. They run away from it, either physically or through alcohol or drugs. Many will say “I’m spiritual” so I don’t join a synagogue to pray – I can meditate in the Himalayan Mountains.
The Torah, I believe, deeply understands man’s nature better than humans do. Though there is beauty and spirituality in life, there are rules and unpleasant moments each and every one of us has to endure during our lifetime. The Torah gives us a clear set of laws to live by
The Torah in my opinion is a wonderful study of “Balance.” After numerous rules, “Mishpatim” ends with Moses going up the mountain!
“The presence of the Lord abode on Mount Sinai, and the cloud hid it for six days. On the seventh day He called to Moses from the midst of the cloud. Now the presence of the Lord appeared in the sight of the Israelites as a consuming fire on the top of the mountain. Moses went inside the cloud and ascended the mountain; and Moses remained on the mountain forty days and forty nights.” Now Moses had time for his spiritual preparations!
While our six weekdays are filled with many obligations between work and family we all feel over-committed with mundane events. But then, each week, Shabbat arrives and gives us a time for ourselves so we can elevate our souls and find our own spiritual rejuvenation.
I wish you all Shabbat Shalom, a peaceful and spiritual Shabbat.
Cantor Herschel Fox
When I was a child at an Orthodox Day School in Winnipeg I did not like this week’s Torah Portion of “Mishpatim” – (Rules). “Breishit” the first book of the Torah was full of beautiful stories – Creation, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, the Brothers, etc. All of a sudden this week’s Torah Portion begins “These are the rules you shall set before them:” We are now served a bundle of rules! Kids don’t like rules. I did not like this portion of “Exodus”, the second book of the Bible.
As I grew up I began to realize that we need rules. Without some rules, indeed, our whole society would fall apart. The Torah wisely gives us a blueprint for our lives.
“Mishpatim” discusses unpleasant matters, because in life we encounter them. What happens when someone is murdered? What if the murder was an accident? We are guided in “Mishpatim” to try our very best to deal compassionately with our fellow man even when there is conflict. We cannot run away from problems.
In today’s world many young people don’t like to face reality. They run away from it, either physically or through alcohol or drugs. Many will say “I’m spiritual” so I don’t join a synagogue to pray – I can meditate in the Himalayan Mountains.
The Torah, I believe, deeply understands man’s nature better than humans do. Though there is beauty and spirituality in life, there are rules and unpleasant moments each and every one of us has to endure during our lifetime. The Torah gives us a clear set of laws to live by
The Torah in my opinion is a wonderful study of “Balance.” After numerous rules, “Mishpatim” ends with Moses going up the mountain!
“The presence of the Lord abode on Mount Sinai, and the cloud hid it for six days. On the seventh day He called to Moses from the midst of the cloud. Now the presence of the Lord appeared in the sight of the Israelites as a consuming fire on the top of the mountain. Moses went inside the cloud and ascended the mountain; and Moses remained on the mountain forty days and forty nights.” Now Moses had time for his spiritual preparations!
While our six weekdays are filled with many obligations between work and family we all feel over-committed with mundane events. But then, each week, Shabbat arrives and gives us a time for ourselves so we can elevate our souls and find our own spiritual rejuvenation.
I wish you all Shabbat Shalom, a peaceful and spiritual Shabbat.
Friday, January 21, 2011
Shabbat Shalom- January 21-22, 2011
YITRO
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Once a stranger approached Hillel and Shammai, the great sages of the first century, with a request: "Teach me the Torah while I stand on one foot." First, he brought the request to Shammai. According to the Talmud, Shammai picked up a builder's rule, smacked him along side his head and dismissed him. So he came to Hillel. "Teach me the Torah on one foot." Hillel taught him: "That which is hateful to you, do not do to your fellow. That is the whole Torah, all the rest is commentary. Zil u'gemar, now, go and learn." Hillel's answer is loving, accepting and kind. But Shammai was right.
"Teach me the Torah on one foot." Rabbis hear this daily. They want spiritual enlightenment but without spiritual discipline. They seek inner peace without facing their own dark side. They demand Torah in monaural -- monolithic, doctrinal, authoritative. A simple truth to live by -- void of complexity, detail and nuance. And quickly. Who has time to master all those dusty books?
We are bound to disappoint them. Because Judaism never comes that way. That's not how Jews think. In our tradition, there is a distinct pattern, a texture of thinking. You find it in Bible, Mishna, Talmud. It is never on one foot. It is always dialectical: In argument, in tension, in polarity. Truth is too big to put into simple maxims. It is too important to set down in simple discursive rules. It always comes in contradiction.
Rav Naftali the Ropshizer Rebbe, told his Hasidim that before he was born an angel appeared and showed him a tablet divided into two columns. On the right side it offered Talmud Taaneet: "The learned man should be a fiery furnace." On the left side it quoted Talmud Sanhedrin: "The meek and lowly shall inherit the world to come." On the right side from Talmud Brachot: "Man should be wise in his fear of God." And on the left side from the Yalkut, "You should be simple-hearted in your love of the Lord." On the right side from the Talmud: "God wants the heart." And on the left side, from the Prophet Jeremiah: "The heart of His people is corrupt and wayward." And the Rebbe pondered the contradictions. Until he heard the voice of the angels announcing, "You are now to be born." Whereupon he resolved in his heart to follow both columns no matter the contradictions.
To be Jewish is to live both columns. It is to live with tension, ambivalence, and paradox. "Polarity," wrote Abraham Joshua Heschel, "is at the heart of Judaism."
Consider this image: A pendulum, swinging back and forth. The arc described by the pendulum is truth. If you stop the pendulum anywhere along the arc and you say: "This point here at the zenith, this is the truth" ... or if you stop it down at the midpoint and say, "This is truth" -- you are wrong. You will always be wrong. Because truth is the pendulum in motion.
The philosopher Isaiah Berlin taught that every difficult, complex problem -- in politics, life, or thought -- has a simple answer. Which is always wrong. Not just wrong, deadly. For throughout human history, we Jews have always been the exception to somebody's rule. We have always been the anomaly to someone's absolute. And we have suffered for it. This is why extremism of any kind make us so anxious. It is what scares us about fundamentalism and simplistic moralism. We respond viscerally. Because whatever reduces truth to a simple absolute, reduces us.
Every morning we recite, "Blessed is God who creates light and darkness, peace and all else." Ours is not a monism, reducing all experience to one principle, one idea, one path -- denying the contrasts and the reality of tensions. But neither are we dualists who break everything into sharp disjunctions between good and evil, light and darkness, religious and secular, us and them. We are monotheists. We can acknowledge the contrasts in experience because we affirm that beneath them there is a basic unity. This is the meaning of the first of the Ten Commandments read this week all over the world: Ani Adonai Eloheychem. I am the Lord your God. In worshipping one God, we embrace life's rich complexity.
Shabbat Shalom
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Once a stranger approached Hillel and Shammai, the great sages of the first century, with a request: "Teach me the Torah while I stand on one foot." First, he brought the request to Shammai. According to the Talmud, Shammai picked up a builder's rule, smacked him along side his head and dismissed him. So he came to Hillel. "Teach me the Torah on one foot." Hillel taught him: "That which is hateful to you, do not do to your fellow. That is the whole Torah, all the rest is commentary. Zil u'gemar, now, go and learn." Hillel's answer is loving, accepting and kind. But Shammai was right.
"Teach me the Torah on one foot." Rabbis hear this daily. They want spiritual enlightenment but without spiritual discipline. They seek inner peace without facing their own dark side. They demand Torah in monaural -- monolithic, doctrinal, authoritative. A simple truth to live by -- void of complexity, detail and nuance. And quickly. Who has time to master all those dusty books?
We are bound to disappoint them. Because Judaism never comes that way. That's not how Jews think. In our tradition, there is a distinct pattern, a texture of thinking. You find it in Bible, Mishna, Talmud. It is never on one foot. It is always dialectical: In argument, in tension, in polarity. Truth is too big to put into simple maxims. It is too important to set down in simple discursive rules. It always comes in contradiction.
Rav Naftali the Ropshizer Rebbe, told his Hasidim that before he was born an angel appeared and showed him a tablet divided into two columns. On the right side it offered Talmud Taaneet: "The learned man should be a fiery furnace." On the left side it quoted Talmud Sanhedrin: "The meek and lowly shall inherit the world to come." On the right side from Talmud Brachot: "Man should be wise in his fear of God." And on the left side from the Yalkut, "You should be simple-hearted in your love of the Lord." On the right side from the Talmud: "God wants the heart." And on the left side, from the Prophet Jeremiah: "The heart of His people is corrupt and wayward." And the Rebbe pondered the contradictions. Until he heard the voice of the angels announcing, "You are now to be born." Whereupon he resolved in his heart to follow both columns no matter the contradictions.
To be Jewish is to live both columns. It is to live with tension, ambivalence, and paradox. "Polarity," wrote Abraham Joshua Heschel, "is at the heart of Judaism."
Consider this image: A pendulum, swinging back and forth. The arc described by the pendulum is truth. If you stop the pendulum anywhere along the arc and you say: "This point here at the zenith, this is the truth" ... or if you stop it down at the midpoint and say, "This is truth" -- you are wrong. You will always be wrong. Because truth is the pendulum in motion.
The philosopher Isaiah Berlin taught that every difficult, complex problem -- in politics, life, or thought -- has a simple answer. Which is always wrong. Not just wrong, deadly. For throughout human history, we Jews have always been the exception to somebody's rule. We have always been the anomaly to someone's absolute. And we have suffered for it. This is why extremism of any kind make us so anxious. It is what scares us about fundamentalism and simplistic moralism. We respond viscerally. Because whatever reduces truth to a simple absolute, reduces us.
Every morning we recite, "Blessed is God who creates light and darkness, peace and all else." Ours is not a monism, reducing all experience to one principle, one idea, one path -- denying the contrasts and the reality of tensions. But neither are we dualists who break everything into sharp disjunctions between good and evil, light and darkness, religious and secular, us and them. We are monotheists. We can acknowledge the contrasts in experience because we affirm that beneath them there is a basic unity. This is the meaning of the first of the Ten Commandments read this week all over the world: Ani Adonai Eloheychem. I am the Lord your God. In worshipping one God, we embrace life's rich complexity.
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, January 14, 2011
Shabbat Shalom January 14-15, 2011
THE LONG MARCH TOWARDS FREEDOM LAND
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
There is a conspicuous conjunction of the calendar this week. We celebrate both the anniversary of the birthdays of Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. on January 15, as well as the birthday of Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel on January 11. In addition, this week we read the third section and the most climactic parasha of the Exodus narrative. As the Israelites are encamped at Succot, Moses parts the water, raising it like walls high above. The land dries beneath their feet, and the people pass through this narrow passage with Pharaoh’s army nipping at their heels. This was the singular moment of the Exodus, when all of Israel saw with clarity and purpose the affirmative direction and utter glory of living in God’s presence. Once the sea split no one questioned, no one balked, no one hesitated – they knew what must be done. So they marched arm-in-arm into the sea towards freedom, singing together. This Shabbat, I will hear “we shall overcome” in my inner-ear while our congregation sings “mi-chamocha” from the Song of the Sea.
There are few moments in history when a community is singular in opinion, when conviction compels unity towards a common good. Those precious few instances that morally silence our opposing inclinations for avarice, greed, and brute self-interest, that we feel the presence and embrace of humanity, that reach higher to envelop our ennobled selves in goodness and push towards a meeting with God in a common place - our tradition captures those moments as glimpses of the Divine in the world and calls them revelation.
There are even fewer individuals who can harness the strength and courage buried within each of us to act towards what our conscience demands, to create concern for those who live at the margin – the needy, the downtrodden, the struggling - and galvanize the community towards a common deed. Our tradition records the essence of those individuals and calls them prophet. Reverend King was one of those prophets.
This means that revelation cannot be consigned to history books or merely encoded in works of art – it is woven into the tapestry of human living, and prophets are not merely artifacts of ancient Israel, but continue to inspire us towards disclosure’s end – freedom and justice. For those who seek light, truth, and goodness for themselves and others the Exodus never truly ends. As Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel wrote, “ …we have not yet completed crossing the Red Sea. There is still a long way to go.” As long as we have not reached the common good and drawn out Godliness in every person, we have not yet crossed into freedom land. On March 21, 1965, on the steps of Brown Chapel in Selma, Alabama, the American people got a good hard look at Godliness in the world, thanks to the prophetic voice of Reverend King.
Heschel received a telegram a few days earlier from King to come to Selma to join him in the third and fateful march to Montgomery, which he did. Sensing the importance of the moment, King gave a rousing speech, “I want to say to Selma, I want to say to Alabama…We are on the move now and no wave of racism can stop us….like an idea whose time is come ... We are marching to the land of freedom.”
For King and Heschel, the fight against racism and the fight for civil rights carried a spiritual dimension as much as a political one. For them and for us, the Exodus is an event to be lived by all peoples at all times in eternal struggle for freedom and justice. Heschel wrote King upon his return, "The day we marched together out of Selma was a day of sanctification. That day I hope will never be past to me - that day will continue to be this day...,” Everyday can be a day of Exodus.
