Endings and Beginnings – A Conclusion to the Book of Genesis
Rabbi Joshua Hoffman
This past Monday evening, our community was given the opportunity to view an advanced screening of the movie Race to Nowhere, a film by Vicki Abeles and graciously sponsored by the Gold and Tajkef families.
(Read on! There’s no need for a spoiler alert for what comes next!)
The central message of the movie is a heartfelt call for dialogue around the ongoing pressures our children face when preparing for college. Cast in the shadow of a thirteen year old girl’s surprising suicide, the movie uncovers the layers of stress and anxiety children increasingly face today. The question the movie asks is, “Why isn’t anyone talking about this?”
I was left with so many more questions, and those who will have the chance to see the movie soon will too, I believe. Looming above all my questions is the question of our day, “Where to begin?”
Where to begin addressing the concerns of our children who are quietly suffering? They’re suffering not only because there is too much pressure to perform, but also because they are (not-so) subconsciously absorbing a model from parents, communities, and the world that measures success with quantity and not quality.
Where to begin assuaging the anxiety today’s parents feel in their quest to provide the best possible life for their children, and the even deeper fear that if they don’t do for their children what others are doing they are unfairly depriving them of an opportunity to self-actualize?
So many questions from one movie. Living in the era of movies like this or, “An Inconvenient Truth” means we are becoming more and more sensitive to gigantic global issues. It doesn’t mean we are predicting the future, though.
First and foremost, I post this as an invitation to an open and sustained exchange about some real issues, such as:
-Defining models of success within the current educational framework,
-Addressing the genuine and abiding concern for today’s parents and tomorrow's teenagers leading frantic lifestyles, and
-The challenge of the Jewish tradition to continue to speak with relevance to our lives and the world around us.
I offer this humbly as one among many concerned educators, parents, and community leaders. I hope they and you will lend your voice and share the conversation.
*****
While there is much to discover in this conversation, we can look to our Torah this week for insight and perspective, especially as we try to connect to a bunch of stressed out people.
“And Jacob called unto his sons, and said: 'Gather yourselves together, that I may tell you that which shall befall you in the end of days.” (Gen. 49:1)
Rashi comments on this verse, he notes,
Gather yourselves together, that I may tell you... (49:1)”Jacob wished to reveal the end (that they will become enslaved and eventually redeemed in Egypt), but the Divine Presence departed from him.”
We don’t need deathbeds to inspire prophetic visions, each and every day we may feel a little like Jacob. We see the struggles of others and we want so badly to make it easier and better and painless for them, all the more so for our own precious children. But as our great patriarch Jacob, was prevented from acting on his impulse, perhaps we too must not strive so hard to make our children into something they ought not to be – hyper-performing students who are prepared to run for Congress and lead a team of doctors into earthquake ravaged Haiti all before they turn 18.
What Jacob did do was to highlight the qualities of each of his children and focus on character rather than accomplishments. Besides, if Jacob had told his children that they would become slaves and eventually be redeemed, perhaps they wouldn’t have taken the steps to act on their own behalf to bring redemption. Painful as it may be, the best gift parents, educators, and communities can give our children is the courage to face the future, however it comes, with hope and determination. And as Jacob teaches us, it is the quality of their character that will ultimately define them.
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, December 17, 2010
Friday, December 3, 2010
Shabbat Shalom December 3-4, 2010
HOW THE GRINCH STOLE THE STORIES
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Hannuka 2010
Oh, the Jews of old Jewville just love to tell stories,
Of old Jewish heroes and all of their glories.
Of old father Abraham and Isaac his son
Who would have been sacrificed, if no angel had come.
They told of smooth Jacob, he sure was a play’a
Till he discovered he’d married not Rachel, but Leah.
He wrestled the angel, and at dawn he prevailed
And that’s how we came to be called Yisrael.
They loved tales of great Moses who taught us the Torah,
And of his sister Miriam, who taught us to Hora.
Of mighty King David, and Solomon the Wise,
Of Samson and Delilah, who was hot, but not nice.
But of all of the stories that we Jews remember,
The ones they loved best we tell in December.
At this time of the year, a long time ago,
There was a great miracle, nes gadol haya po!
But there was one among them who got no joy and no nachas
From candles and latkes, and dreidels and brachas.
Hannuka made him so angry and blue-ish
You’d hardly have guessed that he was born Jewish.
Since Kitah Aleph, he grew not an inch.
He was surly and hairy, and they called him the Grinch.
He lived on a mountaintop, far above town,
When Hannuka came, he declared with a frown,
“I hate all your holidays, it’s all hocus pocus
When I tell the story, I’m for Antiochos!
Because all these miracles – they are all made up and fake!
If you believe them, you make mistake!
Maybe Macabees found some oil in the Temple
But soon it burned out, that’s the truth, just that simple.
And so my dear children, just listen to me,
If you’re looking for oil, go talk to BP.”
As Hannuka came, he got bluer and bluer,
When up from the town he heard “Maoz Tzur.”
And when he heard Jews singing “Mi Yemalel,”
He made up a plan, guaranteed not to fail.
“I’ll steal their Hannuka, I know just how to do it,
I will succeed where Antiochus just blew it!”
I’ll get them to turn their backs on the Torah,
They’ll throw away dreidels, and toss their Menorah!”
So down from the mountaintop, came the Grinch without stop
And across from the school he set up a big shop.
The shop was so glorious, the shop was so fine,
And in front of the shop was a bright shiny sign:
“Special Today, Kids, Just What You Need,
You Don’t Need to Waste Time To Learn How To Read!
No! Your generation no longer needs phonics,
Not when you’ve got all these electronics!
Just for today, it’s all here and it’s free
Take an I-Phone, an X-Box, an HDTV!”
Out of their school, they came like a horde,
So proud of the gadgets and tchatchkas they scored.
They snatch up the I-Pads, and played with the Wii’s
They pick up Blackberries and Play Station 3’s.
They tossed away all their books and sneered at their teachers,
We don’t need you, we have laptops with all of these features!
It’s said the Dark Ages began on the day
When people found books had nothing to say.
So they closed the libraries and sealed up their stacks
And tried to live life without thought, without facts.
They would have returned, those Dark Ages of old
Had it not been for someone quite small and quiet bold.
The school it was dark, no one was learning,
But down in the library, there was still one light burning.
So the Grinch rushed right down there to see who would try
To resist his free offer of 4-G WiFi.
There sat Suzie L’Jew, filled with devotion
She ignored all the hoopla and all the commotion.
Librarian hero, she sat in a nook
And read to her class from a big open book.
Long long ago, lived a king, Antiochus,
Who ruled over our land with laws that would choke us.
He outlawed the Torah, he outlawed Shabbat,
He made it illegal to worship our God.
Long before Simon Cowell heard songs in recital
Antiochus just loved to watch “Syrian Idol.”
So he fashioned a statue of the great Greek god Zeus
To be installed in the Temple of the God of the Jews.
He thought that the Jews would accept this new faith,
And stop eating kosher, and start eating tref.
Ah, but poor Antiochus, he didn’t know Jews,
How ferocious they get, when they are abused.
From the town of Modin came a force to unite us,
Judah and Simon, and brave Mattathias.
They defeated the Greeks in a glorious fight,
And came to the Temple to rekindle the light.
But the oil they found was only enough for one day,
So the Macabees turned to God and they prayed.
Give us Your light, God, to live by Your Torah,
Give us Your light from this great Menorah,
Our world is so dark and there's so much to fear,
So give us Your light God, and we'll know You're here.
When great men of war, put down their swords,
And turn in devotion to pray to the Lord,
And declare that it’s time for the fighting to cease,
It’s time that the world knows the blessing of peace.
God hears these great prayers, these blessings and psalms,
And decrees that it’s time for tikkum olam.
The light from the Temple lasted all eight nights long
The Macabees lifted their voices in song,
The light it kept burning, within every Jew,
And burns even today, in me and in you.
In Grinch’s cold heart, he heard a big thump
As down in his throat he felt a big lump.
And out of his eyes came flowing the tears
From all of the stories he’d missed all these years.
Do you have more stories? he asked like a kid,
And tell him more stories, that’s just what she did.
The Grinch he was changed by the power of stories
He fell in love with great books, in all of their glories.
‘Cause a book, like the Macabees’ miracle lights
Can light up the world on these cold cold dark nights.
When you visit the library, walk way into the shelves
Past books about presidents and books about elves,
And way way in the back, where it’s lonely and scary,
You’ll see there a fellow whose green and he’s hairy.
He’ll invite you to sit and enjoy a good book,
Just turn off your I-pad and have a good look.
He’ll shares all the treasures of Talmud and Torah
That will light up the world light a great big Menorah.
HAPPY HANNUKA!!!
(If you want to hear Rabbi Feinstein tell this story, come to services tonight, December 3 at 7:30PM)
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Hannuka 2010
Oh, the Jews of old Jewville just love to tell stories,
Of old Jewish heroes and all of their glories.
Of old father Abraham and Isaac his son
Who would have been sacrificed, if no angel had come.
They told of smooth Jacob, he sure was a play’a
Till he discovered he’d married not Rachel, but Leah.
He wrestled the angel, and at dawn he prevailed
And that’s how we came to be called Yisrael.
They loved tales of great Moses who taught us the Torah,
And of his sister Miriam, who taught us to Hora.
Of mighty King David, and Solomon the Wise,
Of Samson and Delilah, who was hot, but not nice.
But of all of the stories that we Jews remember,
The ones they loved best we tell in December.
At this time of the year, a long time ago,
There was a great miracle, nes gadol haya po!
But there was one among them who got no joy and no nachas
From candles and latkes, and dreidels and brachas.
Hannuka made him so angry and blue-ish
You’d hardly have guessed that he was born Jewish.
Since Kitah Aleph, he grew not an inch.
He was surly and hairy, and they called him the Grinch.
He lived on a mountaintop, far above town,
When Hannuka came, he declared with a frown,
“I hate all your holidays, it’s all hocus pocus
When I tell the story, I’m for Antiochos!
Because all these miracles – they are all made up and fake!
If you believe them, you make mistake!
Maybe Macabees found some oil in the Temple
But soon it burned out, that’s the truth, just that simple.
And so my dear children, just listen to me,
If you’re looking for oil, go talk to BP.”
As Hannuka came, he got bluer and bluer,
When up from the town he heard “Maoz Tzur.”
And when he heard Jews singing “Mi Yemalel,”
He made up a plan, guaranteed not to fail.
“I’ll steal their Hannuka, I know just how to do it,
I will succeed where Antiochus just blew it!”
I’ll get them to turn their backs on the Torah,
They’ll throw away dreidels, and toss their Menorah!”
So down from the mountaintop, came the Grinch without stop
And across from the school he set up a big shop.
The shop was so glorious, the shop was so fine,
And in front of the shop was a bright shiny sign:
“Special Today, Kids, Just What You Need,
You Don’t Need to Waste Time To Learn How To Read!
No! Your generation no longer needs phonics,
Not when you’ve got all these electronics!
Just for today, it’s all here and it’s free
Take an I-Phone, an X-Box, an HDTV!”
Out of their school, they came like a horde,
So proud of the gadgets and tchatchkas they scored.
They snatch up the I-Pads, and played with the Wii’s
They pick up Blackberries and Play Station 3’s.
They tossed away all their books and sneered at their teachers,
We don’t need you, we have laptops with all of these features!
It’s said the Dark Ages began on the day
When people found books had nothing to say.
So they closed the libraries and sealed up their stacks
And tried to live life without thought, without facts.
They would have returned, those Dark Ages of old
Had it not been for someone quite small and quiet bold.
The school it was dark, no one was learning,
But down in the library, there was still one light burning.
So the Grinch rushed right down there to see who would try
To resist his free offer of 4-G WiFi.
There sat Suzie L’Jew, filled with devotion
She ignored all the hoopla and all the commotion.
Librarian hero, she sat in a nook
And read to her class from a big open book.
Long long ago, lived a king, Antiochus,
Who ruled over our land with laws that would choke us.
He outlawed the Torah, he outlawed Shabbat,
He made it illegal to worship our God.
Long before Simon Cowell heard songs in recital
Antiochus just loved to watch “Syrian Idol.”
So he fashioned a statue of the great Greek god Zeus
To be installed in the Temple of the God of the Jews.
He thought that the Jews would accept this new faith,
And stop eating kosher, and start eating tref.
Ah, but poor Antiochus, he didn’t know Jews,
How ferocious they get, when they are abused.
From the town of Modin came a force to unite us,
Judah and Simon, and brave Mattathias.
They defeated the Greeks in a glorious fight,
And came to the Temple to rekindle the light.
But the oil they found was only enough for one day,
So the Macabees turned to God and they prayed.
Give us Your light, God, to live by Your Torah,
Give us Your light from this great Menorah,
Our world is so dark and there's so much to fear,
So give us Your light God, and we'll know You're here.
When great men of war, put down their swords,
And turn in devotion to pray to the Lord,
And declare that it’s time for the fighting to cease,
It’s time that the world knows the blessing of peace.
God hears these great prayers, these blessings and psalms,
And decrees that it’s time for tikkum olam.
The light from the Temple lasted all eight nights long
The Macabees lifted their voices in song,
The light it kept burning, within every Jew,
And burns even today, in me and in you.
In Grinch’s cold heart, he heard a big thump
As down in his throat he felt a big lump.
And out of his eyes came flowing the tears
From all of the stories he’d missed all these years.
Do you have more stories? he asked like a kid,
And tell him more stories, that’s just what she did.
The Grinch he was changed by the power of stories
He fell in love with great books, in all of their glories.
‘Cause a book, like the Macabees’ miracle lights
Can light up the world on these cold cold dark nights.
When you visit the library, walk way into the shelves
Past books about presidents and books about elves,
And way way in the back, where it’s lonely and scary,
You’ll see there a fellow whose green and he’s hairy.
He’ll invite you to sit and enjoy a good book,
Just turn off your I-pad and have a good look.
He’ll shares all the treasures of Talmud and Torah
That will light up the world light a great big Menorah.
HAPPY HANNUKA!!!
(If you want to hear Rabbi Feinstein tell this story, come to services tonight, December 3 at 7:30PM)
Friday, November 26, 2010
Shabbat Shalom November 26-27, 2010
BLACK AND WHITE FRIDAY
PARASHAT VAYESHEV 2010
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
There’s a flurry of activity this time of year. From Thanksgiving to Hanukah, we seem to be caught up in a maelstrom of feasting, shopping, and celebrating. Black Friday is the newest American holiday. In recognition of Black Friday, I thought it best to teach a story about Reb Zusiya of Anipoli (ca. 1718-1800).
Reb Zusiya once attended a great feast in his honor at the home of one of the wealthy people in Ostroh (today in western Ukraine). Reb Zusiya came from a poor family and began his life as a student in Ostroh, begging for a morsel of food and a place to put his head. At the time of his feast however, he was a well-respected teacher and master of Talmud. Yet he was careful never to forget his humble past.
During the feast, as the well-to-do townspeople sat drinking and enjoying themselves, Reb Zusiya sat at the head of the table in silence. Without warning, he picked up the bowl of soup before him and threw it onto to his silk bekishe, the long, black hassidic caftan worn by many hassidim to this day.
The conversation suddenly stopped and all eyes turned to Reb Zusiya who began to angrily address his robe: "Go ahead, eat, bekishe! This whole party is for you!” The guests looked at each other not knowing what to say.
Reb Zusiya looked around the table. With a warm grin, he explained: "I was sitting here and remembering that a few years back I was a poor man here in Ostroh. Times have changed, and today I am invited to this grand feast in my honor. But I was thinking, have I really changed that much since I was last in Ostroh? I’m still the same person I was back then, but the only change that I could think of was my clothes! A few years back I came into Ostroh wearing the torn garments of a pauper, and no one would take me in or feed me. Today I sit before you in a fine tailored silk bekishe. When I realized that, I suddenly understood that you were not honoring me, that the food was not prepared in my honor, the guests were not invited because of my reputation. The credit must go to my bekishe! He then should eat!"
A new immigrant to America once told me, “You know, Rabbi, there are just so many opportunities to spend money in this country.” From an outsider’s perspective, America is not only a land of promise and opportunity, but place of great consumerism and material wealth. Reb Zusiya teaches us in a funny way, that feasting and celebration are Jewishly meaningful only when they are paired with the sacred values of tzedkah and chesed – the compassionate inclusion of those who are not at the table with us. This is why we give gifts to the poor on Purim, we invite the stranger into our homes on Passover, and celebrate with open arms during the festival of Sukkot.
This is what troubles me about Black Friday. For many, the Friday after Thanksgiving is the day that kicks off the shopping season that makes businesses profitable for the year, putting companies in the black (hence the name Black Friday). The sales on Black Friday also enable some to achieve a higher living standard (eg. “I could never have afforded this TV any other way). But can we take it too far? Do we risk tipping the community scales in the direction of material acquisition so much on one day that it rises to the level of being called a national phenomenon? When does bargain hunting become unbridled consumerism? When does running errands become a consumerist version of Pamplona? We need not spill soup on our shirts to confound our quest for material wealth, but Judaism does teach us to live a balanced, valued, and thoughtful life. We never celebrate without mourning the dead, we never grieve without telling at least one joke, we never feast without thinking of those who are hungry, and on Black Friday for those who do shop, let’s not purchase for ourselves without buying something for those who cannot afford. Moreover, instead of thinking of Black Friday as the day after Thanksgiving, let’s see it as a prelude to the most anti-materialistic day on the Jewish calendar, Shabbat. When you put your shopping bags down, take a breath, and turn your Friday flurry into Erev Shabbat. Put on a white shirt, light some candles, drink some wine, and take the time to live with what is truly most important in our lives – our sacred relationships.
Shabbat Shalom.
PARASHAT VAYESHEV 2010
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
There’s a flurry of activity this time of year. From Thanksgiving to Hanukah, we seem to be caught up in a maelstrom of feasting, shopping, and celebrating. Black Friday is the newest American holiday. In recognition of Black Friday, I thought it best to teach a story about Reb Zusiya of Anipoli (ca. 1718-1800).
Reb Zusiya once attended a great feast in his honor at the home of one of the wealthy people in Ostroh (today in western Ukraine). Reb Zusiya came from a poor family and began his life as a student in Ostroh, begging for a morsel of food and a place to put his head. At the time of his feast however, he was a well-respected teacher and master of Talmud. Yet he was careful never to forget his humble past.
During the feast, as the well-to-do townspeople sat drinking and enjoying themselves, Reb Zusiya sat at the head of the table in silence. Without warning, he picked up the bowl of soup before him and threw it onto to his silk bekishe, the long, black hassidic caftan worn by many hassidim to this day.
The conversation suddenly stopped and all eyes turned to Reb Zusiya who began to angrily address his robe: "Go ahead, eat, bekishe! This whole party is for you!” The guests looked at each other not knowing what to say.
Reb Zusiya looked around the table. With a warm grin, he explained: "I was sitting here and remembering that a few years back I was a poor man here in Ostroh. Times have changed, and today I am invited to this grand feast in my honor. But I was thinking, have I really changed that much since I was last in Ostroh? I’m still the same person I was back then, but the only change that I could think of was my clothes! A few years back I came into Ostroh wearing the torn garments of a pauper, and no one would take me in or feed me. Today I sit before you in a fine tailored silk bekishe. When I realized that, I suddenly understood that you were not honoring me, that the food was not prepared in my honor, the guests were not invited because of my reputation. The credit must go to my bekishe! He then should eat!"
