BIBILICAL LIBERTY
Rabbi Noah Zvi Farkas
Freedom! Every Passover for thousands of years Jews have gathered around dining room tables, in synagogue ballrooms, in ghetto basements, and in frontline bunkers to celebrate our liberation from Egypt. From what I remember, the Passover seder integrates the international Jewish community – it is practiced by more Jews than any other mitzvah. But what is this liberty that we speak of? When we raise our wine glasses and toast to freedom, what exactly are we praising God for?
There are two great narratives of liberty that have engaged in a kind of philosophical wrestling match with each other over the course of our people’s long history and our nation’s shorter one. The first, as the philosopher Isaiah Berlin understands it, is called, “negative liberty.” Simply put, negative liberty is freedom from interference. As Berlin writes, “The fundamental sense of freedom is freedom from chains, from imprisonment, and from enslavement by others.” The second idea of liberty is called “positive liberty.” It is the freedom to grow and prosper, find fulfillment, and a flourishing life. On the face of it, freedom from interference and freedom to prosper might not seem so far apart. But when given over to communal structures and how we decide to shape our community, negative liberty and positive liberty lead us in very different directions.
Negative liberty gives energy to the idea that each one of us carries certain natural rights that must not be impugned by others. Negative liberty originates inside each one of us. Thoughts cannot be compelled, character cannot be minted. Even if we are enslaved to others' political will, it is the liberty of the mind that is freedom’s beginning. Biblically, we find root of this idea in the Exodus story. After 400 years of oppression, the Israelite slaves first freed their minds and looked to wider horizons of human living. Then they were able to finally see the disconnect between the way they lived as slaves and the way they could live as free people. The groaning was heard by God, who took note of this primal call for freedom and reached out the God’s mighty hand to begin the Exodus.
Beyond the machinations of the mind, it is in our acts of will in which negative liberty accrues true force and celebration. “Remember this day, on which you went free from Egypt, the house of bondage, how the LORD freed you from it with a mighty hand...You go free on this day, in the month of Aviv.” (Exodus 13:5) In the opening moments of liberation, the Israelites understood freedom in its rawest form – as freedom from oppression. After the Exodus, negative liberty normalizes in as value in biblical law. For example, debtors cannot be stripped of the shirts off their backs, and each one of us has an inalienable right to food and clothing.
Given its head, however, negative liberty can affirm too strongly the idea of rugged individualism. “Don’t tread on me” can easily become “don’t bother me.” An understanding of this sort of libertarianism leads us precisely to the type of virtue the rabbis understand as the virtue of Sodom, “What’s mine is mine and what’s yours is yours.” (Avot 5:10). Like the character of Noah, if we affirm liberty only as freedom from interference, our disposition situates ourselves alone in a world flooded with “others” of whom we have no real concern.
On the other side of the spectrum is positive liberty. The freedom to prosper entails a different sort of communal expectation than simply a freedom from interference. Positive liberty looks to wider goals or ideals than negative liberty. Positive liberty pursues ends like human fulfillment, societal welfare, and moral perfection. If each of us has the right to prosper freely, then each of us must create a society that allows for everyone to pursue those rights. As the rabbis say, each one of us has, “a share in the world to come.” In the Torah, human flourishing overrides even the most strident of individuals including the injunction against covetous behavior (Exodus 20:12) the requirement of safe harbor for guests (Genesis 19), the exceptions to conscription into the army (Deuteronomy 24:5), and denial of permanent ownership over property or others (Leviticus Ch. 25). Micah, understands positive liberty in the broadest of terms: “He has told, you O human, what is good, And what the LORD requires of you: Only to do justice and to love goodness and to walk modestly with your God.” (Micah 6:8)
But positive liberty given its teeth can also lead to disaster. If the conventions used to secure the human good for all are strengthened qua convention, then the resultant society limits freedom instead of promoting it. The most dastardly examples of positive liberty are found in political systems that find their power in the enslavement to a single idea of the human good where the good for the many trumps any notion of individual choice. As Jews, we are rightly chary of those who wish to choose for us our fate.
Both negative and positive liberty animates our Torah and our sense of Judaism. Moreover, these notions of freedom stand at the heart of the choices set before us as Americans. In the coming weeks and months, our nation will embark on a policy discussion that will shape the texture and timbre of our society. How do we understand our freedom as individuals? On one side of the debate the central question is how can the government have the right to proscribe my liberties for the sake of another’s? On the other side, the central question is how could it not? It is these questions that will rub one type of liberty against the other on the threshing-floor of the House and Senate, across tables in lunchrooms and boardrooms, and on porches and in family rooms across the country.
I believe, however, the question is not of kind, but of degree. Our sacred texts speak of both, because we need both. Positive liberty cannot alienate negative rights and negative liberty is fascicle without positive rights. The rabbis understood the interplay between these ideas of cherut, freedom, as engraved into the very tablets that stand at the center of our religion as a covenanted people: “The Tablets of the Law are the work of God, engraved upon the stones. (Exodus. 32:16) Read not charut [engraved] but cherut, [freedom]. To which one rabbi believes it means freedom from oppression, and another takes it to mean freedom to live. At which all the rabbis agreed that freedom at the very least means freedom from suffering. As we move into the final days of Passover we realize with all too much clarity that the answers to the most important questions, like, “What does it mean to be free?,” yield complex answers. Yet, as we all know, there is no end to the questions set before us on Passover. It is in the questions that we find the meaning and direction that will shape our lives and our children’s lives in the years to come.
Shabbat Shalom
Chag Sameach
Friday, April 22, 2011
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment