BLACK AND WHITE FRIDAY
PARASHAT VAYESHEV 2010
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
There’s a flurry of activity this time of year. From Thanksgiving to Hanukah, we seem to be caught up in a maelstrom of feasting, shopping, and celebrating. Black Friday is the newest American holiday. In recognition of Black Friday, I thought it best to teach a story about Reb Zusiya of Anipoli (ca. 1718-1800).
Reb Zusiya once attended a great feast in his honor at the home of one of the wealthy people in Ostroh (today in western Ukraine). Reb Zusiya came from a poor family and began his life as a student in Ostroh, begging for a morsel of food and a place to put his head. At the time of his feast however, he was a well-respected teacher and master of Talmud. Yet he was careful never to forget his humble past.
During the feast, as the well-to-do townspeople sat drinking and enjoying themselves, Reb Zusiya sat at the head of the table in silence. Without warning, he picked up the bowl of soup before him and threw it onto to his silk bekishe, the long, black hassidic caftan worn by many hassidim to this day.
The conversation suddenly stopped and all eyes turned to Reb Zusiya who began to angrily address his robe: "Go ahead, eat, bekishe! This whole party is for you!” The guests looked at each other not knowing what to say.
Reb Zusiya looked around the table. With a warm grin, he explained: "I was sitting here and remembering that a few years back I was a poor man here in Ostroh. Times have changed, and today I am invited to this grand feast in my honor. But I was thinking, have I really changed that much since I was last in Ostroh? I’m still the same person I was back then, but the only change that I could think of was my clothes! A few years back I came into Ostroh wearing the torn garments of a pauper, and no one would take me in or feed me. Today I sit before you in a fine tailored silk bekishe. When I realized that, I suddenly understood that you were not honoring me, that the food was not prepared in my honor, the guests were not invited because of my reputation. The credit must go to my bekishe! He then should eat!"
A new immigrant to America once told me, “You know, Rabbi, there are just so many opportunities to spend money in this country.” From an outsider’s perspective, America is not only a land of promise and opportunity, but place of great consumerism and material wealth. Reb Zusiya teaches us in a funny way, that feasting and celebration are Jewishly meaningful only when they are paired with the sacred values of tzedkah and chesed – the compassionate inclusion of those who are not at the table with us. This is why we give gifts to the poor on Purim, we invite the stranger into our homes on Passover, and celebrate with open arms during the festival of Sukkot.
This is what troubles me about Black Friday. For many, the Friday after Thanksgiving is the day that kicks off the shopping season that makes businesses profitable for the year, putting companies in the black (hence the name Black Friday). The sales on Black Friday also enable some to achieve a higher living standard (eg. “I could never have afforded this TV any other way). But can we take it too far? Do we risk tipping the community scales in the direction of material acquisition so much on one day that it rises to the level of being called a national phenomenon? When does bargain hunting become unbridled consumerism? When does running errands become a consumerist version of Pamplona? We need not spill soup on our shirts to confound our quest for material wealth, but Judaism does teach us to live a balanced, valued, and thoughtful life. We never celebrate without mourning the dead, we never grieve without telling at least one joke, we never feast without thinking of those who are hungry, and on Black Friday for those who do shop, let’s not purchase for ourselves without buying something for those who cannot afford. Moreover, instead of thinking of Black Friday as the day after Thanksgiving, let’s see it as a prelude to the most anti-materialistic day on the Jewish calendar, Shabbat. When you put your shopping bags down, take a breath, and turn your Friday flurry into Erev Shabbat. Put on a white shirt, light some candles, drink some wine, and take the time to live with what is truly most important in our lives – our sacred relationships.
Shabbat Shalom.
Friday, November 26, 2010
Thursday, November 18, 2010
Shabbat Shalom November 19-20, 2010
Parashat Vayishlach
Cantor Phil Baron
Last week Rabbi Steinberg wrote about the Bible’s tendency to present opposing points of view. In examining Rachel’s dilemma in parashat Vayeitsei the rabbi very clearly pointed out the Bible’s many opinions on Rachel’s conception of motherhood and womanhood. In reading his argument I wondered: Is the Bible asking us to consider many sides of an issue, or is it making a statement about ambivalence as a natural part of living? What happens when strongly divergent feelings and impulses reside within one person?
In the very next parasha, Vayishlach, Jacob literally tackles that question. He is on his way to a final confrontation with his brother Esau. The night before, he is alone and is assaulted by a strange “man” whom he engages in what might be called an epic “smackdown,” a wrestling match of cosmic proportions. His opponent, as it turns out, is hunkier than Hulk Hogan, grungier than Goldberg. He is, in fact, a celestial being, probably with super powers. Yet he can’t defeat Jacob. What’s going on here? Isn’t this the Jacob who runs from confrontation – the mama’s boy who survives by wit, not muscle?
We know that Jacob, despite his cunning and business acumen is no warrior -- that’s his brother Esau. Jacob got the brains. So how does he win a split decision with Iron Man?
There’s no sports section in the Bible, no box scores, no blow-by-blow, just a few verses devoted to the match. But we do know some important details. The story begins in Genesis 32:23. “That same night he arose and taking his two wives, his two maidservants, and his eleven children, he crossed the ford of the Jabbock.” A neat trick in the middle of the night! I know that if I woke my kids and my two wives (okay, I only have one) up in the middle of the night and asked them to cross a river, I’d also find myself in a fight to the death. What was Jacob’s hurry?
Jacob schleps his family and all their belongings across the river in the dark. The great Jewish scholar Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman says “He made them pass the brook.” I’ll bet he did. The parasha continues, “After taking them across the stream, he sent across all his possessions.”(Gen. 32:24) So he makes the mishpacha cross the river, goes back to the other side, sends his processions along, and remains there alone, waiting.
This reminds me of the scene in countless cowboy movies where the sheriff says to the townspeople “lock up the women-folk and young’ns, there’s gonna be some shootin’and some dyin’!” Gary Cooper knows what’s coming, and so does Jacob. And like the sheriff in “High Noon,” Jacob is controlling the situation.
Jacob knows he needs to have it out once and for all to bring peace to his family. So he waits there in the dark for The Incredible Hulk. Yes, I’ve now given away the real identity of the “man” or angel with whom Jacob tangles. It’s the big hairy monster whose secret identity is mild-mannered Bruce Banner. The Green Guy is a pretty good metaphor for the “Hulk” that lives in Jacob. He has to master the conniving, weak and disloyal creature that lives within himself before he has the strength to face Esau -- to face his own guilt. He can’t really cross the river Jabbock (a Biblical pun on the name Jacob?) until he’s conquered his past, cleaned the slate, and become ready to make peace with his brother and himself, or to die trying.
As descendents of Jacob, we benefit from the realization that his greatness came not only from his leadership of others, but from his willingness to conquer and control his greatest adversary -- himself.
Shabbat Shalom.
Cantor Phil Baron
Last week Rabbi Steinberg wrote about the Bible’s tendency to present opposing points of view. In examining Rachel’s dilemma in parashat Vayeitsei the rabbi very clearly pointed out the Bible’s many opinions on Rachel’s conception of motherhood and womanhood. In reading his argument I wondered: Is the Bible asking us to consider many sides of an issue, or is it making a statement about ambivalence as a natural part of living? What happens when strongly divergent feelings and impulses reside within one person?
In the very next parasha, Vayishlach, Jacob literally tackles that question. He is on his way to a final confrontation with his brother Esau. The night before, he is alone and is assaulted by a strange “man” whom he engages in what might be called an epic “smackdown,” a wrestling match of cosmic proportions. His opponent, as it turns out, is hunkier than Hulk Hogan, grungier than Goldberg. He is, in fact, a celestial being, probably with super powers. Yet he can’t defeat Jacob. What’s going on here? Isn’t this the Jacob who runs from confrontation – the mama’s boy who survives by wit, not muscle?
We know that Jacob, despite his cunning and business acumen is no warrior -- that’s his brother Esau. Jacob got the brains. So how does he win a split decision with Iron Man?
There’s no sports section in the Bible, no box scores, no blow-by-blow, just a few verses devoted to the match. But we do know some important details. The story begins in Genesis 32:23. “That same night he arose and taking his two wives, his two maidservants, and his eleven children, he crossed the ford of the Jabbock.” A neat trick in the middle of the night! I know that if I woke my kids and my two wives (okay, I only have one) up in the middle of the night and asked them to cross a river, I’d also find myself in a fight to the death. What was Jacob’s hurry?
Jacob schleps his family and all their belongings across the river in the dark. The great Jewish scholar Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman says “He made them pass the brook.” I’ll bet he did. The parasha continues, “After taking them across the stream, he sent across all his possessions.”(Gen. 32:24) So he makes the mishpacha cross the river, goes back to the other side, sends his processions along, and remains there alone, waiting.
This reminds me of the scene in countless cowboy movies where the sheriff says to the townspeople “lock up the women-folk and young’ns, there’s gonna be some shootin’and some dyin’!” Gary Cooper knows what’s coming, and so does Jacob. And like the sheriff in “High Noon,” Jacob is controlling the situation.
Jacob knows he needs to have it out once and for all to bring peace to his family. So he waits there in the dark for The Incredible Hulk. Yes, I’ve now given away the real identity of the “man” or angel with whom Jacob tangles. It’s the big hairy monster whose secret identity is mild-mannered Bruce Banner. The Green Guy is a pretty good metaphor for the “Hulk” that lives in Jacob. He has to master the conniving, weak and disloyal creature that lives within himself before he has the strength to face Esau -- to face his own guilt. He can’t really cross the river Jabbock (a Biblical pun on the name Jacob?) until he’s conquered his past, cleaned the slate, and become ready to make peace with his brother and himself, or to die trying.
As descendents of Jacob, we benefit from the realization that his greatness came not only from his leadership of others, but from his willingness to conquer and control his greatest adversary -- himself.
Shabbat Shalom.
Friday, November 12, 2010
Shabbat Shalom November 12-13, 2010
Parshat Va-Yetzei
Rabbi Paul Steinberg
"Give me children, or I shall die. This is what Rachel said to Jacob" (Gen. 30:1), seeing that she was barren and that her sister, Leah, continued to conceive.
As we read Rachel’s painful supplication, we immediately understand the despair that infertility brings. Many of us have been touched, either directly or indirectly by infertility and understand the sorrow it brings to couples, especially women. We hear her pain and can relate to it.
That being said, it seems unlikely that we might hear such a drastic statement from women in the 21st century; presumably, suicide or fertility would be a false choice for most women in our modern society. In this past century and a half, women have fought hard to be valued as mothers but also not to be defined by motherhood alone [the national average for women having their first child is app. 25 yrs]. In fact, the wisdom of feminism is that no one should assume that motherhood is all of womanhood, and that women have equal voices in many other arenas of society. Thus, this text poses a strange contemporary dilemma as we see our matriarch, Rachel, basing the value of her life and her very existence only upon her motherhood. On one hand we can relate to her pain, yet on the other, we may distance ourselves because she goes too far.
There are two primary ways with which to read such a difficult biblical verse from our modern perspective. One is apologetics. That is to say, we assume that even though it may be difficult and counter to our cultural sensibilities, there must be some deep and abiding truth that we can attribute to this verse. Apologetics would therefore acknowledge that Rachel may go too far for many women today, but ultimately, defend her position in defining her womanhood as motherhood.
The second way to read this text would be to dismiss it. That is, we might say that the text is clearly written from the perspective of a time and place that is no longer relevant. In other words, we may acknowledge that it may have been true that Rachel’s womanhood and existence was actually based on her ability to bear children, but that simply isn’t the case today. Therefore, we can dismiss the verse to the files of anthropologists.