A new immigrant to America once told me, “You know, Rabbi, there are just so many opportunities to spend money in this country.” From an outsider’s perspective, America is not only a land of promise and opportunity, but place of great consumerism and material wealth. Reb Zusiya teaches us in a funny way, that feasting and celebration are Jewishly meaningful only when they are paired with the sacred values of tzedkah and chesed – the compassionate inclusion of those who are not at the table with us. This is why we give gifts to the poor on Purim, we invite the stranger into our homes on Passover, and celebrate with open arms during the festival of Sukkot.
This is what troubles me about Black Friday. For many, the Friday after Thanksgiving is the day that kicks off the shopping season that makes businesses profitable for the year, putting companies in the black (hence the name Black Friday). The sales on Black Friday also enable some to achieve a higher living standard (eg. “I could never have afforded this TV any other way). But can we take it too far? Do we risk tipping the community scales in the direction of material acquisition so much on one day that it rises to the level of being called a national phenomenon? When does bargain hunting become unbridled consumerism? When does running errands become a consumerist version of Pamplona? We need not spill soup on our shirts to confound our quest for material wealth, but Judaism does teach us to live a balanced, valued, and thoughtful life. We never celebrate without mourning the dead, we never grieve without telling at least one joke, we never feast without thinking of those who are hungry, and on Black Friday for those who do shop, let’s not purchase for ourselves without buying something for those who cannot afford. Moreover, instead of thinking of Black Friday as the day after Thanksgiving, let’s see it as a prelude to the most anti-materialistic day on the Jewish calendar, Shabbat. When you put your shopping bags down, take a breath, and turn your Friday flurry into Erev Shabbat. Put on a white shirt, light some candles, drink some wine, and take the time to live with what is truly most important in our lives – our sacred relationships.
Shabbat Shalom.
Thursday, November 18, 2010
Shabbat Shalom November 19-20, 2010
Parashat Vayishlach
Cantor Phil Baron
Last week Rabbi Steinberg wrote about the Bible’s tendency to present opposing points of view. In examining Rachel’s dilemma in parashat Vayeitsei the rabbi very clearly pointed out the Bible’s many opinions on Rachel’s conception of motherhood and womanhood. In reading his argument I wondered: Is the Bible asking us to consider many sides of an issue, or is it making a statement about ambivalence as a natural part of living? What happens when strongly divergent feelings and impulses reside within one person?
In the very next parasha, Vayishlach, Jacob literally tackles that question. He is on his way to a final confrontation with his brother Esau. The night before, he is alone and is assaulted by a strange “man” whom he engages in what might be called an epic “smackdown,” a wrestling match of cosmic proportions. His opponent, as it turns out, is hunkier than Hulk Hogan, grungier than Goldberg. He is, in fact, a celestial being, probably with super powers. Yet he can’t defeat Jacob. What’s going on here? Isn’t this the Jacob who runs from confrontation – the mama’s boy who survives by wit, not muscle?
We know that Jacob, despite his cunning and business acumen is no warrior -- that’s his brother Esau. Jacob got the brains. So how does he win a split decision with Iron Man?
There’s no sports section in the Bible, no box scores, no blow-by-blow, just a few verses devoted to the match. But we do know some important details. The story begins in Genesis 32:23. “That same night he arose and taking his two wives, his two maidservants, and his eleven children, he crossed the ford of the Jabbock.” A neat trick in the middle of the night! I know that if I woke my kids and my two wives (okay, I only have one) up in the middle of the night and asked them to cross a river, I’d also find myself in a fight to the death. What was Jacob’s hurry?
Jacob schleps his family and all their belongings across the river in the dark. The great Jewish scholar Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman says “He made them pass the brook.” I’ll bet he did. The parasha continues, “After taking them across the stream, he sent across all his possessions.”(Gen. 32:24) So he makes the mishpacha cross the river, goes back to the other side, sends his processions along, and remains there alone, waiting.
This reminds me of the scene in countless cowboy movies where the sheriff says to the townspeople “lock up the women-folk and young’ns, there’s gonna be some shootin’and some dyin’!” Gary Cooper knows what’s coming, and so does Jacob. And like the sheriff in “High Noon,” Jacob is controlling the situation.
Jacob knows he needs to have it out once and for all to bring peace to his family. So he waits there in the dark for The Incredible Hulk. Yes, I’ve now given away the real identity of the “man” or angel with whom Jacob tangles. It’s the big hairy monster whose secret identity is mild-mannered Bruce Banner. The Green Guy is a pretty good metaphor for the “Hulk” that lives in Jacob. He has to master the conniving, weak and disloyal creature that lives within himself before he has the strength to face Esau -- to face his own guilt. He can’t really cross the river Jabbock (a Biblical pun on the name Jacob?) until he’s conquered his past, cleaned the slate, and become ready to make peace with his brother and himself, or to die trying.
As descendents of Jacob, we benefit from the realization that his greatness came not only from his leadership of others, but from his willingness to conquer and control his greatest adversary -- himself.
Shabbat Shalom.
Cantor Phil Baron
Last week Rabbi Steinberg wrote about the Bible’s tendency to present opposing points of view. In examining Rachel’s dilemma in parashat Vayeitsei the rabbi very clearly pointed out the Bible’s many opinions on Rachel’s conception of motherhood and womanhood. In reading his argument I wondered: Is the Bible asking us to consider many sides of an issue, or is it making a statement about ambivalence as a natural part of living? What happens when strongly divergent feelings and impulses reside within one person?
In the very next parasha, Vayishlach, Jacob literally tackles that question. He is on his way to a final confrontation with his brother Esau. The night before, he is alone and is assaulted by a strange “man” whom he engages in what might be called an epic “smackdown,” a wrestling match of cosmic proportions. His opponent, as it turns out, is hunkier than Hulk Hogan, grungier than Goldberg. He is, in fact, a celestial being, probably with super powers. Yet he can’t defeat Jacob. What’s going on here? Isn’t this the Jacob who runs from confrontation – the mama’s boy who survives by wit, not muscle?
We know that Jacob, despite his cunning and business acumen is no warrior -- that’s his brother Esau. Jacob got the brains. So how does he win a split decision with Iron Man?
There’s no sports section in the Bible, no box scores, no blow-by-blow, just a few verses devoted to the match. But we do know some important details. The story begins in Genesis 32:23. “That same night he arose and taking his two wives, his two maidservants, and his eleven children, he crossed the ford of the Jabbock.” A neat trick in the middle of the night! I know that if I woke my kids and my two wives (okay, I only have one) up in the middle of the night and asked them to cross a river, I’d also find myself in a fight to the death. What was Jacob’s hurry?
Jacob schleps his family and all their belongings across the river in the dark. The great Jewish scholar Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman says “He made them pass the brook.” I’ll bet he did. The parasha continues, “After taking them across the stream, he sent across all his possessions.”(Gen. 32:24) So he makes the mishpacha cross the river, goes back to the other side, sends his processions along, and remains there alone, waiting.
This reminds me of the scene in countless cowboy movies where the sheriff says to the townspeople “lock up the women-folk and young’ns, there’s gonna be some shootin’and some dyin’!” Gary Cooper knows what’s coming, and so does Jacob. And like the sheriff in “High Noon,” Jacob is controlling the situation.
Jacob knows he needs to have it out once and for all to bring peace to his family. So he waits there in the dark for The Incredible Hulk. Yes, I’ve now given away the real identity of the “man” or angel with whom Jacob tangles. It’s the big hairy monster whose secret identity is mild-mannered Bruce Banner. The Green Guy is a pretty good metaphor for the “Hulk” that lives in Jacob. He has to master the conniving, weak and disloyal creature that lives within himself before he has the strength to face Esau -- to face his own guilt. He can’t really cross the river Jabbock (a Biblical pun on the name Jacob?) until he’s conquered his past, cleaned the slate, and become ready to make peace with his brother and himself, or to die trying.
As descendents of Jacob, we benefit from the realization that his greatness came not only from his leadership of others, but from his willingness to conquer and control his greatest adversary -- himself.
Shabbat Shalom.
Friday, November 12, 2010
Shabbat Shalom November 12-13, 2010
Parshat Va-Yetzei
Rabbi Paul Steinberg
"Give me children, or I shall die. This is what Rachel said to Jacob" (Gen. 30:1), seeing that she was barren and that her sister, Leah, continued to conceive.
As we read Rachel’s painful supplication, we immediately understand the despair that infertility brings. Many of us have been touched, either directly or indirectly by infertility and understand the sorrow it brings to couples, especially women. We hear her pain and can relate to it.
That being said, it seems unlikely that we might hear such a drastic statement from women in the 21st century; presumably, suicide or fertility would be a false choice for most women in our modern society. In this past century and a half, women have fought hard to be valued as mothers but also not to be defined by motherhood alone [the national average for women having their first child is app. 25 yrs]. In fact, the wisdom of feminism is that no one should assume that motherhood is all of womanhood, and that women have equal voices in many other arenas of society. Thus, this text poses a strange contemporary dilemma as we see our matriarch, Rachel, basing the value of her life and her very existence only upon her motherhood. On one hand we can relate to her pain, yet on the other, we may distance ourselves because she goes too far.
There are two primary ways with which to read such a difficult biblical verse from our modern perspective. One is apologetics. That is to say, we assume that even though it may be difficult and counter to our cultural sensibilities, there must be some deep and abiding truth that we can attribute to this verse. Apologetics would therefore acknowledge that Rachel may go too far for many women today, but ultimately, defend her position in defining her womanhood as motherhood.
The second way to read this text would be to dismiss it. That is, we might say that the text is clearly written from the perspective of a time and place that is no longer relevant. In other words, we may acknowledge that it may have been true that Rachel’s womanhood and existence was actually based on her ability to bear children, but that simply isn’t the case today. Therefore, we can dismiss the verse to the files of anthropologists.
I want to recommend a third possible approach to the text, which is suggested by Judy Klitsner, the author of "Subversive Sequels in the Bible: How Biblical Stories Mine and Undermine Each Other." In her book, Klitsner convincingly argues that it is possible to read the stories and ideas presented in the Bible as if they are in conversation with one another – reacting and even arguing with each other. So, we may read of Rachel’s conception of womanhood as motherhood in this verse and parsha, yet elsewhere we will find other voices either in agreement or in contention with the one we have here.
For now, I want to point out both a place in which the Bible agrees with Rachel’s concept of womanhood and a place where it disagrees. Regarding the former, we must turn back to chapter three in Genesis with the story of Eden (this is actually the third story of womanhood within the first three chapters alone). This is, of course the story of the fall of Adam and Eve. Each of them sin and each of them are punished. As for God’s punishment of Eve, the Torah states (Gen. 3:16):
"And to the woman He said,
‘I will make most severe your pangs in childbearing;
in pain you shall bear children.
Yet your urge shall be for your husband,
and he shall rule over you.’"
And four verses later, following the litany of curses to Adam and the serpent, the text continues (Gen 3:20):
"The man named his wife Eve (Chava, from the verb root meaning “life”), because she was the mother of all the living."
Here we see that following the sin of disobedience in the Garden of Eden, Eve – who is named for her life-giving capacity – is quite literally limited to her function as a mother. Of course, motherhood is a grand and magnificent gift with which women are bestowed. However, a grand blessing can become a burden and used to subvert rights when such a grand blessing is understood to be the totality of one’s identity and worth. This is what seems to be the case here in Genesis, as well as in our parsha with Rachel, wherein her existential identity as a mother has indeed become a burden. Moreover, because she was unsuccessful in actualizing her one and only gift, she rendered herself and her life utterly worthless.
There is also an opposing voice to Rachel’s conception of motherhood and womanhood. We find it explicitly in the fourth and fifth chapters of the Book of Judges. This is the story of the Deborah. Here we encounter Deborah who is married yet has no children and, paradoxically, she is referred to as “mother of Israel” – Em b’Yisrael (Judges 5:7). Not literally a mother, Deborah is a prophetess and a leader of the people both in the wisdom that she offers and inspiration she brings to the battlefield. Furthermore, within Deborah’s story, we meet Yael – also married and childless – who helps to defeat the enemy by acting as a military assassin. The story is rather clear on this issue: neither of our heroes, Deborah nor Yael, could possibly be limited in their value as human beings by their motherhood alone.
As a brother to five sisters, as a husband to a brilliant and beautiful wife, as a father to three wonderful daughters, and as a son to a mother, I can honestly say that I still know nothing about what it is to be a woman! I am comforted, however, to see that the Torah itself also has no one answer as to what it means to be a woman (or man, for that matter). Instead we see that there are different ways of understanding the value and purpose of our gender. That’s what’s so amazing and incredible about our Bible – it is honest enough and mature enough to draw upon a cacophony of voices and ideas, recognizing that the truth may lie within all of them together.
Rabbi Paul Steinberg
"Give me children, or I shall die. This is what Rachel said to Jacob" (Gen. 30:1), seeing that she was barren and that her sister, Leah, continued to conceive.
As we read Rachel’s painful supplication, we immediately understand the despair that infertility brings. Many of us have been touched, either directly or indirectly by infertility and understand the sorrow it brings to couples, especially women. We hear her pain and can relate to it.
That being said, it seems unlikely that we might hear such a drastic statement from women in the 21st century; presumably, suicide or fertility would be a false choice for most women in our modern society. In this past century and a half, women have fought hard to be valued as mothers but also not to be defined by motherhood alone [the national average for women having their first child is app. 25 yrs]. In fact, the wisdom of feminism is that no one should assume that motherhood is all of womanhood, and that women have equal voices in many other arenas of society. Thus, this text poses a strange contemporary dilemma as we see our matriarch, Rachel, basing the value of her life and her very existence only upon her motherhood. On one hand we can relate to her pain, yet on the other, we may distance ourselves because she goes too far.
There are two primary ways with which to read such a difficult biblical verse from our modern perspective. One is apologetics. That is to say, we assume that even though it may be difficult and counter to our cultural sensibilities, there must be some deep and abiding truth that we can attribute to this verse. Apologetics would therefore acknowledge that Rachel may go too far for many women today, but ultimately, defend her position in defining her womanhood as motherhood.
The second way to read this text would be to dismiss it. That is, we might say that the text is clearly written from the perspective of a time and place that is no longer relevant. In other words, we may acknowledge that it may have been true that Rachel’s womanhood and existence was actually based on her ability to bear children, but that simply isn’t the case today. Therefore, we can dismiss the verse to the files of anthropologists.
I want to recommend a third possible approach to the text, which is suggested by Judy Klitsner, the author of "Subversive Sequels in the Bible: How Biblical Stories Mine and Undermine Each Other." In her book, Klitsner convincingly argues that it is possible to read the stories and ideas presented in the Bible as if they are in conversation with one another – reacting and even arguing with each other. So, we may read of Rachel’s conception of womanhood as motherhood in this verse and parsha, yet elsewhere we will find other voices either in agreement or in contention with the one we have here.
For now, I want to point out both a place in which the Bible agrees with Rachel’s concept of womanhood and a place where it disagrees. Regarding the former, we must turn back to chapter three in Genesis with the story of Eden (this is actually the third story of womanhood within the first three chapters alone). This is, of course the story of the fall of Adam and Eve. Each of them sin and each of them are punished. As for God’s punishment of Eve, the Torah states (Gen. 3:16):
"And to the woman He said,
‘I will make most severe your pangs in childbearing;
in pain you shall bear children.
Yet your urge shall be for your husband,
and he shall rule over you.’"
And four verses later, following the litany of curses to Adam and the serpent, the text continues (Gen 3:20):
"The man named his wife Eve (Chava, from the verb root meaning “life”), because she was the mother of all the living."
Here we see that following the sin of disobedience in the Garden of Eden, Eve – who is named for her life-giving capacity – is quite literally limited to her function as a mother. Of course, motherhood is a grand and magnificent gift with which women are bestowed. However, a grand blessing can become a burden and used to subvert rights when such a grand blessing is understood to be the totality of one’s identity and worth. This is what seems to be the case here in Genesis, as well as in our parsha with Rachel, wherein her existential identity as a mother has indeed become a burden. Moreover, because she was unsuccessful in actualizing her one and only gift, she rendered herself and her life utterly worthless.
There is also an opposing voice to Rachel’s conception of motherhood and womanhood. We find it explicitly in the fourth and fifth chapters of the Book of Judges. This is the story of the Deborah. Here we encounter Deborah who is married yet has no children and, paradoxically, she is referred to as “mother of Israel” – Em b’Yisrael (Judges 5:7). Not literally a mother, Deborah is a prophetess and a leader of the people both in the wisdom that she offers and inspiration she brings to the battlefield. Furthermore, within Deborah’s story, we meet Yael – also married and childless – who helps to defeat the enemy by acting as a military assassin. The story is rather clear on this issue: neither of our heroes, Deborah nor Yael, could possibly be limited in their value as human beings by their motherhood alone.
As a brother to five sisters, as a husband to a brilliant and beautiful wife, as a father to three wonderful daughters, and as a son to a mother, I can honestly say that I still know nothing about what it is to be a woman! I am comforted, however, to see that the Torah itself also has no one answer as to what it means to be a woman (or man, for that matter). Instead we see that there are different ways of understanding the value and purpose of our gender. That’s what’s so amazing and incredible about our Bible – it is honest enough and mature enough to draw upon a cacophony of voices and ideas, recognizing that the truth may lie within all of them together.
Friday, October 22, 2010
Shabbat Shalom Oct. 22-23 2010
Vayera - Cantor Herschel Fox
Chapter XVIII
1. And the Lord appeared unto him by the terebinths of Mamre, as he sat in the tent door in the heat of the day; 2. and he lifted up his eyes and looked , and, lo three men stood over against him; and when he saw them, he ran to meet them from the tent door, and bowed down to the earth, 3. And said; “My lord, if now I have found favor in thy sight, pass not away. I pray thee, from thy servant. 4. Let now a little water be fetched, and wash your feet, and recline yourselves under the tree. 5. And I will fetch a morsel of bread, and stay ye your heart; after that ye shall pass on; forasmuch as ye are come to your servant.’ And they said; ‘So do, as thou hast said.’ 6. Abraham hastened unto the tent unto Sarah, and said; ‘Make ready quickly three measures of fine meal, knead it, and make cakes.’ 7. And Abraham ran unto the herd, and fetched a calf tender and good, and gave it unto the servant; and he hastened to dress it. 8. And he took curd, and milk, and the calf which he had dressed, and set it before them; and he . . .
I am honored to offer a few words about this week’s Sidrah “Vayera.” Eight verses express one of the greatest traits or characteristics of our people – Abraham, our patriarch personified the wonderful mitzvah of “Hachnasat Orchim” – “Being kind to guests,” welcoming the stranger, being kind to a visitor, making someone welcome.
May I speak from personal experience? In 1949, when I was four years old, my parents and I came to Canada, thanks to my father’s cousin who probably saved our lives. My parents were Holocaust survivors. We came to Winnipeg – a cold city with warm Jews. Between 1946 and 1951, many survivors were welcomed to Winnipeg by a warm Jewish community.
This community gave the survivor families help with accommodations, language classes, funding, jobs, medical help, and many other forms of assistance. When kids went to Jewish schools and parents asked “How much does it cost?” the answer was “Whatever you can afford, if you can afford anything.”
When my mother went to the Yiddish school in our neighborhood, the executive director, Mr. Cohen, began to cry when he realized what my parents went through in Europe. He knew we were penniless, but didn’t want to embarrass us, so he asked if we could pay $2 a month, and that’s what we paid for seven years. He cared about us. He was a real “Machnis Orach” — he welcomed the guest, he welcomed the stranger.
May I offer one more example of “Hachnasat Orchim?” Thirty years ago, when I began my new job at Valley Beth Shalom, numerous people welcomed my wife and me to their homes, opened their hearts to us, and truly made us comfortable. Within weeks we felt this was our community and our home.
No wonder that every morning when we pray “Eilu D’varim,” we mention that there are mitzvot of which you cannot do too much. “Hachnasat Orchim” is one of the mitzvot mentioned. Helping the stranger, welcoming the guest, assisting someone in trouble — each one is a great mitzvah. What a wonderful trait to encourage in our children and in ourselves.
Chapter XVIII
1. And the Lord appeared unto him by the terebinths of Mamre, as he sat in the tent door in the heat of the day; 2. and he lifted up his eyes and looked , and, lo three men stood over against him; and when he saw them, he ran to meet them from the tent door, and bowed down to the earth, 3. And said; “My lord, if now I have found favor in thy sight, pass not away. I pray thee, from thy servant. 4. Let now a little water be fetched, and wash your feet, and recline yourselves under the tree. 5. And I will fetch a morsel of bread, and stay ye your heart; after that ye shall pass on; forasmuch as ye are come to your servant.’ And they said; ‘So do, as thou hast said.’ 6. Abraham hastened unto the tent unto Sarah, and said; ‘Make ready quickly three measures of fine meal, knead it, and make cakes.’ 7. And Abraham ran unto the herd, and fetched a calf tender and good, and gave it unto the servant; and he hastened to dress it. 8. And he took curd, and milk, and the calf which he had dressed, and set it before them; and he . . .
I am honored to offer a few words about this week’s Sidrah “Vayera.” Eight verses express one of the greatest traits or characteristics of our people – Abraham, our patriarch personified the wonderful mitzvah of “Hachnasat Orchim” – “Being kind to guests,” welcoming the stranger, being kind to a visitor, making someone welcome.
May I speak from personal experience? In 1949, when I was four years old, my parents and I came to Canada, thanks to my father’s cousin who probably saved our lives. My parents were Holocaust survivors. We came to Winnipeg – a cold city with warm Jews. Between 1946 and 1951, many survivors were welcomed to Winnipeg by a warm Jewish community.
This community gave the survivor families help with accommodations, language classes, funding, jobs, medical help, and many other forms of assistance. When kids went to Jewish schools and parents asked “How much does it cost?” the answer was “Whatever you can afford, if you can afford anything.”
When my mother went to the Yiddish school in our neighborhood, the executive director, Mr. Cohen, began to cry when he realized what my parents went through in Europe. He knew we were penniless, but didn’t want to embarrass us, so he asked if we could pay $2 a month, and that’s what we paid for seven years. He cared about us. He was a real “Machnis Orach” — he welcomed the guest, he welcomed the stranger.
May I offer one more example of “Hachnasat Orchim?” Thirty years ago, when I began my new job at Valley Beth Shalom, numerous people welcomed my wife and me to their homes, opened their hearts to us, and truly made us comfortable. Within weeks we felt this was our community and our home.
No wonder that every morning when we pray “Eilu D’varim,” we mention that there are mitzvot of which you cannot do too much. “Hachnasat Orchim” is one of the mitzvot mentioned. Helping the stranger, welcoming the guest, assisting someone in trouble — each one is a great mitzvah. What a wonderful trait to encourage in our children and in ourselves.
Friday, October 15, 2010
Shabbat Shalom October 15-16, 2010
LECH LECHA, 1997
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
You know me, Rabbi. You know how important the synagogue is to me, how much I enjoy services, you see me at your Torah classes. You know what kind of Jew I am: I am the only one at the family Seder table who can read the Hebrew side of the Hagadda, but they won't accept me because I wasn't born Jewish!
Every rabbi has heard these painful testimonies.
After my conversion, the Christians in my office congratulated me on this special moment. They wanted to hear all about the ritual and about my new faith. The Jews, on the other hand, made sarcastic remarks. Someone wondered aloud if they'd given me a Bloomingdale's charge card at the Mikva as the symbol of my Jewishness.
Sociologically, it can be explained. Judaism is a unique composite of religion and ethnicity. One can convert into a religion by adopting its beliefs and practices. One cannot convert into an ethnicity. Ethnicity is family, it is blood. Try as one may, one cannot become Italian or Irish. Ethnicity is expressed in a complex and subtle culture of shared memories, language and symbols. Facing an ethnic culture, the outsider can at best become the equivalent of a daughter-in-law or son-in-law: invited to sit at the family table even though one may never get our family jokes or share our intimate memories. You can come to the table, but you'll never really feel at home. In an American Jewish community, where ethnic identity far outweighs spirituality, the convert faces a difficult dilemma-how to ever feel at home as a Jew.
This is compounded by the Jewish experience of two thousand years of oppression and exile. In response to castigation and humiliation, Jews erected a powerful internal barrier between Us and Them. The defense against ghetto walls was an internal wall. But now that we are secure in a free democracy the internal walls remain, held up by old fears and prejudice. Even when Jews assimilate, losing all vestiges of faith and culture, the last thing to go are the internal walls. They don't attend synagogue, own a Bible, or celebrate a Seder, but they won't hesistate to tell her that she's not really Jewish.
Have we forgotten that the Jewish experience began with a radical act of decision, with a conversion?
The Lord said to Abram, "Go forth from your land, from you birthplace, from your father's house to the land that I will show you... and you will be a blessing." (Genesis 12: 1 2)
The convert's journey follows the same radical route of Abram and Sarai. Cutting one's self off from the familiar and the safe, from all that provides identity in this world- home and family, culture and memory to pursue a promise. We call them ben or bat Avraham v'Sarah-the child of Abraham and Sarah. The children of Abraham and Sarah live among us!
An alternative interpretation reads God's command Lech lecha as "Go into yourself!" Abram's journey is not geographic but spiritual. Those who have chosen Judaism are living witnesses to the spiritual journey of Judaism. They are a blessing to us for they teach us that the essence of the Jew is not in ethnic affectations -- bagels and Yiddish quips -- but in the deepest spiritual search for meaning and joy in life, in Covenant with God.
Eight hundred years ago, Maimonides heard the same painful cry. A convert named Ovadia was barred from praying with the congregation because some questioned how he could offer prayers to the "God of our ancestors". With all his rhetorical power Rambam responded: "Anyone who becomes a convert is a pupil of our father Abraham and all of them are members of his household. You may say, 'God of our ancestors' for Abraham is your father...and there is no difference between us and you. Toward father and mother we are commanded to show honor and reverence, toward prophets to obey them, but toward converts we are commanded to have great love in our hearts...God in His glory loves the convert."
Shabbat Shalom
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
You know me, Rabbi. You know how important the synagogue is to me, how much I enjoy services, you see me at your Torah classes. You know what kind of Jew I am: I am the only one at the family Seder table who can read the Hebrew side of the Hagadda, but they won't accept me because I wasn't born Jewish!
Every rabbi has heard these painful testimonies.
After my conversion, the Christians in my office congratulated me on this special moment. They wanted to hear all about the ritual and about my new faith. The Jews, on the other hand, made sarcastic remarks. Someone wondered aloud if they'd given me a Bloomingdale's charge card at the Mikva as the symbol of my Jewishness.
Sociologically, it can be explained. Judaism is a unique composite of religion and ethnicity. One can convert into a religion by adopting its beliefs and practices. One cannot convert into an ethnicity. Ethnicity is family, it is blood. Try as one may, one cannot become Italian or Irish. Ethnicity is expressed in a complex and subtle culture of shared memories, language and symbols. Facing an ethnic culture, the outsider can at best become the equivalent of a daughter-in-law or son-in-law: invited to sit at the family table even though one may never get our family jokes or share our intimate memories. You can come to the table, but you'll never really feel at home. In an American Jewish community, where ethnic identity far outweighs spirituality, the convert faces a difficult dilemma-how to ever feel at home as a Jew.
This is compounded by the Jewish experience of two thousand years of oppression and exile. In response to castigation and humiliation, Jews erected a powerful internal barrier between Us and Them. The defense against ghetto walls was an internal wall. But now that we are secure in a free democracy the internal walls remain, held up by old fears and prejudice. Even when Jews assimilate, losing all vestiges of faith and culture, the last thing to go are the internal walls. They don't attend synagogue, own a Bible, or celebrate a Seder, but they won't hesistate to tell her that she's not really Jewish.
Have we forgotten that the Jewish experience began with a radical act of decision, with a conversion?
The Lord said to Abram, "Go forth from your land, from you birthplace, from your father's house to the land that I will show you... and you will be a blessing." (Genesis 12: 1 2)
The convert's journey follows the same radical route of Abram and Sarai. Cutting one's self off from the familiar and the safe, from all that provides identity in this world- home and family, culture and memory to pursue a promise. We call them ben or bat Avraham v'Sarah-the child of Abraham and Sarah. The children of Abraham and Sarah live among us!
An alternative interpretation reads God's command Lech lecha as "Go into yourself!" Abram's journey is not geographic but spiritual. Those who have chosen Judaism are living witnesses to the spiritual journey of Judaism. They are a blessing to us for they teach us that the essence of the Jew is not in ethnic affectations -- bagels and Yiddish quips -- but in the deepest spiritual search for meaning and joy in life, in Covenant with God.
Eight hundred years ago, Maimonides heard the same painful cry. A convert named Ovadia was barred from praying with the congregation because some questioned how he could offer prayers to the "God of our ancestors". With all his rhetorical power Rambam responded: "Anyone who becomes a convert is a pupil of our father Abraham and all of them are members of his household. You may say, 'God of our ancestors' for Abraham is your father...and there is no difference between us and you. Toward father and mother we are commanded to show honor and reverence, toward prophets to obey them, but toward converts we are commanded to have great love in our hearts...God in His glory loves the convert."
Shabbat Shalom
Friday, October 8, 2010
Shabbat Shalom October 8-9, 2010
TWO VIEWS OF RIGHTEOUSNESS
Parhsat Noach 5771
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
A Jew once came to Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk and asked him for advice about how to warm his frigid home in the winter (after all we’re talking a Polish winter.) He said to the Jew, “When the house is cold, there are two ways to get yourself warm. You can warm up the house, or you can put on a coat. The first way warms up the house for everyone, while the second way warms you up but leaves everyone else in the cold.
While he may have been talking about a cold house, in reality the Kotzker Rebbe was highlighting two fundamental worldviews. When faced with the complexities of human living, we can see ourselves as living in a world of the self that does not include others or we can try the harder task of seeing the world of the self as inclusive of others. We can warm ourselves with a coat, or we can warm others by raising the temperature of the entire house.
This debate is an ancient one, with roots planted deep in the Talmud’s discussion of this week’s Torah portion, Noach:
‘Noach was a righteous man, and perfect in his generation’ (Genesis 6:9). Rabbi Yohanan explained [that Noach was righteous and perfect] only in his own generation, but not [in respect] to others. But Reish Lakish explained the verse saying, Noach was righteous in his own generation, and how much the more so would he have been [in respect] to others! (Sanhedrin 108a)
Framed as a question of righteousness, both Rabbi Yohanan and Reish Lakish see Noach as a righteous individual. For Rabbi Yohanan, Noach was not extraordinary - he was a simple, moral human being and his righteousness stemmed from the fact that he was surrounded by wickedness. Reish Lakish, on the other hand saw the story of the flood as an extraordinary event that required an extraordinary level of moral heroism. From this debate, our two worldviews again emerge. In the face of great adversity and moral turpitude, Noach saves himself, his family, and the animal kingdom. He is either indicted for being selfish (he didn’t save other human beings), or lauded for taking a moral stand when it wasn’t popular. In fact, further in Talmud, Noach is cast as the prophet, who tells humanity to repent, but is rebuffed by a populace consumed by avarice and greed. (Sanhedrin 108b). Either Noach is selfish, wearing a warm coat to protect only himself, or he tries to warm the house – and fails.
In many ways, the ancient debate between a strict sense of self-interest and a strong belief in communitarian values defines the political debate that is raging in our country. Do we as a community of individuals hold strong to our sense of personal liberty, defined by our desire for autonomous living, or do we see ourselves engaged in a wider communal project where we quest for human commonalities, defined by equal rights and protections. The political philosopher Isaiah Berlin pointed out the conflict between liberty and equality in a number of places, most poignantly in his essay, “The Pursuit of the Ideal” where he says, “Liberty- without at least a modicum of which … there is no possibility of remaining human – may have to be curtailed to make room for social welfare, to feed the hungry, to clothe the naked, to shelter the homeless…to allow justice or fairness to be exercised. ”
In this light, the choice Noach makes is crucial to our understanding of radical biblical individualism. Nowhere in the story or in the rabbinic interpretation of it does Noach argue with God as Abraham did on the hills overlooking Sodom and Gomorrah or cast his lot with the people as Moses did in the wilderness. Noach in fact is silent the entire time. Perhaps this is why the rabbinic tradition tends to indict Noah, for he chose the most radical of positions in the most critical of moments by saving himself, while allowing the rest of the world to drown.
While conceding that our values are often at war with each other, the Jewish tradition overcomes the tragic notion of value incommensurability by looking to integrate the values together under the rubric of Holiness, imagined as the Holy One in who is the loadstone of all value. This is the lesson that Noach failed to learn through the trial of the Flood. I believe this is also the lesson that we as a nation are failing to learn in our current political climate. Instead of integrating the notions of the individual and the community, of liberty and equality, we devote ourselves to a single value, often floating it seriatim over other values, and refusing to acknowledge that other values carry moral weight. We fail to see what all values share in common with each other, and what they share with the role of God – namely that they all direct us to pursue a flourishing life.
If we learn anything from the story of Noach, it is that he makes the choice to be a radical individual and the world suffers because of it. For that, we as a Jewish people do not trace our heritage through him. Instead, we learn what Noach learned upon his departure from the ark, that in a world devastated by the Flood, we can cast our eyes upward and see a better model for communal discourse. In that instant when our eyes peer into heaven, we can see the rainbow, the visual symbol of the covenantal integration of values that is becoming of a Godly individual and a Godly community.
Parhsat Noach 5771
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
A Jew once came to Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk and asked him for advice about how to warm his frigid home in the winter (after all we’re talking a Polish winter.) He said to the Jew, “When the house is cold, there are two ways to get yourself warm. You can warm up the house, or you can put on a coat. The first way warms up the house for everyone, while the second way warms you up but leaves everyone else in the cold.
While he may have been talking about a cold house, in reality the Kotzker Rebbe was highlighting two fundamental worldviews. When faced with the complexities of human living, we can see ourselves as living in a world of the self that does not include others or we can try the harder task of seeing the world of the self as inclusive of others. We can warm ourselves with a coat, or we can warm others by raising the temperature of the entire house.
This debate is an ancient one, with roots planted deep in the Talmud’s discussion of this week’s Torah portion, Noach:
‘Noach was a righteous man, and perfect in his generation’ (Genesis 6:9). Rabbi Yohanan explained [that Noach was righteous and perfect] only in his own generation, but not [in respect] to others. But Reish Lakish explained the verse saying, Noach was righteous in his own generation, and how much the more so would he have been [in respect] to others! (Sanhedrin 108a)
Framed as a question of righteousness, both Rabbi Yohanan and Reish Lakish see Noach as a righteous individual. For Rabbi Yohanan, Noach was not extraordinary - he was a simple, moral human being and his righteousness stemmed from the fact that he was surrounded by wickedness. Reish Lakish, on the other hand saw the story of the flood as an extraordinary event that required an extraordinary level of moral heroism. From this debate, our two worldviews again emerge. In the face of great adversity and moral turpitude, Noach saves himself, his family, and the animal kingdom. He is either indicted for being selfish (he didn’t save other human beings), or lauded for taking a moral stand when it wasn’t popular. In fact, further in Talmud, Noach is cast as the prophet, who tells humanity to repent, but is rebuffed by a populace consumed by avarice and greed. (Sanhedrin 108b). Either Noach is selfish, wearing a warm coat to protect only himself, or he tries to warm the house – and fails.
In many ways, the ancient debate between a strict sense of self-interest and a strong belief in communitarian values defines the political debate that is raging in our country. Do we as a community of individuals hold strong to our sense of personal liberty, defined by our desire for autonomous living, or do we see ourselves engaged in a wider communal project where we quest for human commonalities, defined by equal rights and protections. The political philosopher Isaiah Berlin pointed out the conflict between liberty and equality in a number of places, most poignantly in his essay, “The Pursuit of the Ideal” where he says, “Liberty- without at least a modicum of which … there is no possibility of remaining human – may have to be curtailed to make room for social welfare, to feed the hungry, to clothe the naked, to shelter the homeless…to allow justice or fairness to be exercised. ”
In this light, the choice Noach makes is crucial to our understanding of radical biblical individualism. Nowhere in the story or in the rabbinic interpretation of it does Noach argue with God as Abraham did on the hills overlooking Sodom and Gomorrah or cast his lot with the people as Moses did in the wilderness. Noach in fact is silent the entire time. Perhaps this is why the rabbinic tradition tends to indict Noah, for he chose the most radical of positions in the most critical of moments by saving himself, while allowing the rest of the world to drown.
While conceding that our values are often at war with each other, the Jewish tradition overcomes the tragic notion of value incommensurability by looking to integrate the values together under the rubric of Holiness, imagined as the Holy One in who is the loadstone of all value. This is the lesson that Noach failed to learn through the trial of the Flood. I believe this is also the lesson that we as a nation are failing to learn in our current political climate. Instead of integrating the notions of the individual and the community, of liberty and equality, we devote ourselves to a single value, often floating it seriatim over other values, and refusing to acknowledge that other values carry moral weight. We fail to see what all values share in common with each other, and what they share with the role of God – namely that they all direct us to pursue a flourishing life.
If we learn anything from the story of Noach, it is that he makes the choice to be a radical individual and the world suffers because of it. For that, we as a Jewish people do not trace our heritage through him. Instead, we learn what Noach learned upon his departure from the ark, that in a world devastated by the Flood, we can cast our eyes upward and see a better model for communal discourse. In that instant when our eyes peer into heaven, we can see the rainbow, the visual symbol of the covenantal integration of values that is becoming of a Godly individual and a Godly community.
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
Hag Sameach and Shabbat Shalom September 29-October 2, 2010
What is Shemini Atzeret?
Not quite Sukkot, not quite its own holiday.
Rabbi Paul Steinberg-excerpted from "Celebrating the Jewish Year: The Fall Holidays"
Although Hoshanah Rabbah may technically be the "last day" of Sukkot, the Rabbis decided to treat Shemini Atzeret (and Simhat Torah) as a part of Sukkot, because its significance is unequivocally informed by Sukkot itself.
Two cryptic references in the Torah cause the confusion about the status of Shemini Atzeret. In both Leviticus and Numbers, God commands that the eighth (shemini) day--referring to Sukkot--is to be a "sacred occasion" and an atzeret, generally translated as "solemn gathering."
