Friday, June 3, 2011

Shabbat Shalom--June 3-4, 2011

Nasso-When Torah Must be Changed
Rabbi Paul Steinberg

The Torah doesn’t always offer us such wonderful models of the gender roles, nor does it offer many model relationships between men and women. Perhaps, however, today’s society doesn’t really, either. The Torah describes a patriarchal society where men “own” their wives. I just can’t relate to that. But I am also struggling to relate to the gender divisions of men and women today, particularly with men and women in their 20’s and 30’s.

Let’s start with today and work our way back to looking at the Torah.

When teenage boys watch movies today, they see a cadre of common male role models, including caricatures often played by Adam Sandler, Seth Rogen, Will Ferrel, and Jonah Hill. The reason teenage boys love watching them is because these grown men are actually just like them. The most important things to these guys are hanging with their buddies, beer, playing Halo on PlayStation, action flicks, and their subscription to Maxim Magazine. This Sandler-Rogen type is between 21-35 years old, they’re unmarried, and are still figuring out their careers. They may not be necessarily lazy or unintelligent, they’re just in no rush to grow up.

For girls, the type of women to watch for are... well, picture Carrie, Miranda, Charlotte and Samantha from Sex and the City. These are upwardly mobile, urban professionals, and in the case of Sex and the City, they boast of a columnist, a Harvard law school graduated lawyer, a director of an art gallery, and an independent PR executive. This is likely to be the most educated and successful group of women ever portrayed! Like their male counterparts, this female demographic is also generally unmarried, but their “biological clocks” are ticking. While the men can wait until their 40’s to marry and have kids, women can’t.

In her book, Manning Up, Kay Mymowitz identifies this new 21st century demographic as “pre-adults.” She specifically calls the men “child-men.” The existence of pre-adults for Mymowitz is a result of economics. Although she believes there are differences between men and women, this emerging life stage is not about hormones or brain chemistry. She explains that this is a manifestation of what economists call the “knowledge economy” wherein people go to university more, they move from city to city more, and they marry later. The average age of marriage in 1950 for men was 22.8 and for women 20.3, compared with 28.4 for men and 26.5 for women today (American Jews tend to marry even later than the national average). Moreover, the job market has created new jobs that are attractive to women at least as much as men in areas including technology, public relations and marketing, and health and fitness.

Now, contrasting the complexity and challenge of the foregoing discussion on family, marriage, and career as it pertains to gender here in America in the 21st century, it is utterly inane and practically inconceivable to seriously consider and regard the selection from this week’s Torah portion, which discusses the woman accused of infidelity to her husband (Num. 5:11-31). The ritual of the sotah (literally “deviant woman”) describes a jealous husband who accuses his wife of adultery. He takes her to the local priest where she is stripped and forced to drink a bitter potion. Along with incantations and sacrifices, the priest declares that if she is guilty, a spell will enter her body, “causing the belly to distend and the thigh to sag” (Num. 5:22). If she is innocent, she will go free.

The Rabbis of the Mishnah extrapolate and detail this procedure, leading to a strange justification for women to study Torah: “Ben Azzai infers that it is a man’s duty to teach his daughter Torah so that if she must drink [the sotah waters because she is an accused adulterer] she should know that merit will keep her punishment on hold.” (Mishnah, Sotah 3:4). Of all of the reasons to teach my three daughters Torah, I must confess that concern over any of them becoming a sotah and enduring this rite is not among them.

The Mishnah (Sotah 3:4) continues:
Rabbi Eliezer says: “If any man teaches his daughter Torah it is as though he taught her lewdness [tiflot].” Rabbi Yehoshua says: “A woman prefers one measure of lewdness to nine measures of chastity” [i.e., a wife would prefer more sex and less income over more income and less sex].

Interestingly, this Rabbinic stream of consciousness leads to the majority acceptance of Rabbi Eliezer’s position, namely that it is prohibited to teach girls Torah on the basis of illicit sexual indiscretion. “Torah” here was later interpreted as Talmud (specifically the Gemara), which continues to remain prohibited to girls for study in many Jewish circles.

As I study this source and I consider the issues Mymowitz raises about the real gender, family, and demographic concerns facing us in the 21st century, I cannot help but to think that the Rabbis were simply living in a different world. What the Rabbis express in Jewish law and what they believed to be the will of God concerning men and women is simply not what I believe or could accept. This may have been an acceptable line of thinking for our Rabbis then, but it’s wrong and unhelpful for us today.

Despite the dissonance between the contemporary study of family and gender and the concept of gender and relationships exemplified in the Torah and Mishnah, I still maintain that the study of Torah, especially study for its own sake, is among the highest spiritual practices available. I also maintain that no text is off limits, including this one about the sotah ritual. We must not be blind, however, to the fact that people authored our sacred texts from a particular time and place. Those who wrote these and other texts that are so obviously irrelevant today were undoubtedly wise. Much of what they taught is universally and eternally true, and… they also got a few things wrong.

Study of sacred texts is intended to be mind-opening, so that when we look at a text and sincerely question it, we see that the truth, which is universal and eternal, is held within those manifold questions that the texts raise. That is to say, the sotah text – no matter how alien it appears at first glance – is really asking deep questions about the relationship between husbands and wives: How do we express the pain of jealousy? How do we engage our spouses and community when we suspect them of adultery? What kind of strain does this put on a family or community and how do we collectively reconcile and resolve it? The sotah text also asks questions of the relationship between parents, children, and gender differences: Should parents have different academic or professional expectations for sons and daughters? How do parents themselves acquiesce to the cultural gender stereotypes for their own children? Should boys and girls be reared differently and to what ends?

The truth is that Mymowitz is asking some of these same questions regarding gender and family. She, like the ancient texts, is merely viewing these questions from her own time and place and with the cultural assumptions and tools accessible to her, namely the media and scientific method. She adds her own conceptions to the layers upon layers of scholars that have asked if there should be gender roles and if so what they should be for a healthy society. Mymowitz proves that answers to the same questions will change for each generation, just as it has with regard to women in the professional world. And frankly, sometimes, the answer to such questions simply must change; if the Torah is to remain relevant, there are times when a new Torah must heal the old Torah. In the end, however, Judaism espouses that the truth is ultimately in the asking, questioning assumptions, comparing and contrasting, analyzing, and asking again: “Turn it, turn it for everything is in it” (Mishnah, Avot 5:22).

Shabbat Shalom

No comments:

Post a Comment