I want to recommend a third possible approach to the text, which is suggested by Judy Klitsner, the author of "Subversive Sequels in the Bible: How Biblical Stories Mine and Undermine Each Other." In her book, Klitsner convincingly argues that it is possible to read the stories and ideas presented in the Bible as if they are in conversation with one another – reacting and even arguing with each other. So, we may read of Rachel’s conception of womanhood as motherhood in this verse and parsha, yet elsewhere we will find other voices either in agreement or in contention with the one we have here.
For now, I want to point out both a place in which the Bible agrees with Rachel’s concept of womanhood and a place where it disagrees. Regarding the former, we must turn back to chapter three in Genesis with the story of Eden (this is actually the third story of womanhood within the first three chapters alone). This is, of course the story of the fall of Adam and Eve. Each of them sin and each of them are punished. As for God’s punishment of Eve, the Torah states (Gen. 3:16):
"And to the woman He said,
‘I will make most severe your pangs in childbearing;
in pain you shall bear children.
Yet your urge shall be for your husband,
and he shall rule over you.’"
And four verses later, following the litany of curses to Adam and the serpent, the text continues (Gen 3:20):
"The man named his wife Eve (Chava, from the verb root meaning “life”), because she was the mother of all the living."
Here we see that following the sin of disobedience in the Garden of Eden, Eve – who is named for her life-giving capacity – is quite literally limited to her function as a mother. Of course, motherhood is a grand and magnificent gift with which women are bestowed. However, a grand blessing can become a burden and used to subvert rights when such a grand blessing is understood to be the totality of one’s identity and worth. This is what seems to be the case here in Genesis, as well as in our parsha with Rachel, wherein her existential identity as a mother has indeed become a burden. Moreover, because she was unsuccessful in actualizing her one and only gift, she rendered herself and her life utterly worthless.
There is also an opposing voice to Rachel’s conception of motherhood and womanhood. We find it explicitly in the fourth and fifth chapters of the Book of Judges. This is the story of the Deborah. Here we encounter Deborah who is married yet has no children and, paradoxically, she is referred to as “mother of Israel” – Em b’Yisrael (Judges 5:7). Not literally a mother, Deborah is a prophetess and a leader of the people both in the wisdom that she offers and inspiration she brings to the battlefield. Furthermore, within Deborah’s story, we meet Yael – also married and childless – who helps to defeat the enemy by acting as a military assassin. The story is rather clear on this issue: neither of our heroes, Deborah nor Yael, could possibly be limited in their value as human beings by their motherhood alone.
As a brother to five sisters, as a husband to a brilliant and beautiful wife, as a father to three wonderful daughters, and as a son to a mother, I can honestly say that I still know nothing about what it is to be a woman! I am comforted, however, to see that the Torah itself also has no one answer as to what it means to be a woman (or man, for that matter). Instead we see that there are different ways of understanding the value and purpose of our gender. That’s what’s so amazing and incredible about our Bible – it is honest enough and mature enough to draw upon a cacophony of voices and ideas, recognizing that the truth may lie within all of them together.
Rabbi Paul Steinberg
"Give me children, or I shall die. This is what Rachel said to Jacob" (Gen. 30:1), seeing that she was barren and that her sister, Leah, continued to conceive.
As we read Rachel’s painful supplication, we immediately understand the despair that infertility brings. Many of us have been touched, either directly or indirectly by infertility and understand the sorrow it brings to couples, especially women. We hear her pain and can relate to it.
That being said, it seems unlikely that we might hear such a drastic statement from women in the 21st century; presumably, suicide or fertility would be a false choice for most women in our modern society. In this past century and a half, women have fought hard to be valued as mothers but also not to be defined by motherhood alone [the national average for women having their first child is app. 25 yrs]. In fact, the wisdom of feminism is that no one should assume that motherhood is all of womanhood, and that women have equal voices in many other arenas of society. Thus, this text poses a strange contemporary dilemma as we see our matriarch, Rachel, basing the value of her life and her very existence only upon her motherhood. On one hand we can relate to her pain, yet on the other, we may distance ourselves because she goes too far.
There are two primary ways with which to read such a difficult biblical verse from our modern perspective. One is apologetics. That is to say, we assume that even though it may be difficult and counter to our cultural sensibilities, there must be some deep and abiding truth that we can attribute to this verse. Apologetics would therefore acknowledge that Rachel may go too far for many women today, but ultimately, defend her position in defining her womanhood as motherhood.
The second way to read this text would be to dismiss it. That is, we might say that the text is clearly written from the perspective of a time and place that is no longer relevant. In other words, we may acknowledge that it may have been true that Rachel’s womanhood and existence was actually based on her ability to bear children, but that simply isn’t the case today. Therefore, we can dismiss the verse to the files of anthropologists.
I want to recommend a third possible approach to the text, which is suggested by Judy Klitsner, the author of "Subversive Sequels in the Bible: How Biblical Stories Mine and Undermine Each Other." In her book, Klitsner convincingly argues that it is possible to read the stories and ideas presented in the Bible as if they are in conversation with one another – reacting and even arguing with each other. So, we may read of Rachel’s conception of womanhood as motherhood in this verse and parsha, yet elsewhere we will find other voices either in agreement or in contention with the one we have here.
For now, I want to point out both a place in which the Bible agrees with Rachel’s concept of womanhood and a place where it disagrees. Regarding the former, we must turn back to chapter three in Genesis with the story of Eden (this is actually the third story of womanhood within the first three chapters alone). This is, of course the story of the fall of Adam and Eve. Each of them sin and each of them are punished. As for God’s punishment of Eve, the Torah states (Gen. 3:16):
"And to the woman He said,
‘I will make most severe your pangs in childbearing;
in pain you shall bear children.
Yet your urge shall be for your husband,
and he shall rule over you.’"
And four verses later, following the litany of curses to Adam and the serpent, the text continues (Gen 3:20):
"The man named his wife Eve (Chava, from the verb root meaning “life”), because she was the mother of all the living."
Here we see that following the sin of disobedience in the Garden of Eden, Eve – who is named for her life-giving capacity – is quite literally limited to her function as a mother. Of course, motherhood is a grand and magnificent gift with which women are bestowed. However, a grand blessing can become a burden and used to subvert rights when such a grand blessing is understood to be the totality of one’s identity and worth. This is what seems to be the case here in Genesis, as well as in our parsha with Rachel, wherein her existential identity as a mother has indeed become a burden. Moreover, because she was unsuccessful in actualizing her one and only gift, she rendered herself and her life utterly worthless.
There is also an opposing voice to Rachel’s conception of motherhood and womanhood. We find it explicitly in the fourth and fifth chapters of the Book of Judges. This is the story of the Deborah. Here we encounter Deborah who is married yet has no children and, paradoxically, she is referred to as “mother of Israel” – Em b’Yisrael (Judges 5:7). Not literally a mother, Deborah is a prophetess and a leader of the people both in the wisdom that she offers and inspiration she brings to the battlefield. Furthermore, within Deborah’s story, we meet Yael – also married and childless – who helps to defeat the enemy by acting as a military assassin. The story is rather clear on this issue: neither of our heroes, Deborah nor Yael, could possibly be limited in their value as human beings by their motherhood alone.
As a brother to five sisters, as a husband to a brilliant and beautiful wife, as a father to three wonderful daughters, and as a son to a mother, I can honestly say that I still know nothing about what it is to be a woman! I am comforted, however, to see that the Torah itself also has no one answer as to what it means to be a woman (or man, for that matter). Instead we see that there are different ways of understanding the value and purpose of our gender. That’s what’s so amazing and incredible about our Bible – it is honest enough and mature enough to draw upon a cacophony of voices and ideas, recognizing that the truth may lie within all of them together.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)