What is Atzeret?
The inherent problem is that no one really knows exactly what atzeret means. Possibly it comes from the word atzar, meaning "stop," and thus implies that we are to refrain from work. On the other hand, atzeret may also be defined by its textual context, which implies that it is some sort of deliberate extension of the prior seven days. This lack of verbal clarity is likely the reason why the rabbinic sages seemed to struggle with the precise meaning of the holiday.
The earliest rabbinic reference to Shemini Atzeret calls it yom tov aharon shel ha-hag, the last day of the festival. The Talmud (Taanit 20b-31a), however, declares, "The eighth day is a festival in its own right." At the same time, the Talmud (Taanit 28b) attempts to distinguish it from Sukkot, as there are 70 temple sacrifices given throughout Sukkot, compared to only one given on Shemini Atzeret. (This distinction was only theoretical as the Temple had been destroyed five centuries prior to the redaction of the Talmud.)
Cutting through this puzzle, the most appealing depiction of the holiday may be that of Samson Raphael Hirsch, a 19th-century Orthodox rabbi who lived in Germany. He infers the meaning of the holiday from the word atzeret, which he renders as "to gather" or "to store up." Accordingly, on this eighth day of Sukkot, the final day of celebration, we must store up the sentiments of gratitude and devotion acquired throughout the entire fall holiday season; nearly two months will pass until we celebrate another holiday, that of Hanukkah.
Different from Sukkot
Although the observances of Shemini Atzeret generally share the characteristics of the rest of Sukkot, there are four significant differences. The first is that there is no more shaking of the lulav and etrog. Second is that although we have our meals and recite Kiddush in the sukkah (though customs vary), we no longer say the blessing to sanctify us through the commandment to dwell in it, as we did the previous seven days. The third is that in the synagogue, after the Torah reading, we recite the memorial prayer (Yizkor).
And finally, the special prayer for rain (Geshem) is added to the repetition of Musaf and thus begins the period of an additional call for rain in our prayers, which lasts until Passover. It is customary for the leader of the Geshem prayer to wear a kitel as was done during the divine judgment of the High Holidays. Wearing the garment indicates that this is the season of divine judgment for the future year's rainfall, the time when we pray that God's goodwill may afford us the appropriate amount.
Not quite Sukkot, not quite its own holiday.
Rabbi Paul Steinberg-excerpted from "Celebrating the Jewish Year: The Fall Holidays"
Although Hoshanah Rabbah may technically be the "last day" of Sukkot, the Rabbis decided to treat Shemini Atzeret (and Simhat Torah) as a part of Sukkot, because its significance is unequivocally informed by Sukkot itself.
Two cryptic references in the Torah cause the confusion about the status of Shemini Atzeret. In both Leviticus and Numbers, God commands that the eighth (shemini) day--referring to Sukkot--is to be a "sacred occasion" and an atzeret, generally translated as "solemn gathering."
What is Atzeret?
The inherent problem is that no one really knows exactly what atzeret means. Possibly it comes from the word atzar, meaning "stop," and thus implies that we are to refrain from work. On the other hand, atzeret may also be defined by its textual context, which implies that it is some sort of deliberate extension of the prior seven days. This lack of verbal clarity is likely the reason why the rabbinic sages seemed to struggle with the precise meaning of the holiday.
The earliest rabbinic reference to Shemini Atzeret calls it yom tov aharon shel ha-hag, the last day of the festival. The Talmud (Taanit 20b-31a), however, declares, "The eighth day is a festival in its own right." At the same time, the Talmud (Taanit 28b) attempts to distinguish it from Sukkot, as there are 70 temple sacrifices given throughout Sukkot, compared to only one given on Shemini Atzeret. (This distinction was only theoretical as the Temple had been destroyed five centuries prior to the redaction of the Talmud.)
Cutting through this puzzle, the most appealing depiction of the holiday may be that of Samson Raphael Hirsch, a 19th-century Orthodox rabbi who lived in Germany. He infers the meaning of the holiday from the word atzeret, which he renders as "to gather" or "to store up." Accordingly, on this eighth day of Sukkot, the final day of celebration, we must store up the sentiments of gratitude and devotion acquired throughout the entire fall holiday season; nearly two months will pass until we celebrate another holiday, that of Hanukkah.
Different from Sukkot
Although the observances of Shemini Atzeret generally share the characteristics of the rest of Sukkot, there are four significant differences. The first is that there is no more shaking of the lulav and etrog. Second is that although we have our meals and recite Kiddush in the sukkah (though customs vary), we no longer say the blessing to sanctify us through the commandment to dwell in it, as we did the previous seven days. The third is that in the synagogue, after the Torah reading, we recite the memorial prayer (Yizkor).
And finally, the special prayer for rain (Geshem) is added to the repetition of Musaf and thus begins the period of an additional call for rain in our prayers, which lasts until Passover. It is customary for the leader of the Geshem prayer to wear a kitel as was done during the divine judgment of the High Holidays. Wearing the garment indicates that this is the season of divine judgment for the future year's rainfall, the time when we pray that God's goodwill may afford us the appropriate amount.
Wednesday, September 15, 2010
Shabbat Yom Kippur September 17-18, 2010
YOM KIPPUR, 1999
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
When we arrive in heaven, the Talmudic sages wondered, what will God ask of us?
This is not really a question about heaven. It is about how we live and how we locate eternity within life. The philosopher Franz Rosensweig explained that on Yom Kippur we are offered a look at our lives through the eyes of eternity. From that perspective, what do we amount to? What's real? What's important? What matters?
God asks four questions:
Kavaata Itim Latorah? Do you set aside time for learning Torah?
Torah is not only a book, a scroll in the ark. Torah is a process. Torah is the eternal conversation among generations of Jewish thinkers and dreamers -- sharing their perceptions of life's true purpose, of God's presence, of life’s beauty. When we study Torah, we join the conversation. In nature, writes the biologist, Lewis Thomas, there is no such thing as “an ant.” It is the same with Jews. Jews come with ancestors and descendants -- a community spanning generations. What binds us together is our shared wisdom, our Torah. To learn Torah is to enter the eternal Jewish conversation. So God asks, Kavata Itim L'Torah, did you find time for Torah?
Second question: Asakta B'priya U'reviah? Do you devote yourself to family?
God is shrewd. God doesn't ask: Did you learn Torah? God asks: Did you establish a time for study? Do you have control over your time, over your life? And if you don't, who does? Where does your time go?
God doesn't ask, Did you love your family? Did you provide for your children? God asks: Asakta, from the Hebrew esek, business: Is family your preoccupation? Do you invest yourself in family? In family there is immortality. Our children represent our reach into eternity. They carry our names, our values and dreams. But only if we invest our time in them, to teach them and share with them. Did you make time for family?
Third question: Nasata B'emunah? Do you do business with integrity?
This is the most surprising of the questions. We expect questions about Torah and family. We might also expect a question about charity, about ritual, about supporting the community. Where is immortality found? In the world of business. Because in my study, in my den, over my breakfast table, in my deepest thoughts, I’m a moral hero. It's easy to be a moral hero -- a Tzadik -- in theory. Deep in our hearts, everyone thinks they’re a good, well-meaning person. The question is what happens in the real world: in the marketplace, in business, in a world of tough competition, of conflict and its passions. Nasaata B'emunah: are you a mensch where it counts? What does business do to us? How many human beings must earn their livelihood at the expense of their own humanity? How much of us must die in order to make a living? Nasaata B'emunah -- Are you faithful to the best in you, even under the worst of circumstances?
The last question: Tzipita L'yeshua? Do you anticipate redemption? Do you have hope?
Victor Frankel was a Viennese psychiatrist when he was taken to Auschwitz in 1941. And as he struggled to survive Nazi slavery, he carefully studied his fellow prisoners. He writes, "Woe to him who saw no more sense in his life, no aim, no purpose, and therefore no point in carrying on. He was soon lost....We had to learn that it did not really matter what we expected from life, but rather what life expected from us. We needed to stop asking about the meaning of life, and instead think of ourselves as those who were being questioned by life -- daily and hourly." Hope isn’t given or found or revealed. We choose hope. We choose to grasp and hold the possibilities of tomorrow. Tzipita L'yeshua? Do you choose to live with hope?
Immortality is not found in heaven or beyond the grave. It is in our hearts, in the way we live, in the daily tasks of life. This holiday, go to synagogue, or find a place that’s quiet, and ask yourself God’s questions. This year, may we find the eternity planted within.
Shana Tova.
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
When we arrive in heaven, the Talmudic sages wondered, what will God ask of us?
This is not really a question about heaven. It is about how we live and how we locate eternity within life. The philosopher Franz Rosensweig explained that on Yom Kippur we are offered a look at our lives through the eyes of eternity. From that perspective, what do we amount to? What's real? What's important? What matters?
God asks four questions:
Kavaata Itim Latorah? Do you set aside time for learning Torah?
Torah is not only a book, a scroll in the ark. Torah is a process. Torah is the eternal conversation among generations of Jewish thinkers and dreamers -- sharing their perceptions of life's true purpose, of God's presence, of life’s beauty. When we study Torah, we join the conversation. In nature, writes the biologist, Lewis Thomas, there is no such thing as “an ant.” It is the same with Jews. Jews come with ancestors and descendants -- a community spanning generations. What binds us together is our shared wisdom, our Torah. To learn Torah is to enter the eternal Jewish conversation. So God asks, Kavata Itim L'Torah, did you find time for Torah?
Second question: Asakta B'priya U'reviah? Do you devote yourself to family?
God is shrewd. God doesn't ask: Did you learn Torah? God asks: Did you establish a time for study? Do you have control over your time, over your life? And if you don't, who does? Where does your time go?
God doesn't ask, Did you love your family? Did you provide for your children? God asks: Asakta, from the Hebrew esek, business: Is family your preoccupation? Do you invest yourself in family? In family there is immortality. Our children represent our reach into eternity. They carry our names, our values and dreams. But only if we invest our time in them, to teach them and share with them. Did you make time for family?
Third question: Nasata B'emunah? Do you do business with integrity?
This is the most surprising of the questions. We expect questions about Torah and family. We might also expect a question about charity, about ritual, about supporting the community. Where is immortality found? In the world of business. Because in my study, in my den, over my breakfast table, in my deepest thoughts, I’m a moral hero. It's easy to be a moral hero -- a Tzadik -- in theory. Deep in our hearts, everyone thinks they’re a good, well-meaning person. The question is what happens in the real world: in the marketplace, in business, in a world of tough competition, of conflict and its passions. Nasaata B'emunah: are you a mensch where it counts? What does business do to us? How many human beings must earn their livelihood at the expense of their own humanity? How much of us must die in order to make a living? Nasaata B'emunah -- Are you faithful to the best in you, even under the worst of circumstances?
The last question: Tzipita L'yeshua? Do you anticipate redemption? Do you have hope?
Victor Frankel was a Viennese psychiatrist when he was taken to Auschwitz in 1941. And as he struggled to survive Nazi slavery, he carefully studied his fellow prisoners. He writes, "Woe to him who saw no more sense in his life, no aim, no purpose, and therefore no point in carrying on. He was soon lost....We had to learn that it did not really matter what we expected from life, but rather what life expected from us. We needed to stop asking about the meaning of life, and instead think of ourselves as those who were being questioned by life -- daily and hourly." Hope isn’t given or found or revealed. We choose hope. We choose to grasp and hold the possibilities of tomorrow. Tzipita L'yeshua? Do you choose to live with hope?
Immortality is not found in heaven or beyond the grave. It is in our hearts, in the way we live, in the daily tasks of life. This holiday, go to synagogue, or find a place that’s quiet, and ask yourself God’s questions. This year, may we find the eternity planted within.
Shana Tova.
Friday, September 3, 2010
Shabbat Shalom September 3-4, 2010
NETZAVIM, 1998
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
When the Hasidic master, Reb Yitzchak Yakov, the Seer of Lublin, died, his disciples divided his worldly goods. One got his books and his notes, another his "shtender" his study lectern, one his kiddish cup, another his tallis and tfilin. When it was all distributed, there remained one humble hasid who had not asked for anything. To him was given the Rebbe's clock.
On his way home, the hasid stopped at an inn. But when he discovered that he had no money to pay the innkeeper, he offered the Rebbe's clock as payment. And so it was that the innkeeper took the clock and installed it in one of the rooms.
A year later, another one of the Rebbe's hasidim passed by, and stayed the night at the same inn. All night, he could not sleep. All night, the innkeeper heard the footsteps of the restless hasid pacing back and forth in his room.
In the morning, the concerned innkeeper confronted the hasid, Master, why did you not sleep last night?
Where did you get the clock? asked the hasid. And the innkeeper related the story.
I knew it, responded the hasid. This clock belonged to the Seer. It is a holy clock. All other clocks in the world mark time from the past -- from where we've come. This clock, ticks toward the future -- toward redemption. And every time I lay down to rest, the clock reminded me how much more there is to do before the future can come, before redemption can be realized.
It's all in how we read the clock. We are the heirs and bearers of a rich, powerful and magnificent tradition. We come from a long and remarkable past. And with all we have experienced, there is a powerful temptation to look backward. To count backward. To calculate how far we have wandered from our past.
There is a difference between love of tradition and an obsessive habit of looking backward. There is a difference between reverence for the past and enslavement to the past. But this difference can become obscure because in looking backward there is certainty and security. Forward there is only apprehension and wonder. Forward, there is fear. And it is this dreadful fear of the present that grips so many.
It grips the child afraid to begin a new year of school. It shackles the young fellow afraid to commit to marriage and family. It holds the middle ager afraid to admit that he's not 20 any more. It paralyzes the community obsessed with the way thing used to be. It cripples the spirituality that measures our contemporary struggle for faith and wisdom against a mythical ancestry of giants and geniuses. It blinds us to all the possibilities and promises of today and tomorrow.
"Atem netzavim hayom You stand today, all of you before the Lord your God ... to enter into the covenant of the Lord your God, which the Lord your God is concluding with you today, with its sanctions, so that He may establish you today as His people." (Deuteronomy 29:9-12) This triple reiteration of the word "today" in the opening verses of this week's Torah reading leaps off the page, embracing us in the present. Today, we are invited to the Covenant. Today, we are invited to share God's dreams for the world. The choice we make today is the one that counts. Today -- with all its wonderous and fearful potential.
A Hasidic master asked his disciples, what is the most significant moment in all Jewish history. In all the experience of the Jewish people, what moment stands out as paramount? And the students answered: The crossing of the Red Sea, the giving of Torah on Sinai, the conquest of Jerusalem. No, taught the master, the most important moment in all Jewish history is right now. We. Here. Now. That's the only reality. Shana Tova.
Rabbi Ed Feinstein
When the Hasidic master, Reb Yitzchak Yakov, the Seer of Lublin, died, his disciples divided his worldly goods. One got his books and his notes, another his "shtender" his study lectern, one his kiddish cup, another his tallis and tfilin. When it was all distributed, there remained one humble hasid who had not asked for anything. To him was given the Rebbe's clock.
On his way home, the hasid stopped at an inn. But when he discovered that he had no money to pay the innkeeper, he offered the Rebbe's clock as payment. And so it was that the innkeeper took the clock and installed it in one of the rooms.
A year later, another one of the Rebbe's hasidim passed by, and stayed the night at the same inn. All night, he could not sleep. All night, the innkeeper heard the footsteps of the restless hasid pacing back and forth in his room.
In the morning, the concerned innkeeper confronted the hasid, Master, why did you not sleep last night?
Where did you get the clock? asked the hasid. And the innkeeper related the story.
I knew it, responded the hasid. This clock belonged to the Seer. It is a holy clock. All other clocks in the world mark time from the past -- from where we've come. This clock, ticks toward the future -- toward redemption. And every time I lay down to rest, the clock reminded me how much more there is to do before the future can come, before redemption can be realized.
It's all in how we read the clock. We are the heirs and bearers of a rich, powerful and magnificent tradition. We come from a long and remarkable past. And with all we have experienced, there is a powerful temptation to look backward. To count backward. To calculate how far we have wandered from our past.
There is a difference between love of tradition and an obsessive habit of looking backward. There is a difference between reverence for the past and enslavement to the past. But this difference can become obscure because in looking backward there is certainty and security. Forward there is only apprehension and wonder. Forward, there is fear. And it is this dreadful fear of the present that grips so many.
It grips the child afraid to begin a new year of school. It shackles the young fellow afraid to commit to marriage and family. It holds the middle ager afraid to admit that he's not 20 any more. It paralyzes the community obsessed with the way thing used to be. It cripples the spirituality that measures our contemporary struggle for faith and wisdom against a mythical ancestry of giants and geniuses. It blinds us to all the possibilities and promises of today and tomorrow.
"Atem netzavim hayom You stand today, all of you before the Lord your God ... to enter into the covenant of the Lord your God, which the Lord your God is concluding with you today, with its sanctions, so that He may establish you today as His people." (Deuteronomy 29:9-12) This triple reiteration of the word "today" in the opening verses of this week's Torah reading leaps off the page, embracing us in the present. Today, we are invited to the Covenant. Today, we are invited to share God's dreams for the world. The choice we make today is the one that counts. Today -- with all its wonderous and fearful potential.
A Hasidic master asked his disciples, what is the most significant moment in all Jewish history. In all the experience of the Jewish people, what moment stands out as paramount? And the students answered: The crossing of the Red Sea, the giving of Torah on Sinai, the conquest of Jerusalem. No, taught the master, the most important moment in all Jewish history is right now. We. Here. Now. That's the only reality. Shana Tova.
Monday, August 30, 2010
Shabbat Shalom August 27-28, 2010
Share! Share! Share!
Parshat Ki Tavo – Rabbi Joshua Hoffman
As parents, we try to learn from the vast wisdom of others and to teach our children to behave with care and compassion. A recent example in our family has been the effort to help our two year old daughter learn the word ‘share.’ Fearing that her developing maturity would prompt long, scream-filled battles with her older siblings while claiming, “Mine!” we thought “Share” would be the best response. Much to our surprise, she took to the word beautifully, but now uses “Share” every time she really wants to say, “Mine!”
“Share! Share! Share!” Has a whole new ring to it in our house these days.
Learning to share is the great challenge of two year olds and sometimes even carries forward into adulthood. To share with others is a blessing. That is why this week’s Torah portion offers generous reminders to share our blessings wherever we find them. We are taught, “You shall enjoy, together with the Levite and the stranger in your midst, all the bounty that the LORD your God has bestowed upon you and your household.” (26:11)
Read in conclusion to the moving ritual of bringing first fruits to the Temple, two distinct features of this mitzvah emerge. First is the commandment to simply enjoy the fruit. Bringing offerings to God is not a matter of self-deprivation. We are blessed in our lives, often with more than we need and deserve. Our command is to enjoy these blessings as they are given to us. Don’t minimize this. Enjoy your blessings – God knows they are precious.
Second, and perhaps more important is that we must enjoy the fruits with the priest and the stranger. Sharing with the priest offers us an opportunity to enjoy our blessings in community. The priest is a conduit and mirror for God’s presence in our lives. The priest symbolizes the communal vision of sharing our bounty with God. The priest is familiar – he’s mishpacha.
The greater challenge is in sharing with the stranger. You can feel the tension between “Share!” and “Mine!” throbbing. Which stranger? What for? Who invited them? We’re reminded that the stranger is also the mirror and conduit for God’s blessings. Traditional commentators point out that our gesture to the stranger is the compassionate response to being strangers in Egypt. Today, sharing our bounty with strangers can mean anyone from the newcomer to our synagogue community, to the needy on the streets outside our homes, even strangers in the land of Israel. Enjoying your blessings with the stranger is enjoying your blessings with God as well.
Admittedly, our daughter understands sharing pretty well, even if it takes a few times to correct her definition from time to time. Our Torah guides us well, reminding us that even we can use a correction of definitions when we find more blessings than we deserve in our midst.
Parshat Ki Tavo – Rabbi Joshua Hoffman
As parents, we try to learn from the vast wisdom of others and to teach our children to behave with care and compassion. A recent example in our family has been the effort to help our two year old daughter learn the word ‘share.’ Fearing that her developing maturity would prompt long, scream-filled battles with her older siblings while claiming, “Mine!” we thought “Share” would be the best response. Much to our surprise, she took to the word beautifully, but now uses “Share” every time she really wants to say, “Mine!”
“Share! Share! Share!” Has a whole new ring to it in our house these days.
Learning to share is the great challenge of two year olds and sometimes even carries forward into adulthood. To share with others is a blessing. That is why this week’s Torah portion offers generous reminders to share our blessings wherever we find them. We are taught, “You shall enjoy, together with the Levite and the stranger in your midst, all the bounty that the LORD your God has bestowed upon you and your household.” (26:11)
Read in conclusion to the moving ritual of bringing first fruits to the Temple, two distinct features of this mitzvah emerge. First is the commandment to simply enjoy the fruit. Bringing offerings to God is not a matter of self-deprivation. We are blessed in our lives, often with more than we need and deserve. Our command is to enjoy these blessings as they are given to us. Don’t minimize this. Enjoy your blessings – God knows they are precious.
Second, and perhaps more important is that we must enjoy the fruits with the priest and the stranger. Sharing with the priest offers us an opportunity to enjoy our blessings in community. The priest is a conduit and mirror for God’s presence in our lives. The priest symbolizes the communal vision of sharing our bounty with God. The priest is familiar – he’s mishpacha.
The greater challenge is in sharing with the stranger. You can feel the tension between “Share!” and “Mine!” throbbing. Which stranger? What for? Who invited them? We’re reminded that the stranger is also the mirror and conduit for God’s blessings. Traditional commentators point out that our gesture to the stranger is the compassionate response to being strangers in Egypt. Today, sharing our bounty with strangers can mean anyone from the newcomer to our synagogue community, to the needy on the streets outside our homes, even strangers in the land of Israel. Enjoying your blessings with the stranger is enjoying your blessings with God as well.
Admittedly, our daughter understands sharing pretty well, even if it takes a few times to correct her definition from time to time. Our Torah guides us well, reminding us that even we can use a correction of definitions when we find more blessings than we deserve in our midst.
Friday, August 20, 2010
Shabbat Shalom August 20-21, 2010
KI TEZTZE, 1997
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
A professor in Seminary once asked us to find the most important section in all the Torah. We offered Creation, the Shma, the Exodus, the revelation at Mt Sinai. No, he argued, it's Ki Tetze L'milchama, Deuteronomy 21: "When you go out to war against your enemies, and the LORD God delivers them into your power and you take some of them captive, and you see among the captives a beautiful woman, and you desire her, and would have her. You shall first bring her into your house and she shall cut her hair and her nails, and discard her captive's garb. She shall spend a month's time in your house mourning her father and mother...and then you may come to her, and marry her, and she shall be your wife. And if not, you must release her."
Why would anyone think this the most important section of the Torah?
In my den, over my breakfast table, in my deepest thoughts, I can be a moral hero. It's easy to be a Tzadik in theory. Deep in the heart, everyone thinks of himself as a good person. But to moralize in the abstract is the height of superficiality. Morality is what happens in the real world, in the marketplace, in the world of conflict and competition. And the challenge of morality is not to recite pithy rules, but to look deeply at the darker parts of our own souls; to examine and know the drives and desires that distract our moral vision; to appreciate our infinite capacity to rationalize, compromise and excuse our own moral failures.
What is real morality? The Torah offers us a study of the moral worst case scenario: The most amoral of settings. The most unrestrained of moral actors. The most vulnerable of victims. He sees her on the field of battle, and desires her with all the lusts and passions of battle. With rape, looting and wanton acts of violence all around him, no one would know, no one would care. After all what is she? A captive, an enemy, the spoils of battle. He wants her. And just at that moment, in that most unrestrained and amoral of all circumstances, amid the smoke and screams and confusion of war, the Torah says, Stop. She is not an object. She is a human being. And you must uphold her humanity and protect her dignity. All is not fair in love and war!
The genius of the Torah's ethic, argued my professor, is found in this unique combination of realism and idealism. The Torah does not reproach him for his drives. It does not condemn his desire. Desire is natural; it is not evil. But neither will Torah allow its untamed, savage explosion. "Who is a hero?" asks Pirke Avot, "one who conquers his yetzer, his drives." One does not uproot the yetzer. It is part of us. But neither is it given raw expression.
Torah permits the expression of drives and desire only in the proper relationship of human dignity. So this ingenious rite is followed allowing the captive woman to mourn and heal, while allowing our soldier's ardor to cool and his judgement to return. She is actually made ugly her head shaved, her nails pared -- and she lives untouched in his household for 30 days. If after that, he still wants her, he may marry her and afford her all the protection of his household...otherwise, she goes free. He may not sell her as a slave, the normal fate of captives.
On all the battlefields we find ourselves in corporate offices, community politics, in the marketplace, in personal conflicts when passions are high and indiscretions overlooked, when anything goes, the Torah demands reverence for the humanity and dignity of the other. What's at stake, after all, is not just the other, but your humanity as well. Ki Tzetze L'milchama, when you go out to war, don't win the battle and lose your soul.
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
A professor in Seminary once asked us to find the most important section in all the Torah. We offered Creation, the Shma, the Exodus, the revelation at Mt Sinai. No, he argued, it's Ki Tetze L'milchama, Deuteronomy 21: "When you go out to war against your enemies, and the LORD God delivers them into your power and you take some of them captive, and you see among the captives a beautiful woman, and you desire her, and would have her. You shall first bring her into your house and she shall cut her hair and her nails, and discard her captive's garb. She shall spend a month's time in your house mourning her father and mother...and then you may come to her, and marry her, and she shall be your wife. And if not, you must release her."
Why would anyone think this the most important section of the Torah?
In my den, over my breakfast table, in my deepest thoughts, I can be a moral hero. It's easy to be a Tzadik in theory. Deep in the heart, everyone thinks of himself as a good person. But to moralize in the abstract is the height of superficiality. Morality is what happens in the real world, in the marketplace, in the world of conflict and competition. And the challenge of morality is not to recite pithy rules, but to look deeply at the darker parts of our own souls; to examine and know the drives and desires that distract our moral vision; to appreciate our infinite capacity to rationalize, compromise and excuse our own moral failures.
What is real morality? The Torah offers us a study of the moral worst case scenario: The most amoral of settings. The most unrestrained of moral actors. The most vulnerable of victims. He sees her on the field of battle, and desires her with all the lusts and passions of battle. With rape, looting and wanton acts of violence all around him, no one would know, no one would care. After all what is she? A captive, an enemy, the spoils of battle. He wants her. And just at that moment, in that most unrestrained and amoral of all circumstances, amid the smoke and screams and confusion of war, the Torah says, Stop. She is not an object. She is a human being. And you must uphold her humanity and protect her dignity. All is not fair in love and war!
The genius of the Torah's ethic, argued my professor, is found in this unique combination of realism and idealism. The Torah does not reproach him for his drives. It does not condemn his desire. Desire is natural; it is not evil. But neither will Torah allow its untamed, savage explosion. "Who is a hero?" asks Pirke Avot, "one who conquers his yetzer, his drives." One does not uproot the yetzer. It is part of us. But neither is it given raw expression.
Torah permits the expression of drives and desire only in the proper relationship of human dignity. So this ingenious rite is followed allowing the captive woman to mourn and heal, while allowing our soldier's ardor to cool and his judgement to return. She is actually made ugly her head shaved, her nails pared -- and she lives untouched in his household for 30 days. If after that, he still wants her, he may marry her and afford her all the protection of his household...otherwise, she goes free. He may not sell her as a slave, the normal fate of captives.
On all the battlefields we find ourselves in corporate offices, community politics, in the marketplace, in personal conflicts when passions are high and indiscretions overlooked, when anything goes, the Torah demands reverence for the humanity and dignity of the other. What's at stake, after all, is not just the other, but your humanity as well. Ki Tzetze L'milchama, when you go out to war, don't win the battle and lose your soul.
Tuesday, August 10, 2010
Rosh Hodesh Elul
Hodesh Tov - May the new month of Elul bring goodness for you and your family!
Our preparations for the New Year, physically and spiritually, begin today and we offer you some insights and a resource as turn your attention toward self-reflection and growth.
You may have heard the parable shared by the great writer S.Y. Agnon. He tells a tale of a man wandering in a forest for several days utterly lost. Another man approaches and their hearts are filled with joy in their discovery. "Now I will certainly find the right way," the first man thought to himself. He then asked, "Brother, I have been wandering about in this forest for days. Can you tell me which is the right way out?" "My brother," the other replied, "I do not know the right way out either. But, this I can tell you; do not go the way that I went, for it will surely lead you astray. Come let us look for the way together."
Come let us journey together toward the High Holy Days. Our way begins by taking a few moments each day to focus our thoughts to moments of personal awe and communal joy. To guide us and inspire us along the way, we are grateful for Craig Taubman's Jewel's of Elul to offer daily insight and opportunities for discussion. Please take a moment and sign up for the daily postings.
www.jewelsofelul.com
Our preparations for the New Year, physically and spiritually, begin today and we offer you some insights and a resource as turn your attention toward self-reflection and growth.
You may have heard the parable shared by the great writer S.Y. Agnon. He tells a tale of a man wandering in a forest for several days utterly lost. Another man approaches and their hearts are filled with joy in their discovery. "Now I will certainly find the right way," the first man thought to himself. He then asked, "Brother, I have been wandering about in this forest for days. Can you tell me which is the right way out?" "My brother," the other replied, "I do not know the right way out either. But, this I can tell you; do not go the way that I went, for it will surely lead you astray. Come let us look for the way together."
Come let us journey together toward the High Holy Days. Our way begins by taking a few moments each day to focus our thoughts to moments of personal awe and communal joy. To guide us and inspire us along the way, we are grateful for Craig Taubman's Jewel's of Elul to offer daily insight and opportunities for discussion. Please take a moment and sign up for the daily postings.
www.jewelsofelul.com
Friday, August 6, 2010
Shabbat Shalom August 6-7, 2010
REEH
Deuteronomy 11:26 - 16:17
FOR A FLAME-BROILED WORLD
by Rabbi Edward Feinstein
"Why does your God object to cheeseburgers?" a friend asked over lunch one day, "Why does He care?" A very good question. Why does a tradition so concerned with ultimate issues concern itself so earnestly with, of all things, cheeseburgers? First, please understand that it has nothing to do with health. The laws of Kashrut -- the food restrictions imposed upon Jews by the Bible and the Talmud -- were not intended to keep us healthy. Trust me, you can eat very Kosher but very unhealthy. Kashrut is a symbol system. The question is not: What does it do for me? but rather: What does it say to me?
"You are what you eat," observed the philosopher Feuerbach. The way we confront nature and make a living in the world determines our values. And eating is the most direct way we confront nature. Because the way we eat speaks for the values we hold, Judaism impresses its most fundamental values into the daily act of preparing and eating food. All of Kashrut says: Choose Life.
The Bible envisioned man and woman in the Garden of Eden as vegetarians. The perfect world -- without conflict, violence, fear -- is a world of vegetarianism. It is a world of oneness with nature. When we hunger for animal products, especially meat, we break the oneness. At that point, the laws of Kashrut apply.
Kashrut is a compromise. Choosing to eat meat puts us at the end of a process of killing -- making us the end cause, the reason, for the entire process, and therefore, morally responsible. No matter how careful and clean, this is a matter of aggression and violence. We often forget this when meat appears in the supermarket, all sanitized and freezer-wrapped: This was once a living, breathing being, whose life we have taken by force. Kashrut is a compromise between the nonviolent ideal of vegetarianism and the human craving for meat. You may eat meat. But only with certain restrictions.
There are four basic laws of eating meat: (1) Only certain animals may be eaten, so that killing is not indiscriminate. (2) The animal is killed in the most painless way. (3) All blood must be removed because blood symbolizes life, and all life belongs to God. You may eat the animal, but you must not imagine yourself to be the master of life and death. (4) Foods made from milk and foods made from meat must be prepared, served and eaten separately. Because meat symbolizes the taking of life, and milk symbolizes the giving of life, and the two must never be confused in our lives. This week's Torah portion teaches this ideal: "You are a people consecrated to the Lord your God. You shall not boil a kid in its mother's milk." (Deuteronomy 14:21)
What's wrong with a cheeseburger? It bespeaks a culture, no longer shocked by violence, that casually mixes up life and death. We are surrounded by a culture that celebrates violence as a source of vigor and vitality, and mixes violence into the fabric of daily life. Consider Arnold Schwartenegger. One of the most successful and highly paid actors in Hollywood. For what? Certainly not for his portrayal of character. Olivier he's not! But with superb panache and elegant style, Schwartenegger hurts people. He kills. And we love it. That's entertainment!
This is a culture that sells weapons as toys. Visit any toy shop. The LAPD should be as well armed my neighborhood Toys-R-Us! We give weapons to children as playthings, and then we wonder where they get the idea to bring guns to school!
What will you change by refusing a cheeseburger? Will it make a difference? Maybe not in the world at large, but certainly within you. You will be different. You will make a statement about your values and about the world you choose to live in. You will be a little more conscious, a little more sensitive, a little closer to oneness, a little more Godly. Shabbat Shalom.
* This document, or any portion thereof, may not be reproduced without the written permission of the author.
Deuteronomy 11:26 - 16:17
FOR A FLAME-BROILED WORLD
by Rabbi Edward Feinstein
"Why does your God object to cheeseburgers?" a friend asked over lunch one day, "Why does He care?" A very good question. Why does a tradition so concerned with ultimate issues concern itself so earnestly with, of all things, cheeseburgers? First, please understand that it has nothing to do with health. The laws of Kashrut -- the food restrictions imposed upon Jews by the Bible and the Talmud -- were not intended to keep us healthy. Trust me, you can eat very Kosher but very unhealthy. Kashrut is a symbol system. The question is not: What does it do for me? but rather: What does it say to me?
"You are what you eat," observed the philosopher Feuerbach. The way we confront nature and make a living in the world determines our values. And eating is the most direct way we confront nature. Because the way we eat speaks for the values we hold, Judaism impresses its most fundamental values into the daily act of preparing and eating food. All of Kashrut says: Choose Life.
The Bible envisioned man and woman in the Garden of Eden as vegetarians. The perfect world -- without conflict, violence, fear -- is a world of vegetarianism. It is a world of oneness with nature. When we hunger for animal products, especially meat, we break the oneness. At that point, the laws of Kashrut apply.
Kashrut is a compromise. Choosing to eat meat puts us at the end of a process of killing -- making us the end cause, the reason, for the entire process, and therefore, morally responsible. No matter how careful and clean, this is a matter of aggression and violence. We often forget this when meat appears in the supermarket, all sanitized and freezer-wrapped: This was once a living, breathing being, whose life we have taken by force. Kashrut is a compromise between the nonviolent ideal of vegetarianism and the human craving for meat. You may eat meat. But only with certain restrictions.
There are four basic laws of eating meat: (1) Only certain animals may be eaten, so that killing is not indiscriminate. (2) The animal is killed in the most painless way. (3) All blood must be removed because blood symbolizes life, and all life belongs to God. You may eat the animal, but you must not imagine yourself to be the master of life and death. (4) Foods made from milk and foods made from meat must be prepared, served and eaten separately. Because meat symbolizes the taking of life, and milk symbolizes the giving of life, and the two must never be confused in our lives. This week's Torah portion teaches this ideal: "You are a people consecrated to the Lord your God. You shall not boil a kid in its mother's milk." (Deuteronomy 14:21)
What's wrong with a cheeseburger? It bespeaks a culture, no longer shocked by violence, that casually mixes up life and death. We are surrounded by a culture that celebrates violence as a source of vigor and vitality, and mixes violence into the fabric of daily life. Consider Arnold Schwartenegger. One of the most successful and highly paid actors in Hollywood. For what? Certainly not for his portrayal of character. Olivier he's not! But with superb panache and elegant style, Schwartenegger hurts people. He kills. And we love it. That's entertainment!
This is a culture that sells weapons as toys. Visit any toy shop. The LAPD should be as well armed my neighborhood Toys-R-Us! We give weapons to children as playthings, and then we wonder where they get the idea to bring guns to school!
What will you change by refusing a cheeseburger? Will it make a difference? Maybe not in the world at large, but certainly within you. You will be different. You will make a statement about your values and about the world you choose to live in. You will be a little more conscious, a little more sensitive, a little closer to oneness, a little more Godly. Shabbat Shalom.
* This document, or any portion thereof, may not be reproduced without the written permission of the author.
Thursday, July 29, 2010
Shabbat Shalom July 30-31, 2010
EKEV, 1999
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Write a letter. Address it to those you love -- your spouse, your children and grandchild, your friends, your community. Put into this letter what life has taught you: What you learned from childhood, from growing up, from your education. What you learned from marriage and raising children? What have you learned from work, from your triumphs and successes in the world, from your failures and disappointments? What you have learned from the death of loved ones, and the path of mourning and grief. What has life taught you? What is the meaning, the lesson, the wisdom of your life? What is your message?
I ask you to do this for three principal reasons:
First, do it for yourself. You deserve to know what your life has meant, what it has taught. There are 5,485 verses in a Torah scroll; tens of thousands of words, more than a hundred thousand handwritten letters. According to tradition, if any one letter, in any word in any verse, is defaced or erased, the entire Torah is pasul, invalid, and may not be read. A Torah missing even the tiniest yud is set aside. Why such an obsession? A hasidic tradition teaches that each letter stands for one human soul. Each individual human being carries one letter, one byte, of God’s message into the world. Just as the loss of the tiniest letter invalidates an entire Torah scroll, losing one human being makes God’s message indecipherable. You carry part of the message. But do you know what it is? Have you discovered, decoded your part of the message? Have you delivered it?
Second, write the letter for your loved ones. As a rabbi, I frequently accompany families as they grieve. I ask them to share the stories and wisdom of their loved ones’ lives. And I’m often surprised how little they know. They can recount with precision the history of declining health, but they have no notion of the soul -- the inner life, the moral struggles, the deepest values. God forbid anything should happen to you. But shouldn’t your loved ones know what you’ve learned from life -- what secrets you’ve wrestled out of the experiences of living, what wisdom you’ve found?
Third, write the letter for your spiritual life. Our tradition begins with the commandment to Abraham, lech lecha, Go into yourself. Hearing the voice of God begins with hearing your own soul. There are many who believe that spiritual wisdom is far away -- on some mountaintop to be wrested from a master of mystery. But Torah, real spiritual truth, we are taught, is not beyond your reach. It is not in the heavens...neither is it beyond the sea...It is very close to you, in your mouth and in your heart... (Deuteronomy 30:11-14)
Write the letter. But know that it isn’t easy. For so many, the heart is more inaccessible than the heavens, more forbidding than the sea. Denial, avoidance, even distraction, keep us from listening.