Most famously, in Heschel’s diary he wrote of the march, "For many of us the march from Selma to Montgomery was about protest and prayer. Legs are not lips and walking is not kneeling. And yet our legs uttered songs. Even without words, our march was worship. I felt my legs were praying." The Exodus still lives on today in each of us, through our prayers and our deeds. When we see genocide we know what must be done. When we see slavery we know what must be done. When we see hunger we know what must be done. When we see discrimination we know what must be done. As heirs to Heschel and King, it is incumbent upon us to march arm-in-arm towards freedom with others because our redemption is bound-up with theirs.
This Monday is the 25th anniversary of the national celebration of King’s Birthday. For the second year in a row we have chosen to celebrate King and Heschel together by engaging in an interfaith service project that helps others in their march towards goodness. Please join us this Monday with the Family of Faith Christian Center, an African American church, as we feed the hungry, clothe the homeless, and work towards a better tomorrow. For more information about the event, please contact Jeff Brown at jbrown@pircher.com
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
There is a conspicuous conjunction of the calendar this week. We celebrate both the anniversary of the birthdays of Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. on January 15, as well as the birthday of Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel on January 11. In addition, this week we read the third section and the most climactic parasha of the Exodus narrative. As the Israelites are encamped at Succot, Moses parts the water, raising it like walls high above. The land dries beneath their feet, and the people pass through this narrow passage with Pharaoh’s army nipping at their heels. This was the singular moment of the Exodus, when all of Israel saw with clarity and purpose the affirmative direction and utter glory of living in God’s presence. Once the sea split no one questioned, no one balked, no one hesitated – they knew what must be done. So they marched arm-in-arm into the sea towards freedom, singing together. This Shabbat, I will hear “we shall overcome” in my inner-ear while our congregation sings “mi-chamocha” from the Song of the Sea.
There are few moments in history when a community is singular in opinion, when conviction compels unity towards a common good. Those precious few instances that morally silence our opposing inclinations for avarice, greed, and brute self-interest, that we feel the presence and embrace of humanity, that reach higher to envelop our ennobled selves in goodness and push towards a meeting with God in a common place - our tradition captures those moments as glimpses of the Divine in the world and calls them revelation.
There are even fewer individuals who can harness the strength and courage buried within each of us to act towards what our conscience demands, to create concern for those who live at the margin – the needy, the downtrodden, the struggling - and galvanize the community towards a common deed. Our tradition records the essence of those individuals and calls them prophet. Reverend King was one of those prophets.
This means that revelation cannot be consigned to history books or merely encoded in works of art – it is woven into the tapestry of human living, and prophets are not merely artifacts of ancient Israel, but continue to inspire us towards disclosure’s end – freedom and justice. For those who seek light, truth, and goodness for themselves and others the Exodus never truly ends. As Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel wrote, “ …we have not yet completed crossing the Red Sea. There is still a long way to go.” As long as we have not reached the common good and drawn out Godliness in every person, we have not yet crossed into freedom land. On March 21, 1965, on the steps of Brown Chapel in Selma, Alabama, the American people got a good hard look at Godliness in the world, thanks to the prophetic voice of Reverend King.
Heschel received a telegram a few days earlier from King to come to Selma to join him in the third and fateful march to Montgomery, which he did. Sensing the importance of the moment, King gave a rousing speech, “I want to say to Selma, I want to say to Alabama…We are on the move now and no wave of racism can stop us….like an idea whose time is come ... We are marching to the land of freedom.”
For King and Heschel, the fight against racism and the fight for civil rights carried a spiritual dimension as much as a political one. For them and for us, the Exodus is an event to be lived by all peoples at all times in eternal struggle for freedom and justice. Heschel wrote King upon his return, "The day we marched together out of Selma was a day of sanctification. That day I hope will never be past to me - that day will continue to be this day...,” Everyday can be a day of Exodus.
Most famously, in Heschel’s diary he wrote of the march, "For many of us the march from Selma to Montgomery was about protest and prayer. Legs are not lips and walking is not kneeling. And yet our legs uttered songs. Even without words, our march was worship. I felt my legs were praying." The Exodus still lives on today in each of us, through our prayers and our deeds. When we see genocide we know what must be done. When we see slavery we know what must be done. When we see hunger we know what must be done. When we see discrimination we know what must be done. As heirs to Heschel and King, it is incumbent upon us to march arm-in-arm towards freedom with others because our redemption is bound-up with theirs.
This Monday is the 25th anniversary of the national celebration of King’s Birthday. For the second year in a row we have chosen to celebrate King and Heschel together by engaging in an interfaith service project that helps others in their march towards goodness. Please join us this Monday with the Family of Faith Christian Center, an African American church, as we feed the hungry, clothe the homeless, and work towards a better tomorrow. For more information about the event, please contact Jeff Brown at jbrown@pircher.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)