Modernity has brought us many gifts. But one of the casualties of modern life is contemplation. Our ancestors lived in a much slower world. They walked to and from work. They had time to think, to meditate, to pray. At evening, their homes were not filled with television, internet, CD’s VCR’s., DVD’s or AOL. Instead, they read to one another, made their own music, and told stories. In the world before computers, air travel, and running water, they had time to discover the meaning and lessons of existence. With all our leisure and freedom, we must discipline ourselves to make time for contemplation. Otherwise we live from day to day, from appointment to project to vacation and back again to work, without ever stopping to wonder why. It takes a conscientious effort of the will to make the time, to find the quiet, the turn inward and to listen to what life has come to teach us. If only you would listen, begs the Torah in this week’s portion, then all of God’s blessings would find you. Shabbat Shalom.
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Write a letter. Address it to those you love -- your spouse, your children and grandchild, your friends, your community. Put into this letter what life has taught you: What you learned from childhood, from growing up, from your education. What you learned from marriage and raising children? What have you learned from work, from your triumphs and successes in the world, from your failures and disappointments? What you have learned from the death of loved ones, and the path of mourning and grief. What has life taught you? What is the meaning, the lesson, the wisdom of your life? What is your message?
I ask you to do this for three principal reasons:
First, do it for yourself. You deserve to know what your life has meant, what it has taught. There are 5,485 verses in a Torah scroll; tens of thousands of words, more than a hundred thousand handwritten letters. According to tradition, if any one letter, in any word in any verse, is defaced or erased, the entire Torah is pasul, invalid, and may not be read. A Torah missing even the tiniest yud is set aside. Why such an obsession? A hasidic tradition teaches that each letter stands for one human soul. Each individual human being carries one letter, one byte, of God’s message into the world. Just as the loss of the tiniest letter invalidates an entire Torah scroll, losing one human being makes God’s message indecipherable. You carry part of the message. But do you know what it is? Have you discovered, decoded your part of the message? Have you delivered it?
Second, write the letter for your loved ones. As a rabbi, I frequently accompany families as they grieve. I ask them to share the stories and wisdom of their loved ones’ lives. And I’m often surprised how little they know. They can recount with precision the history of declining health, but they have no notion of the soul -- the inner life, the moral struggles, the deepest values. God forbid anything should happen to you. But shouldn’t your loved ones know what you’ve learned from life -- what secrets you’ve wrestled out of the experiences of living, what wisdom you’ve found?
Third, write the letter for your spiritual life. Our tradition begins with the commandment to Abraham, lech lecha, Go into yourself. Hearing the voice of God begins with hearing your own soul. There are many who believe that spiritual wisdom is far away -- on some mountaintop to be wrested from a master of mystery. But Torah, real spiritual truth, we are taught, is not beyond your reach. It is not in the heavens...neither is it beyond the sea...It is very close to you, in your mouth and in your heart... (Deuteronomy 30:11-14)
Write the letter. But know that it isn’t easy. For so many, the heart is more inaccessible than the heavens, more forbidding than the sea. Denial, avoidance, even distraction, keep us from listening.
Modernity has brought us many gifts. But one of the casualties of modern life is contemplation. Our ancestors lived in a much slower world. They walked to and from work. They had time to think, to meditate, to pray. At evening, their homes were not filled with television, internet, CD’s VCR’s., DVD’s or AOL. Instead, they read to one another, made their own music, and told stories. In the world before computers, air travel, and running water, they had time to discover the meaning and lessons of existence. With all our leisure and freedom, we must discipline ourselves to make time for contemplation. Otherwise we live from day to day, from appointment to project to vacation and back again to work, without ever stopping to wonder why. It takes a conscientious effort of the will to make the time, to find the quiet, the turn inward and to listen to what life has come to teach us. If only you would listen, begs the Torah in this week’s portion, then all of God’s blessings would find you. Shabbat Shalom.
Friday, July 23, 2010
Shabbat Shalom July 23-24, 2010
VAETCHANAN, 2005
Who Loves You?
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Their daughter, a bright and otherwise articulate second-grader, was having night terrors. Well after midnight she’d awaken screaming hysterically something about death. So her parents brought her to see me, the rabbi.
“I know kids, but I’m not a therapist,” I complained.
“But she trusts you,” they responded.
So I agreed to speak to the child and see what I could do.
“Sounds like you’re really scared at night,” I began.
“Yeah,” she agreed, playing with the knickknacks on my desk.
“Did something happen that made you so scared?” I inquired.
“No, nothing really,” she put me off. Then after a pause, “Well, my dog died.”
I jumped on this, “That’s terrible! Your poor dog died. You must be really sad about that.”
“No,” she parried, “he was really old and really sick and really smelly, and I didn’t like him very much.” And then, “But when he died, I started thinking about my grandma who died.”
Having been put off once, I proceeded more carefully, “And what was that like?”
“Well, I was only three, so I don’t really remember her very well. But I started thinking that if grandma could die, and grandma was mommy’s mother, well, that means mommy could die. And that made me really scared.”
The knickknacks were set aside, and we were both paying attention now. She was such an open and forthright kid, I thought I’d go a bit farther. “What do you think about when you’re so scared?”
“Well, you know, if mommy died, who would take care of me?”
“That is scarrey.”
“Yeah, that’s what I think about at night and that’s why I start crying.”
Of course you’re crying. At age 7, you’ve discovered the single most terrifying element of the human condition and your world is no longer so secure and bright. Of course you’re crying. We’ve all cried those tears. But we know something else about being human. And you know it too.
“Tell me something, who loves you?”
“That’s a silly question….lots of people love me!”
“Like who?”
“Well, mommy and daddy, my grandpa, and my other grandma and grandpa – I call them Nana and Papa, my Uncle Jack – he’s really funny…”
“Wait a second,” I held her back and reached to find a piece of coloring paper and a marker. “Start writing. Make a list of all the people who love you.”
So we started the list again. “Mommy, daddy, grandpa, Nana, Papa, Uncle Jack…” Soon the list grew long including teachers, doctors, babysitters, the lady at the bakery who gave away cookies. Even the rabbi made the list.
“Here’s what I want you to do. Keep this right next to your bed. When you wake up in the middle of the night, and you start thinking those scarrey thoughts about death, read the list. Read the list of all the people who love you. Read it out loud. Let’s see what happens.”
She read the list every night before bed. And sometimes in the middle of the night. And the night terrors stopped.
This week’s Torah portion gives us the central affirmation of Jewish prayer – Shema Yisrael. Before saying Shema Yisrael in the morning, tradition requires that we gather together the tzitziot, the fringes of the tallit. We wrap them around the fingers and hold them close as we affirm our faith. There are several authoritative interpretations of this custom. But now I have my own, taught to me by this insightful young woman. As we gather the fringes, we gather all those who love us and all those we love into our hands. We gather them into one, as we say the word Ehad -- to affirm the oneness that give us the courage to face all the terrors of being human and continue to live with hope and with faith. The custom is, as well, to elongate the word Ehad – hold the syllable, Ehaaaaaad – long enough to include them all, all those we love, and all whose love touches us. To feel their collective love is to feel the presence of the One who loves us.
Who Loves You?
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
Their daughter, a bright and otherwise articulate second-grader, was having night terrors. Well after midnight she’d awaken screaming hysterically something about death. So her parents brought her to see me, the rabbi.
“I know kids, but I’m not a therapist,” I complained.
“But she trusts you,” they responded.
So I agreed to speak to the child and see what I could do.
“Sounds like you’re really scared at night,” I began.
“Yeah,” she agreed, playing with the knickknacks on my desk.
“Did something happen that made you so scared?” I inquired.
“No, nothing really,” she put me off. Then after a pause, “Well, my dog died.”
I jumped on this, “That’s terrible! Your poor dog died. You must be really sad about that.”
“No,” she parried, “he was really old and really sick and really smelly, and I didn’t like him very much.” And then, “But when he died, I started thinking about my grandma who died.”
Having been put off once, I proceeded more carefully, “And what was that like?”
“Well, I was only three, so I don’t really remember her very well. But I started thinking that if grandma could die, and grandma was mommy’s mother, well, that means mommy could die. And that made me really scared.”
The knickknacks were set aside, and we were both paying attention now. She was such an open and forthright kid, I thought I’d go a bit farther. “What do you think about when you’re so scared?”
“Well, you know, if mommy died, who would take care of me?”
“That is scarrey.”
“Yeah, that’s what I think about at night and that’s why I start crying.”
Of course you’re crying. At age 7, you’ve discovered the single most terrifying element of the human condition and your world is no longer so secure and bright. Of course you’re crying. We’ve all cried those tears. But we know something else about being human. And you know it too.
“Tell me something, who loves you?”
“That’s a silly question….lots of people love me!”
“Like who?”
“Well, mommy and daddy, my grandpa, and my other grandma and grandpa – I call them Nana and Papa, my Uncle Jack – he’s really funny…”
“Wait a second,” I held her back and reached to find a piece of coloring paper and a marker. “Start writing. Make a list of all the people who love you.”
So we started the list again. “Mommy, daddy, grandpa, Nana, Papa, Uncle Jack…” Soon the list grew long including teachers, doctors, babysitters, the lady at the bakery who gave away cookies. Even the rabbi made the list.
“Here’s what I want you to do. Keep this right next to your bed. When you wake up in the middle of the night, and you start thinking those scarrey thoughts about death, read the list. Read the list of all the people who love you. Read it out loud. Let’s see what happens.”
She read the list every night before bed. And sometimes in the middle of the night. And the night terrors stopped.
This week’s Torah portion gives us the central affirmation of Jewish prayer – Shema Yisrael. Before saying Shema Yisrael in the morning, tradition requires that we gather together the tzitziot, the fringes of the tallit. We wrap them around the fingers and hold them close as we affirm our faith. There are several authoritative interpretations of this custom. But now I have my own, taught to me by this insightful young woman. As we gather the fringes, we gather all those who love us and all those we love into our hands. We gather them into one, as we say the word Ehad -- to affirm the oneness that give us the courage to face all the terrors of being human and continue to live with hope and with faith. The custom is, as well, to elongate the word Ehad – hold the syllable, Ehaaaaaad – long enough to include them all, all those we love, and all whose love touches us. To feel their collective love is to feel the presence of the One who loves us.
Thursday, July 15, 2010
Shabbat Shalom July 16-17, 2010
DEVARIM, 1997
The Last Taboo
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
I love answering kids' questions. I'll visit a classroom and face an eager chorus of "Did God create dinosaurs?" "Where do people go when they die?" Then at the end, there's always one wise guy, who smirks and asks, "What's the meaning of life?" I love that kid. I admire his chutzpah, and I love the question.
This may be the last taboo. In our culture, people are encouraged to reveal every intimate detail of their lives, every personal secret. In public meetings, at social gatherings, and if that weren't enough, on national television, people shamelessly share every foible and fantasy, every nuance of sexual adventure and interpersonal sin, every addiction and fixation. We'll listen with rapt intent as strangers recounts their bouts with drugs and drink, his infidelities, broken relationships with parents, spouse and children, the bizarre and the spectacular lengths they've gone to obtain thrills. That's permitted. It's even celebrated. But ask "What's the meaning of your life?" and the conversation stops dead.
Try dropping my young friend's question at a cocktail reception or summer barbecue. "So, what's the meaning of your life?" People will laugh. They think you're joking. Isn't that strange? Don't we all, at some point, need to ask this question with seriousness and reflection? Why the laughter?
A homework assignment: On you way home, stop at a drug store and pick up a package of 200 4X6 index cards, and a box of pencils. When you return home, and you find a quiet moment alone, write down on a card all that life has taught you. In Medieval times, Jews left their children a special will. More than instructions for dividing the property, it contained a summary of a life's wisdom. Write one for yourself. To force your concentration, keep it short, no more than an index card. What have you learned from life? From growing up, from school, marriage (and divorce), from raising kids, making a living, building a community, saying goodbye to loved ones? What has life taught you?
It might take a hundred attempts -- one hundred cards written, then tossed out -- to arrive at just the right words. When you arrive at just the right words, cherish that card. Save it, look at it and update it each Rosh Hashana. You deserve to know the meaning, the lesson, the wisdom, of your life. Each of us, according to a mystical teaching, carries one word in God's message to the world. Wouldn't you like to figure out what your word is? And if anything, God forbid, were to happen to you tomorrow, wouldn't you like your children, your grandchildren, your friends to know?
The Torah portion this week describes a miracle. Moses finds words. This man who once protested Lo ish devarim anochi "I am not a man of words devarim" (Exodus 4:10), now stands before his people with something to say. Elah ha-devaim asher deber Moshe el kol Yisrael "These are the words devarim which Moses addressed to all Israel on the other side of the Jordan." The forty year journey has not only brought Israel to the Promised Land. The forty year journey has brought Moses to words. He has discovered the message and meaning of his life's struggle. And for the entire book of Deuteronomy, the once mute prophet will articulate his words.
My young friend asks the question and he is shocked when I answer forthrightly.
When God created the world, it was left unfinished. We are God's partners, assigned to finish the work of Creation. The world that we encounter is a mixture of chaos and order, of good and evil, of darkness and light. It is our job, as God's partners, to bring order to the chaos, to bring good out of evil, to cast light into the darkness. There is a corner of the world that only you can fix. You must find that corner, and applying your energies, imagination and intelligence, bring wholeness and healing. In that direction you will find the meaning of your life.
The Last Taboo
By Rabbi Ed Feinstein
I love answering kids' questions. I'll visit a classroom and face an eager chorus of "Did God create dinosaurs?" "Where do people go when they die?" Then at the end, there's always one wise guy, who smirks and asks, "What's the meaning of life?" I love that kid. I admire his chutzpah, and I love the question.
This may be the last taboo. In our culture, people are encouraged to reveal every intimate detail of their lives, every personal secret. In public meetings, at social gatherings, and if that weren't enough, on national television, people shamelessly share every foible and fantasy, every nuance of sexual adventure and interpersonal sin, every addiction and fixation. We'll listen with rapt intent as strangers recounts their bouts with drugs and drink, his infidelities, broken relationships with parents, spouse and children, the bizarre and the spectacular lengths they've gone to obtain thrills. That's permitted. It's even celebrated. But ask "What's the meaning of your life?" and the conversation stops dead.
Try dropping my young friend's question at a cocktail reception or summer barbecue. "So, what's the meaning of your life?" People will laugh. They think you're joking. Isn't that strange? Don't we all, at some point, need to ask this question with seriousness and reflection? Why the laughter?
A homework assignment: On you way home, stop at a drug store and pick up a package of 200 4X6 index cards, and a box of pencils. When you return home, and you find a quiet moment alone, write down on a card all that life has taught you. In Medieval times, Jews left their children a special will. More than instructions for dividing the property, it contained a summary of a life's wisdom. Write one for yourself. To force your concentration, keep it short, no more than an index card. What have you learned from life? From growing up, from school, marriage (and divorce), from raising kids, making a living, building a community, saying goodbye to loved ones? What has life taught you?
It might take a hundred attempts -- one hundred cards written, then tossed out -- to arrive at just the right words. When you arrive at just the right words, cherish that card. Save it, look at it and update it each Rosh Hashana. You deserve to know the meaning, the lesson, the wisdom, of your life. Each of us, according to a mystical teaching, carries one word in God's message to the world. Wouldn't you like to figure out what your word is? And if anything, God forbid, were to happen to you tomorrow, wouldn't you like your children, your grandchildren, your friends to know?
The Torah portion this week describes a miracle. Moses finds words. This man who once protested Lo ish devarim anochi "I am not a man of words devarim" (Exodus 4:10), now stands before his people with something to say. Elah ha-devaim asher deber Moshe el kol Yisrael "These are the words devarim which Moses addressed to all Israel on the other side of the Jordan." The forty year journey has not only brought Israel to the Promised Land. The forty year journey has brought Moses to words. He has discovered the message and meaning of his life's struggle. And for the entire book of Deuteronomy, the once mute prophet will articulate his words.
My young friend asks the question and he is shocked when I answer forthrightly.
When God created the world, it was left unfinished. We are God's partners, assigned to finish the work of Creation. The world that we encounter is a mixture of chaos and order, of good and evil, of darkness and light. It is our job, as God's partners, to bring order to the chaos, to bring good out of evil, to cast light into the darkness. There is a corner of the world that only you can fix. You must find that corner, and applying your energies, imagination and intelligence, bring wholeness and healing. In that direction you will find the meaning of your life.
Thursday, July 8, 2010
Parashat Mattot-Mas'ei
Parashat Mattot-Mas'ei
Numbers 30:2–36:13
July 10, 2010 / 28 Tammuz 5770
This week's commentary was written by Dr. Alan Mintz, Chana Kekst Professor of Hebrew Literature in the Department of Jewish Literature, Jewish Theological Seminary.
The Torah is replete with lists of every kind: the generations before and after Noah, the enumeration of the tribes and their chieftains in the desert, the catalogs of forbidden foods, the inventories of priestly garments. The book of Numbers, which begins with a census, is especially true to its name. The beginning of chapter 33, which opens Parashat Mas'ei (the second of the double portions read in the synagogue this week), presents one of the grandest lists of all: the forty-two stations of Israel's wandering from Ramses in Egypt to the steppes of Moab on the eve of the entry into the Promised Land. Although we may feel that we have heard all of these place names in earlier weekly readings, the fact is that a significant number of these stations (verses 19–30) are mentioned here for the first time. The uniqueness of this list is indicated by the fact that Moses is specifically instructed to record the names in writing. In many synagogues, a special singsong melody used by the Torah reader also makes this passage unique.
Like many lists, the great wilderness itinerary of Numbers 33 marks a significant boundary. Until this point, the book of Numbers, true to its Hebrew name, Bemidbar, has rendered an exhaustive account of the events that befell Israel in its trek through the wilderness, right up to the present moment when the people stands poised to undertake the conquest of the Land. The remaining three chapters of Numbers look forward in time; they deal exclusively with matters that will become relevant after the conquest. The epic desert narrative has been concluded, and the comprehensive recapitulation of the stations of the journey marks an ending on the eve of a new beginning.
For the Rabbis of the midrash, the itinerary of Numbers 33 functions not only to draw a boundary but also to summarize the moral and spiritual meaning of the entire forty-year sojourn in the desert. Yet even though the Rabbis are joined in extracting a deeper meaning from the list of places, they are deeply divided in their essential attitudes to direction of that meaning.
On the one hand, the Rabbis explain that the "Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses: 'Write down the stages by which Israel journeyed in the wilderness, in order that they shall know what miracles I wrought for them.'" Barren of water and sustenance and rife with snakes, scorpions, and hostile marauding tribes, the desert is a place where life is possible only by virtue of God's protection and intervention. The chronicle of the forty-two stations then becomes a catalog of miracles and a record of an abundance of kindnesses. Even the number forty-two, which at first seems so large, emphasizes God's mercy. The first fourteen encampments, as Rashi points out, took place very early on, before the mission of the spies and the punishment of the forty years of wandering; and the last eight took place during the fortieth year. Thus there were only some twenty journeys during the great bulk of the sojourn; Israel was therefore not vexed by frequent forced marches. In fact, for the prophet Jeremiah, as quoted prominently in the Zikhronot liturgy in the Musaf service for Rosh Hashanah, the desert years are invoked nostalgically as a kind of prolonged honeymoon in the covenantal relations between God and Israel.
The opposite stance toward the desert years is presented by the Rabbis in a parable that likens the enumeration of the itinerary to the case of a king who has taken his son on a journey to cure him of his ills. "On their return journey his father began to recount all the stages, saying: 'Here we slept; here we cooled ourselves, here you had a headache.' So the Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses: 'Recount to them all the places where they provoked me.'" Indeed, this severe assessment needs little special pleading or elaboration because it is the principal experience that we have as readers of the Torah's stories of the desert: complaint, murmuring, disobedience, and rebellion over and over again.
An interesting attempt to make a homiletical connection between these conflicting interpretations of the list and the desert years it describes is undertaken by Samson Raphael Hirsch, the nineteenth-century German rabbi. Hirsch notes a reversed duplication in the second verse of the chapter: "Moses recorded the starting points of their various marches as directed by the Lord; their marches, by starting point, were as follows." In the beginning of the verse, the Hebrew reads motsa'eihem lemas'eihem (the starting point of their journeys), whereas the end of the verse has the same pair of terms in the opposite order, mas'eihem lemotsa'eihem. Although a critical reader might take this simply as an instance of chiasm, the abba pattern that the Torah text often delights in, Hirsch sees the reversal as fraught with meaning. The ordering in the first phrase describes how God regarded their travels. In the divine perspective, each starting point moved Israel forward in a journey that culminated in their accession to the Land and the fulfillment of God's promise. When the order is reversed, however, the travels are rendered from the point of view of the people, who also wanted to set forth on the next stage, but for different reasons. Rather than keeping their eyes on the high purpose of their journey, they were motivated to move on by boredom and dissatisfaction with their current encampment and by the desire merely to change their circumstances.
The wanderings of Israel in the desert, then, have many meanings, and the great itinerary of Numbers 33 looks in many directions.
The publication and distribution of the JTS Commentary are made possible by a generous grant from Rita Dee and Harold (z"l) Hassenfeld.
Numbers 30:2–36:13
July 10, 2010 / 28 Tammuz 5770
This week's commentary was written by Dr. Alan Mintz, Chana Kekst Professor of Hebrew Literature in the Department of Jewish Literature, Jewish Theological Seminary.
The Torah is replete with lists of every kind: the generations before and after Noah, the enumeration of the tribes and their chieftains in the desert, the catalogs of forbidden foods, the inventories of priestly garments. The book of Numbers, which begins with a census, is especially true to its name. The beginning of chapter 33, which opens Parashat Mas'ei (the second of the double portions read in the synagogue this week), presents one of the grandest lists of all: the forty-two stations of Israel's wandering from Ramses in Egypt to the steppes of Moab on the eve of the entry into the Promised Land. Although we may feel that we have heard all of these place names in earlier weekly readings, the fact is that a significant number of these stations (verses 19–30) are mentioned here for the first time. The uniqueness of this list is indicated by the fact that Moses is specifically instructed to record the names in writing. In many synagogues, a special singsong melody used by the Torah reader also makes this passage unique.
Like many lists, the great wilderness itinerary of Numbers 33 marks a significant boundary. Until this point, the book of Numbers, true to its Hebrew name, Bemidbar, has rendered an exhaustive account of the events that befell Israel in its trek through the wilderness, right up to the present moment when the people stands poised to undertake the conquest of the Land. The remaining three chapters of Numbers look forward in time; they deal exclusively with matters that will become relevant after the conquest. The epic desert narrative has been concluded, and the comprehensive recapitulation of the stations of the journey marks an ending on the eve of a new beginning.
For the Rabbis of the midrash, the itinerary of Numbers 33 functions not only to draw a boundary but also to summarize the moral and spiritual meaning of the entire forty-year sojourn in the desert. Yet even though the Rabbis are joined in extracting a deeper meaning from the list of places, they are deeply divided in their essential attitudes to direction of that meaning.
On the one hand, the Rabbis explain that the "Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses: 'Write down the stages by which Israel journeyed in the wilderness, in order that they shall know what miracles I wrought for them.'" Barren of water and sustenance and rife with snakes, scorpions, and hostile marauding tribes, the desert is a place where life is possible only by virtue of God's protection and intervention. The chronicle of the forty-two stations then becomes a catalog of miracles and a record of an abundance of kindnesses. Even the number forty-two, which at first seems so large, emphasizes God's mercy. The first fourteen encampments, as Rashi points out, took place very early on, before the mission of the spies and the punishment of the forty years of wandering; and the last eight took place during the fortieth year. Thus there were only some twenty journeys during the great bulk of the sojourn; Israel was therefore not vexed by frequent forced marches. In fact, for the prophet Jeremiah, as quoted prominently in the Zikhronot liturgy in the Musaf service for Rosh Hashanah, the desert years are invoked nostalgically as a kind of prolonged honeymoon in the covenantal relations between God and Israel.
The opposite stance toward the desert years is presented by the Rabbis in a parable that likens the enumeration of the itinerary to the case of a king who has taken his son on a journey to cure him of his ills. "On their return journey his father began to recount all the stages, saying: 'Here we slept; here we cooled ourselves, here you had a headache.' So the Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses: 'Recount to them all the places where they provoked me.'" Indeed, this severe assessment needs little special pleading or elaboration because it is the principal experience that we have as readers of the Torah's stories of the desert: complaint, murmuring, disobedience, and rebellion over and over again.
An interesting attempt to make a homiletical connection between these conflicting interpretations of the list and the desert years it describes is undertaken by Samson Raphael Hirsch, the nineteenth-century German rabbi. Hirsch notes a reversed duplication in the second verse of the chapter: "Moses recorded the starting points of their various marches as directed by the Lord; their marches, by starting point, were as follows." In the beginning of the verse, the Hebrew reads motsa'eihem lemas'eihem (the starting point of their journeys), whereas the end of the verse has the same pair of terms in the opposite order, mas'eihem lemotsa'eihem. Although a critical reader might take this simply as an instance of chiasm, the abba pattern that the Torah text often delights in, Hirsch sees the reversal as fraught with meaning. The ordering in the first phrase describes how God regarded their travels. In the divine perspective, each starting point moved Israel forward in a journey that culminated in their accession to the Land and the fulfillment of God's promise. When the order is reversed, however, the travels are rendered from the point of view of the people, who also wanted to set forth on the next stage, but for different reasons. Rather than keeping their eyes on the high purpose of their journey, they were motivated to move on by boredom and dissatisfaction with their current encampment and by the desire merely to change their circumstances.
The wanderings of Israel in the desert, then, have many meanings, and the great itinerary of Numbers 33 looks in many directions.
The publication and distribution of the JTS Commentary are made possible by a generous grant from Rita Dee and Harold (z"l) Hassenfeld.
Thursday, June 24, 2010
Shabbat Shalom - June 25-6, 2010
HUKKAT/BALAK, 2000
by Rabbi Ed Feinstein
It's hot and smoggy. The cooling breeze of nightfall won't arrive for hours. Stuck in endless urban traffic, the radio news ticks off the day's toll of rape, murder and mayhem, governmental ineptitude and unfathomable moral lunacy. Welcome to the wasteland. Welcome to Bamidbar.In Exodus, the Torah presents images of God's saving power. With a mighty hand and outstretched arm is Israel rescued from slavery in Egypt . Leviticus lifts us to that pristine moment of holy oneness at Sinai, inviting us to the life of a holy nation, a kingdom of priests. "You will be holy as I, the Lord your God, am holy." Now we resume the journey. But before we can enter the Promised Land, we must cross through the wilderness, the midbar.
Twelve spies are sent to glimpse the Promised Land and bring back samples of its wonders. Instead, they return with fear, disenchantment and despair: "The land that we traversed and scouted is one that devours its inhabitants. All the people we saw were giants...We looked like grasshoppers to ourselves and so we must have looked to them." (Numbers 13:32-33)Envious of power and wealth, Moses' cousin Korah leads a rebellion to overthrown Moses. Deftly, Korah twists the words of the Covenantal promise: "They rallied against Moses and Aaron and said to them, You have gone too far! For all the community are holy, all of them, and the Lord is in their midst. Why do you raise yourselves above the Lords congregation?" (Numbers 16:3)In this week's portion, the blow comes closer to the heart: Miriam, the sister of Moses and voice of his song, dies. Aaron, Moses' brother, partner and the voice of his words, dies. The people whine for water. Out of rage and frustration, Moses defies God's instruction to speak to the rock. He smashes it with his rod. And then the dream dies. "Because you did not trust Me enough to affirm My sanctity in the sight of the Israelite people, therefore you shall not lead this congregation into the land that I have given them." (Numbers 20:12)
Bamidbar, Book of Numbers, offers a guided tour through the human wilderness -- the dark side of the human soul. Its stories are not of heroic triumph but of failure, dissension and conflict. Bamidbar shows us our shadow -- our fear, envy, despair, infidelity, and rage. As Leviticus lifts us up to holiness, Bamidbar parades before us our endless capacity for evil. We Americans quickly grow impatient with this sort of literature. We like our heroes in white and our villains in black. And we don't want to be reminded of our own evil. America , wrote novelist Henry James, is a hotel civilization. A hotel -- a room you leave sloppy and unkempt in the morning,returning in the evening to find it all neat and tidy. You never know, nor do you really care, how it got that way. You never face the messy dark side, the shadow. Instead, you move on. The most powerful myth in American culture is the myth of the frontier. "Go West, young man!" Go west, and escape the evil you've created. Go west, and start over, start fresh. Mobility is the American idea of freedom, and Americans are drawn to the lure of the road. "Everything good," wrote Emerson, "is on the highway." Walt Whitman sings the song of the open road. Jack Keroac takes us "On the Road." Crosby and Hope are On the Road. The generation of the 60's were Easy Riders. And Bruce Springsteen is "Born to Run."
At our own peril, teaches Bamidbar, do we ignore the dark side. The only way to the Promised Land is through the wilderness. Turn away from the shadow, turn away from our capacity to do evil, turn away from the encounter with our rage, fear, jealousy and despair, and we become trapped in that wilderness -- slaves to our own dark impulses. Our dreams turn into nightmares. Our inventions turn into monsters. Our families and communities become desolate wastelands. And we become strangers to ourselves.The trek is dangerous. What will sustain us through this wilderness? What will keep us from turning back? All we have is the story, the book. Moses has been here first. He found the way through to the Promised Land. And following him, we will too.
by Rabbi Ed Feinstein
It's hot and smoggy. The cooling breeze of nightfall won't arrive for hours. Stuck in endless urban traffic, the radio news ticks off the day's toll of rape, murder and mayhem, governmental ineptitude and unfathomable moral lunacy. Welcome to the wasteland. Welcome to Bamidbar.In Exodus, the Torah presents images of God's saving power. With a mighty hand and outstretched arm is Israel rescued from slavery in Egypt . Leviticus lifts us to that pristine moment of holy oneness at Sinai, inviting us to the life of a holy nation, a kingdom of priests. "You will be holy as I, the Lord your God, am holy." Now we resume the journey. But before we can enter the Promised Land, we must cross through the wilderness, the midbar.
Twelve spies are sent to glimpse the Promised Land and bring back samples of its wonders. Instead, they return with fear, disenchantment and despair: "The land that we traversed and scouted is one that devours its inhabitants. All the people we saw were giants...We looked like grasshoppers to ourselves and so we must have looked to them." (Numbers 13:32-33)Envious of power and wealth, Moses' cousin Korah leads a rebellion to overthrown Moses. Deftly, Korah twists the words of the Covenantal promise: "They rallied against Moses and Aaron and said to them, You have gone too far! For all the community are holy, all of them, and the Lord is in their midst. Why do you raise yourselves above the Lords congregation?" (Numbers 16:3)In this week's portion, the blow comes closer to the heart: Miriam, the sister of Moses and voice of his song, dies. Aaron, Moses' brother, partner and the voice of his words, dies. The people whine for water. Out of rage and frustration, Moses defies God's instruction to speak to the rock. He smashes it with his rod. And then the dream dies. "Because you did not trust Me enough to affirm My sanctity in the sight of the Israelite people, therefore you shall not lead this congregation into the land that I have given them." (Numbers 20:12)
Bamidbar, Book of Numbers, offers a guided tour through the human wilderness -- the dark side of the human soul. Its stories are not of heroic triumph but of failure, dissension and conflict. Bamidbar shows us our shadow -- our fear, envy, despair, infidelity, and rage. As Leviticus lifts us up to holiness, Bamidbar parades before us our endless capacity for evil. We Americans quickly grow impatient with this sort of literature. We like our heroes in white and our villains in black. And we don't want to be reminded of our own evil. America , wrote novelist Henry James, is a hotel civilization. A hotel -- a room you leave sloppy and unkempt in the morning,returning in the evening to find it all neat and tidy. You never know, nor do you really care, how it got that way. You never face the messy dark side, the shadow. Instead, you move on. The most powerful myth in American culture is the myth of the frontier. "Go West, young man!" Go west, and escape the evil you've created. Go west, and start over, start fresh. Mobility is the American idea of freedom, and Americans are drawn to the lure of the road. "Everything good," wrote Emerson, "is on the highway." Walt Whitman sings the song of the open road. Jack Keroac takes us "On the Road." Crosby and Hope are On the Road. The generation of the 60's were Easy Riders. And Bruce Springsteen is "Born to Run."
At our own peril, teaches Bamidbar, do we ignore the dark side. The only way to the Promised Land is through the wilderness. Turn away from the shadow, turn away from our capacity to do evil, turn away from the encounter with our rage, fear, jealousy and despair, and we become trapped in that wilderness -- slaves to our own dark impulses. Our dreams turn into nightmares. Our inventions turn into monsters. Our families and communities become desolate wastelands. And we become strangers to ourselves.The trek is dangerous. What will sustain us through this wilderness? What will keep us from turning back? All we have is the story, the book. Moses has been here first. He found the way through to the Promised Land. And following him, we will too.
Monday, March 8, 2010
Important message about knesset vote
This is something several colleagues in the Conservative movement have sent around for our immediate attention. Please take a moment and let your voice be heard!
Knesset Vote on Conversion
Knesset Vote on Conversion
Monday, February 1, 2010
Everyday Heroes
Here is a link to our inspiring friend, Michael Weitz.
http://www.dailynews.com/ci_14267600
Please take a moment to read the article and post your comments here.
http://www.dailynews.com/ci_14267600
Please take a moment to read the article and post your comments here.
Sunday, January 3, 2010
Farewell...for now
Day #11
For those returning to Los Angeles tonight, the stay in the Bedouin tent was a perfect way to get exhausted! We can’t say we slept through the night, especially with the winds blowing through our tent so vigorously. Some of us woke up to offer morning prayers in the picturesque and expansive desert landscape. Despite the cool winds, the words and gestures were an inspiring beginning to our final day in Israel.
Our final breakfast in Israel was as delicious as our first, bountiful arrays of cheeses, fruits and cereals. This morning we were treated to authentic Bedouin bread, plain and with Za’atar, the delicious spice with oregano, marjoram, sesame seeds, and some salt. There was also “Ribat Halav” or “Dulce de Leche” or “Caramel” spread on the table. YUMMMMY!
Our drive to Masada was short as we entered from the West and climbed the Roman Ramp to the top. Each time one visits Masada it seems like there are still incredible artifacts and stories to be discovered and revealed. Most notably, there has been a change in recent years with the use of Masada as a place to induct young soldiers into the military. For so many years, the brave heroism of the zealots and their incredible stand off with the Roman legions has been an inspiring way to dedicate oneself to service in the Army. However, the complete story is that the zealots killed themselves rather than succumb to the Romans, while the builders of the Ramp, for example, were Jewish slaves. The notion that suicide is not a heroic act has impressed the army and they no longer use the space for ceremonies. There was a ceremony taking place this morning in the synagogue there, however, A Bar Mitzvah of a young man on a Birthright trip! Our group spontaneously sang Siman Tov! Mazal Tov! to him and we offered him what VBS B’nai Mitzvah receive on their B’nai Mitzvah. Tzedakah boxes, kiddush cups, and of course the free year of USY! [Dani, our secular guide and professed anti-religionist commented he has been forced to conduct B’nai mitzvah in his capacity as a tour guide. We think we’re seeing him crack a little bit with us Conservative Jews, but he’d never tell!]
We all worked up a good sweat as we hiked down the snake path. The park was crowded with groups, Birthright, Israeli, and tour groups like ours. We could barely move down the path and it felt great to see so many people there.
After the night in the tent, and the hike up Masada, our visit to the Dead Sea was well needed and deserved. Floating in the Dead Sea is a heroic feat. If you didn’t know you had a slight scratch or cut somewhere on your body, the salty water would reveal it instantly! After a few minutes of braving the actual Dead Sea and the breezy winds at the shore, we all got smart and made our way to the heated pool indoors and luxuriated in the fresh water spa for the afternoon.
After cleaning up, we got on the bus and made our way back up to Jerusalem. Conversations turned to reflections on this incredible journey we’ve taken together and discussion and suggestions for future VBS trips was shared. We all learned a lot on this trip and know better how to plan a trip like this for next time.
We arrived in Jerusalem for just enough time to shop quickly and walk over to our restaurant for our final dinner at the Anna Ticho House. For 10 days we have nearly perfect weather without a drop of rain. The rain came down in our final hours in Jerusalem – giving new meaning to the concept that rain is ‘bracha’ or blessing. We were surely blessed to have such incredible weather throughout the trip!
At dinner, we went around and shared two thoughts on our experiences together. “What was one thing you are taking home with you from Israel?” and “What is one thing you are leaving behind?” Our reflections were sweet and grateful sharing that our time was absolutely unforgettable.
I remarked that I am leaving behind the bitter memories of 2001-2 and taking home a promising future for Israel. I also shared that I am taking home some tremendous qualities from the 14 participants in this pioneering journey. I learned wonderful qualities of care and concern, model parenting skills, and sensitivities to others’ needs. I learned when to speak and when to listen, and I learned that Israel can mean so many different things to each one of us. I finally shared that I believe I am leaving behind a little part of each person who participated in this trip, because I think our hearts were sown into the fabric of Israel a little more tightly and colorfully during this trip. I sincerely believed we were all transformed by this experience and I was honored to be present as those changes unfolded.
We are extremely grateful to Dani Slubski, our dynamic guide who truly made himself present and shared his wisdom with us freely throughout our 10 days together. We hope he will visit us in Los Angeles when he comes to visit his family here.
We are grateful for each other as we recognized that we all got along so well, that the children were extremely present and participated wonderfully. Our group ranged in age from 9 – 89 and we truly worked well together. Our deepest admiration goes to Ruth Markman, our 89 year old sage who braved the journey to travel with her rabbi. Even though she missed a few of the adventures along the way, she was appreciated by us all for her strength and generous spirit! Her strength became our strength and we hope to return with new resolve to keep Israel in our hearts and our minds for many years to come.
For those returning to Los Angeles tonight, the stay in the Bedouin tent was a perfect way to get exhausted! We can’t say we slept through the night, especially with the winds blowing through our tent so vigorously. Some of us woke up to offer morning prayers in the picturesque and expansive desert landscape. Despite the cool winds, the words and gestures were an inspiring beginning to our final day in Israel.
Our final breakfast in Israel was as delicious as our first, bountiful arrays of cheeses, fruits and cereals. This morning we were treated to authentic Bedouin bread, plain and with Za’atar, the delicious spice with oregano, marjoram, sesame seeds, and some salt. There was also “Ribat Halav” or “Dulce de Leche” or “Caramel” spread on the table. YUMMMMY!
Our drive to Masada was short as we entered from the West and climbed the Roman Ramp to the top. Each time one visits Masada it seems like there are still incredible artifacts and stories to be discovered and revealed. Most notably, there has been a change in recent years with the use of Masada as a place to induct young soldiers into the military. For so many years, the brave heroism of the zealots and their incredible stand off with the Roman legions has been an inspiring way to dedicate oneself to service in the Army. However, the complete story is that the zealots killed themselves rather than succumb to the Romans, while the builders of the Ramp, for example, were Jewish slaves. The notion that suicide is not a heroic act has impressed the army and they no longer use the space for ceremonies. There was a ceremony taking place this morning in the synagogue there, however, A Bar Mitzvah of a young man on a Birthright trip! Our group spontaneously sang Siman Tov! Mazal Tov! to him and we offered him what VBS B’nai Mitzvah receive on their B’nai Mitzvah. Tzedakah boxes, kiddush cups, and of course the free year of USY! [Dani, our secular guide and professed anti-religionist commented he has been forced to conduct B’nai mitzvah in his capacity as a tour guide. We think we’re seeing him crack a little bit with us Conservative Jews, but he’d never tell!]
We all worked up a good sweat as we hiked down the snake path. The park was crowded with groups, Birthright, Israeli, and tour groups like ours. We could barely move down the path and it felt great to see so many people there.
After the night in the tent, and the hike up Masada, our visit to the Dead Sea was well needed and deserved. Floating in the Dead Sea is a heroic feat. If you didn’t know you had a slight scratch or cut somewhere on your body, the salty water would reveal it instantly! After a few minutes of braving the actual Dead Sea and the breezy winds at the shore, we all got smart and made our way to the heated pool indoors and luxuriated in the fresh water spa for the afternoon.
After cleaning up, we got on the bus and made our way back up to Jerusalem. Conversations turned to reflections on this incredible journey we’ve taken together and discussion and suggestions for future VBS trips was shared. We all learned a lot on this trip and know better how to plan a trip like this for next time.
We arrived in Jerusalem for just enough time to shop quickly and walk over to our restaurant for our final dinner at the Anna Ticho House. For 10 days we have nearly perfect weather without a drop of rain. The rain came down in our final hours in Jerusalem – giving new meaning to the concept that rain is ‘bracha’ or blessing. We were surely blessed to have such incredible weather throughout the trip!
At dinner, we went around and shared two thoughts on our experiences together. “What was one thing you are taking home with you from Israel?” and “What is one thing you are leaving behind?” Our reflections were sweet and grateful sharing that our time was absolutely unforgettable.
I remarked that I am leaving behind the bitter memories of 2001-2 and taking home a promising future for Israel. I also shared that I am taking home some tremendous qualities from the 14 participants in this pioneering journey. I learned wonderful qualities of care and concern, model parenting skills, and sensitivities to others’ needs. I learned when to speak and when to listen, and I learned that Israel can mean so many different things to each one of us. I finally shared that I believe I am leaving behind a little part of each person who participated in this trip, because I think our hearts were sown into the fabric of Israel a little more tightly and colorfully during this trip. I sincerely believed we were all transformed by this experience and I was honored to be present as those changes unfolded.
We are extremely grateful to Dani Slubski, our dynamic guide who truly made himself present and shared his wisdom with us freely throughout our 10 days together. We hope he will visit us in Los Angeles when he comes to visit his family here.
We are grateful for each other as we recognized that we all got along so well, that the children were extremely present and participated wonderfully. Our group ranged in age from 9 – 89 and we truly worked well together. Our deepest admiration goes to Ruth Markman, our 89 year old sage who braved the journey to travel with her rabbi. Even though she missed a few of the adventures along the way, she was appreciated by us all for her strength and generous spirit! Her strength became our strength and we hope to return with new resolve to keep Israel in our hearts and our minds for many years to come.
Adventures in the Desert
Day #10
There is no doubt that Jerusalem is the heart of Israel. Besides being the most populated city, it is clear that what Jerusalem represents above all other cities in the country is its emotional, intellectual, and spiritual core. Sometimes it takes leaving a place to truly grasp how important its influence is on your mind and heart.
We packed up our luggage and bid farewell to Jerusalem for the night. The custom upon leaving Jerusalem is to recite the traveler’s prayer with a special insertion for returning to Jerusalem after a short period of time away. Our hearts were longing this place, but knowing we would return very soon was a comfort.
We made our way through the “Shfela” the lowlands between Jerusalem and the coast to the archeological site called Beit Guvrin. There we were met by the Archeological Seminars group, led by friend of VBS Ian Stern. We were given the opportunity to participate in a real archeological dig in one of the 170 cisterns uncovered in the hills of Beit Guvrin. This was certainly a highlight for the younger participants. Once we learned that someone discovered some gold earrings in one of the cisterns recently, the moms on the trip got excited too! We were also given a spelunking tour of one of the newly discovered area by winding through some very narrow places. Some of us weren’t sure if we were going to make it through some pretty tight spots, but we all made it and were pretty satisfied with our climbing skills too!
Back on the bus, we traveled toward Tel Aviv again to participate in a Mitzvah project. Like our visit to the Chagall windows and Yad L’Kashish, our visit to Table to Table (M’Shulchan l’Shulchan in Hebrew) was way of contributing to Israel instead of being passive observers. www.tabletotable.org.il
Table to Table began as an organization collecting food that wasn’t served at parties or celebrations and bringing the meals to shelters and places where those in need to eat. It has since evolved into a major volunteer effort where acres of produce is grown and picked by volunteers to feed the thousands of needy children daily. The most recent statistic is that 1 in 4 children is under nourished in Israel, up from a 1 in 5 statistic of a few years ago. We were given the chance to pick some fresh Valencia oranges that would be taken to local shelters to help the hungry and needy directly. Even though we only had about an hour to pick, each piece of fruit would make a difference in the life and health of those in need. Even though we performed this mitzvah lishma (for its own sake) the organization expressed their appreciation by giving us some T-Shirts.
We began making our way south to the Negev for our Bedouin adventure at K’far HaNokdim. Just outside the city of Arad in the southern Judean desert – our destination is like the Hilton Hotels of Bedouin tents. It’s hard to say we were roughing it when our tent was supplied with comfortable pads, sleeping bags, clean sheets, heating, electricity, and yes – a hot water pot for tea and two different kinds of coffee! We arrived just in time for our camel ride (watch out for the dramatic dismount!) and we greeted by the Bedouin man who poured us tea and told us the story of who the Bedouin are. Dani, our guide, translated his Hebrew for the group. We realized there was a bit of editorializing when the Bedouin man was explaining the current practice of polygamy. The Bedouin man was explaining having multiple wives was preferable to Western cultural values and used former president Bill Clinton as an example. We all heard Bill Clinton’s name, but when Dani translated he very briefly explained that the Bedouin feel multiple marriages is a preferred way of life. Then he turned his head aside and shook his head in tacit disagreement! We all laughed at his reaction knowing he was a bit uncomfortable with the concept.
We all felt close enough to sleep together in the same tent considering we had been traveling together now for 10 days. After we adjusted our beds and stretch out comfortably and confirming that the loudest snorer would get placed outside the tent, we all quietly drifted off, with the kids turning out the lights after the parents. In case we thought tent living like this would be as luxurious as this, the wind picked up in the middle of the night shaking our tent and causing the flaps to beat forcefully against the tent. Poor Cheryl was closest to the edge of the tent but was smart enough to have ear plugs to dull the brunt of the noise.
[CONTINUED on Day 11]
There is no doubt that Jerusalem is the heart of Israel. Besides being the most populated city, it is clear that what Jerusalem represents above all other cities in the country is its emotional, intellectual, and spiritual core. Sometimes it takes leaving a place to truly grasp how important its influence is on your mind and heart.
We packed up our luggage and bid farewell to Jerusalem for the night. The custom upon leaving Jerusalem is to recite the traveler’s prayer with a special insertion for returning to Jerusalem after a short period of time away. Our hearts were longing this place, but knowing we would return very soon was a comfort.
We made our way through the “Shfela” the lowlands between Jerusalem and the coast to the archeological site called Beit Guvrin. There we were met by the Archeological Seminars group, led by friend of VBS Ian Stern. We were given the opportunity to participate in a real archeological dig in one of the 170 cisterns uncovered in the hills of Beit Guvrin. This was certainly a highlight for the younger participants. Once we learned that someone discovered some gold earrings in one of the cisterns recently, the moms on the trip got excited too! We were also given a spelunking tour of one of the newly discovered area by winding through some very narrow places. Some of us weren’t sure if we were going to make it through some pretty tight spots, but we all made it and were pretty satisfied with our climbing skills too!
Back on the bus, we traveled toward Tel Aviv again to participate in a Mitzvah project. Like our visit to the Chagall windows and Yad L’Kashish, our visit to Table to Table (M’Shulchan l’Shulchan in Hebrew) was way of contributing to Israel instead of being passive observers. www.tabletotable.org.il
Table to Table began as an organization collecting food that wasn’t served at parties or celebrations and bringing the meals to shelters and places where those in need to eat. It has since evolved into a major volunteer effort where acres of produce is grown and picked by volunteers to feed the thousands of needy children daily. The most recent statistic is that 1 in 4 children is under nourished in Israel, up from a 1 in 5 statistic of a few years ago. We were given the chance to pick some fresh Valencia oranges that would be taken to local shelters to help the hungry and needy directly. Even though we only had about an hour to pick, each piece of fruit would make a difference in the life and health of those in need. Even though we performed this mitzvah lishma (for its own sake) the organization expressed their appreciation by giving us some T-Shirts.
We began making our way south to the Negev for our Bedouin adventure at K’far HaNokdim. Just outside the city of Arad in the southern Judean desert – our destination is like the Hilton Hotels of Bedouin tents. It’s hard to say we were roughing it when our tent was supplied with comfortable pads, sleeping bags, clean sheets, heating, electricity, and yes – a hot water pot for tea and two different kinds of coffee! We arrived just in time for our camel ride (watch out for the dramatic dismount!) and we greeted by the Bedouin man who poured us tea and told us the story of who the Bedouin are. Dani, our guide, translated his Hebrew for the group. We realized there was a bit of editorializing when the Bedouin man was explaining the current practice of polygamy. The Bedouin man was explaining having multiple wives was preferable to Western cultural values and used former president Bill Clinton as an example. We all heard Bill Clinton’s name, but when Dani translated he very briefly explained that the Bedouin feel multiple marriages is a preferred way of life. Then he turned his head aside and shook his head in tacit disagreement! We all laughed at his reaction knowing he was a bit uncomfortable with the concept.
We all felt close enough to sleep together in the same tent considering we had been traveling together now for 10 days. After we adjusted our beds and stretch out comfortably and confirming that the loudest snorer would get placed outside the tent, we all quietly drifted off, with the kids turning out the lights after the parents. In case we thought tent living like this would be as luxurious as this, the wind picked up in the middle of the night shaking our tent and causing the flaps to beat forcefully against the tent. Poor Cheryl was closest to the edge of the tent but was smart enough to have ear plugs to dull the brunt of the noise.
[CONTINUED on Day 11]
"If the Messiah is coming, plant the tree first"
Day #9
[Thank you all for understanding these posts now come after we’ve returned. Due to technical difficulties and the pace of our itinerary, I was not able to post these reflections in time. Keep reading, though - it gets better!]
Today we began with our visit to Yad Vashem. The museum was updated in 2005 so this was a first time experience for all of us. While we waited for our appointed time to enter the museum we walked around some of the monuments including the hall of the eternal flame. There we memorialized our experience with the El Maley Rachamim prayer as we looked on the floor at the names of the death camps etched into stone. The children’s memorial remains the most touching monument for the 1.5 million children who lives were cut down by the Nazi perpetrators. Standing outside the memorial there were butterflies. We read the poem, “I never saw another butterfly,” and captured the essence of our purpose at Yad Vashem – we come to remember because we are still alive and must bear witness.
The museum itself is a large and long triangular structure where the majority of the museum is angled downward until the final display that leads you back up again. You are directed through a very specific experience, beginning with the Nazis rise to power to the records and testimonials of survivors, and culminated in a display of righteous gentiles. The final room is a reflective pool and massive cone portraying the vibrant lives of the victims and the pool to reflect our own faces to remind us that we could have been victims too. It is an equally powerful image to stand in a circular room lined with shelves of memory books – each book a record of one victim’s life. While the shelves are still quite empty, 2 million [number of known victims to date] is an impressive number to behold.
We concluded our visit with a meditation and recitation of Kaddish. We sang Oseh Shalom overlooking the Judean hills together for a touching moment in reverence and loving memory of our ancestors who suffered at the hands of the Nazis and the promise to never forget was etched in our memories anew.
We left Yad Vashem for Har Herzl, the Israeli national cemetery. Walking through the gardens and paying our respects to the leaders of the State was awe-inspiring. We just touched the surface of the soldier’s cemetery where thousands of young men and women lay in service to the Jewish people’s quest for peace, but clearly recognized how each and every individual whose grave is present there is significant and not forgotten. We did not enter the new museum there, but we heard it is a must see….next time!
Juxtaposing Yad Vashem and Har Herzl seemed heavy at first, but we culminated our experience by planting trees in the Aminadav forest on the outskirts of the Judean Hills. We were greeted by the eccentric American expatriate Kabbalistic nature guy (What was his name? It was his large,, rainbow colored kippah, scraggly beard and guitar that we remember) who gave us a choice of rosemary, almond trees, and “Ayla” trees to plant. We all found our way to the area near the road and nurtured our little saplings into the ground. We gathered as a group on the roadside and heard a story told by Julia Dick about the man who blessed the tree who had everything – fruit, shade, leaves, etc. – with the blessing that the trees offspring should be just like it. After visiting the Holocaust memorial and the cemetery for Israel’s fallen, our tree planting was a validation that we are thriving and growing in the Land! Am Yisrael Chai!
After a brief visit to the Knesset and a view of the impressive Supreme court building from the outside, we returned to the hotel for a few hours of free time and shopping.
Due to the immense popularity of the Western Wall tunnels museum we were scheduled to visit tonight at 9:00 p.m. Even though we were absolutely tired and had traveled enough by this time, the tunnels museum was completely energizing. Besides the gigantic rock in the Western Wall that you first see when you enter into the museum, the latest innovation are some expertly placed flat screen TV’s to watch video while you follow the tunnels that parallel the Western Wall. The video is a short demonstration of how they believe the workers could move such large rocks into place. As we walked through the narrow passageways, we recalled the moving legend that justifies why the Western Wall and these great stones in particular are still relevant today. Legend has it that that poorest of the workers were the ones to build the Western Wall, especially the foundational stones that are buried beneath the ground. Because they could not afford to hire workers to build the walls for them, it was through their toil and love that the wall was built. When the Temple was destroyed, the angels protected the efforts of the poor workers and prevented their stones from being destroyed. Our day was filled with acts of Hesed, from bearing witness to planting trees, giving great honor to the toils of ancestors and seeing their dreams fulfilled.
[Thank you all for understanding these posts now come after we’ve returned. Due to technical difficulties and the pace of our itinerary, I was not able to post these reflections in time. Keep reading, though - it gets better!]
Today we began with our visit to Yad Vashem. The museum was updated in 2005 so this was a first time experience for all of us. While we waited for our appointed time to enter the museum we walked around some of the monuments including the hall of the eternal flame. There we memorialized our experience with the El Maley Rachamim prayer as we looked on the floor at the names of the death camps etched into stone. The children’s memorial remains the most touching monument for the 1.5 million children who lives were cut down by the Nazi perpetrators. Standing outside the memorial there were butterflies. We read the poem, “I never saw another butterfly,” and captured the essence of our purpose at Yad Vashem – we come to remember because we are still alive and must bear witness.
The museum itself is a large and long triangular structure where the majority of the museum is angled downward until the final display that leads you back up again. You are directed through a very specific experience, beginning with the Nazis rise to power to the records and testimonials of survivors, and culminated in a display of righteous gentiles. The final room is a reflective pool and massive cone portraying the vibrant lives of the victims and the pool to reflect our own faces to remind us that we could have been victims too. It is an equally powerful image to stand in a circular room lined with shelves of memory books – each book a record of one victim’s life. While the shelves are still quite empty, 2 million [number of known victims to date] is an impressive number to behold.
We concluded our visit with a meditation and recitation of Kaddish. We sang Oseh Shalom overlooking the Judean hills together for a touching moment in reverence and loving memory of our ancestors who suffered at the hands of the Nazis and the promise to never forget was etched in our memories anew.
We left Yad Vashem for Har Herzl, the Israeli national cemetery. Walking through the gardens and paying our respects to the leaders of the State was awe-inspiring. We just touched the surface of the soldier’s cemetery where thousands of young men and women lay in service to the Jewish people’s quest for peace, but clearly recognized how each and every individual whose grave is present there is significant and not forgotten. We did not enter the new museum there, but we heard it is a must see….next time!
Juxtaposing Yad Vashem and Har Herzl seemed heavy at first, but we culminated our experience by planting trees in the Aminadav forest on the outskirts of the Judean Hills. We were greeted by the eccentric American expatriate Kabbalistic nature guy (What was his name? It was his large,, rainbow colored kippah, scraggly beard and guitar that we remember) who gave us a choice of rosemary, almond trees, and “Ayla” trees to plant. We all found our way to the area near the road and nurtured our little saplings into the ground. We gathered as a group on the roadside and heard a story told by Julia Dick about the man who blessed the tree who had everything – fruit, shade, leaves, etc. – with the blessing that the trees offspring should be just like it. After visiting the Holocaust memorial and the cemetery for Israel’s fallen, our tree planting was a validation that we are thriving and growing in the Land! Am Yisrael Chai!
After a brief visit to the Knesset and a view of the impressive Supreme court building from the outside, we returned to the hotel for a few hours of free time and shopping.
Due to the immense popularity of the Western Wall tunnels museum we were scheduled to visit tonight at 9:00 p.m. Even though we were absolutely tired and had traveled enough by this time, the tunnels museum was completely energizing. Besides the gigantic rock in the Western Wall that you first see when you enter into the museum, the latest innovation are some expertly placed flat screen TV’s to watch video while you follow the tunnels that parallel the Western Wall. The video is a short demonstration of how they believe the workers could move such large rocks into place. As we walked through the narrow passageways, we recalled the moving legend that justifies why the Western Wall and these great stones in particular are still relevant today. Legend has it that that poorest of the workers were the ones to build the Western Wall, especially the foundational stones that are buried beneath the ground. Because they could not afford to hire workers to build the walls for them, it was through their toil and love that the wall was built. When the Temple was destroyed, the angels protected the efforts of the poor workers and prevented their stones from being destroyed. Our day was filled with acts of Hesed, from bearing witness to planting trees, giving great honor to the toils of ancestors and seeing their dreams fulfilled.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)